Reviews

The Cavendish Home for Boys and Girls by Claire Legrand, Sarah Watts

sparklelys's review against another edition

Go to review page

Creepy. And unresolved creepy.

hello_sunshine's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

What a creepy story! Totally grossed me out in places, but really well-written. Would be perfect for those beyond typical Chiller stuff, but not quite ready for Stephen King. Gaiman qualities abound- would recommend to Coraline fans or those who enjoy Tim Burton.

mlejmeyer's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A strange, dark tale...I enjoyed this and especially the nosy, self-righteous, "practically perfect" narrator of Victoria. I wanted just a bit more at the end of the book, but I loved the first 3/4 of the book. Creepy in a Coraline-esque sort of way.

hudsonpeeps's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

This book is so odd. I didn't think it was spooky at all - just weird. It reminded me a lot of The Mysterious Benedict Society but without much of a story.

melindavan's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

First, this is a middle grade book. It’s meant for 10 years old and up. I have to say, if I had read this when I was 10 I would have fallen in love, read it 50 times, and slept with it by my pillow. As an adult, I didn’t sleep with it. But…

This is a fascinating, twisted, bizarre, spooky, awesome story! I know, I shouldn’t have been reading it because I’m all grown up but sometimes it’s nice to read something that relaxes your brain and still provides an escape with interesting things to think about and a mystery to solve. I’m still shaking my head over the pure imagination wrapped up in this book. And the illustrations! Truly awesome, even on the Kindle. Just look at the cover. There’s more of them inside, and each one is a treat.

There’s creepy crawly things, a frightening caretaker, spooky evil headmistress, and an entire town under some sort of spell. And only one girl can fix the situation. Victoria. Do you doubt she’ll be successful with a name like that? Victoria, for Victory.

If you’re a parent, this one is great for your kids. It provides some talking points about being yourself, standing out in a crowd, letting people be who they are, going against the status quo, while at the same time touting the virtues of being a good girl (or boy). All while being entertaining as heck, especially for those who love the spooky or weird happenings stories. Halloween is right around the corner, y’all. This will definitely set the mood.

If you’re an adult looking for a fast, fun read, check this out. It’ll take you back to childhood. Like James and the Giant Peach, or Willy Wonka, it’ll have you remembering those nights you spent under the covers with a flashlight, reading into the early hours of the morning. You did that, right? I’m not the only one….I can’t be!

Go ahead, be a kid!

christajls's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This review originally posted at More Than Just Magic

If Stephen King wrote for children I imagine it would turn out a little something like this.

Victoria is a very special little girl. She likes everything a certain way and she’s not afraid to say so. She’s not your typical heroine – she’s not the most popular or the nicest or anything like that. She’s just a slightly bossy, head strong twelve year old who knows what she wants. And I think that is what makes her so admirable. I mean really, who is so sure of themself at that age? Not me. But I loved her confidence nd dedication.

I also loved that even though she comes off a little self absorbed she still stops at nothing to save her friend, Lawrence, when he goes missing. A good head on her shoulders AND brave. It’s a pretty unstoppable combination. She’s someone you would want to follow into battle. Someone you always want in your corner. No matter what the house threw at her, she found a way to deal.

Speaking of the house – it was a character in its own right. I love when locations become characters. It felt so real it was like I could reach out and touch it. Because the thing about The Cavendish Home is that it’s not just a collection of boards and nails. It reacts to what’s happening in and around it and it is always a little bit different. I think this was a brilliant concept and an incredibly imaginative one. When all is said and done it was the house that really sold the book for me.

The Cavendish Home For Boys and Girls is a middle grade novel with grim but sharp humour. There’s elements of this story that are very reminiscent of The Witches by Roald Dahl. Remember how disturbed you felt when they were describing what the witches really looked like – you know all bald with the long fingernails and what not? Well that same creepy, disturbing feeling is present while reading this book. Claire Legrand, expertly uses all of those things that give us the creepy crawlies. The bugs especially. *shivers* I’m going to have bad dreams forever about those bugs.

Recommendation: This is a wonderfully creepy and brilliant book filled with an important message about being unique and that “perfect” isn’t always “perfect.” It’s a book that assumes its readers are smart and responds accordingly. An absolutely delightful read for middle grade readers and older readers who love Roald Dahl and Neil Gaiman.

brandypainter's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Originally posted here at Random Musings of a Bibliophile.

The Cavendish Home for Boys and Girls by Claire Legrand is one of those books that I added to my TBR, but felt no urgency to read. Then one day I saw it on display at the library and thought: now's as good a time as any. But soon I was swamped with other things to read and I may have returned it unread if Shelver hadn't read it and started talking about how wonderful it is. So I kept it around, renewed it twice, and finally found the time to read it two days before it was due back. Yes. It is one of those reads that had me wanting to smack myself for not reading it sooner.

Victoria is not a likeable little girl. She was probably even less likeable to me due to the cringe-worthy way she had of reminding me of the more unpleasant aspects of my personality. Still, I love a character you can't help but like despite their unlikeableness, and Victoria is certainly one of those. She is an ambitious type-A perfectionist, who wants to conform the world and people around her to her standards. She is also a questioner though, and this is what makes her a hero. She will not settle for easy answers. She must know the truth at all costs. Lawrence, on the other hand, is one of those boys who is brilliant in a lazy way. (And we all know how much I love those.) He is exactly the sort of boy Victoria needs in her life. One who will disrupt her order, and make her see that it's okay to laugh too loudly and not always be perfect. Which is why her life is devastated when he disappears. Their dynamic is a special one, familiar to be sure, but special. I enjoy how Legrand made it complicated the way boy/girl friendships are when your 12. It was wonderful how they needed both of their strengths to win the day too.


The plot and setting of the book dazzled me the most though, and it isn't every day that I say that. This book is creepy. The wrongness of the town, the home, and Mrs. Cavendish seeps into every word and page leaving the reader feel an impending sense of doom the further in you get. The children make some seriously disturbing discoveries about what goes down in that house too. And then there are the bugs. Shudder. Yet it manages to maintain a humorous balance that keeps it from being too outright horrifying. As I was reading I couldn't help but think of the kids I know who would love it and imagine their reactions. It is going to be a hit with my students I'm sure. In many ways it reminds me of Roald Dahl minus a lot of the issues I find problematic with his books. I also think it's better written.


Anyone who enjoys being entertained with creepy (and slightly gross) horror that's not too over the top who love this book. I sure did.

xxfelixxreads's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark mysterious sad tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

Eine echt gute Gruselgeschichte aber verstörend dass es ein Kinderbuch ist

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

bookgirl4ever's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Victoria is straight-laced, responsible, and on track to be perfect, just like her parents. As a kid she took under wing Lawrence who was the opposite to see if she could help him improve. What began as a project turned into an unlikely friendship. Then Lawrence and some other classmates of Victorias disappear and the grownups don't seem to care. Her last resort is to venture onto the grounds of the Cavendish Home for Boys and Girls, a gated school for orphans at the end of the road. While there she receive a secret note from a resident that says, "Help me!" Convinced that the Cavendish home has something to do with the disappearances and Alice Cavendish is hiding something, Victoria investigates further and finds a creepy, somewhat haunted house that is holding children from many generations past hostage in the attempt to rehabilitate them from degenerates to perfection.

Creepy and dark, I didn't like the way this book ended. Also it took over half the book to get past the set up. Way too long in my opinion.

Middle school.

lesdel70's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This book will not disappoint, though it was 100% not what I expected. It’s The Mysterious Benedict Society gone down to a dark, sinister, and twisted realm. I loved it. Not going to reveal anything. Just. Read. It.