Scan barcode
theseventhl's review
3.0
I can't say I was blown away by Marjane Satrapi's latest graphic novel, but I was entertained by it. The art is rather lovely and stylish, and the story rather intriguing, even if some of the elements were problematic (like the ugly sister and the issue of slavery being dealt with so flippantly - oh, and the awkward icky behavior of Rose's main love interest). Rose was a very strong, capable heroine whom I loved reading about. I hope Satrapi's next novel is also in his style, it really fits her prose.
Although let's be fair: will anything ever measure up to Persepolis? Well, it's true. You can't really get more powerful a story than Satrapi's own life in Iran.
Although let's be fair: will anything ever measure up to Persepolis? Well, it's true. You can't really get more powerful a story than Satrapi's own life in Iran.
jwinchell's review
2.0
Yeah, not sure what's going on here. Is Satrapi weaving a folktale? Is she giving us a parable for how to appreciate life? It read super fast and the illustrations definitely enhanced the story, but I'm just not sure what any reader is supposed to get out of it.
laefe's review against another edition
4.0
"La vita non è che un sospiro."
Marjane Satrapi, l'autrice di Persepolis, che si dà al racconto fiabesco, ma con il suo solito stile personalissimo... e forse in quest'opera più che in altre c'è il riflesso della sua persona: nata in Iran, diventata adulta in Francia. Così questa fiaba ricorda per molti versi quelle europee, ma con tinte e risvolti a La mille e una notte.
Mondo distanti che si incontrano anche in una semplice fiaba, adoro la Satrapi anche per questo.
Marjane Satrapi, l'autrice di Persepolis, che si dà al racconto fiabesco, ma con il suo solito stile personalissimo... e forse in quest'opera più che in altre c'è il riflesso della sua persona: nata in Iran, diventata adulta in Francia. Così questa fiaba ricorda per molti versi quelle europee, ma con tinte e risvolti a La mille e una notte.
Mondo distanti che si incontrano anche in una semplice fiaba, adoro la Satrapi anche per questo.
mattycakesbooks's review
3.0
A classic fairytale from one of my favorite artists. More of a children's book than a graphic novel. It's a good fairy tale, but when I cracked it open, I was hoping for something a bit darker - along the lines of Persepolis. Oh well, though. She's not to blame for misguided expectations. I'll read it to my kids, if I ever have any.
luanndie's review
1.0
Marjane Satrapi me enamoró con Persépolis y me convenció con Bordados así que decidí leer todo lo había publicado hasta el momento pero esta historia ha sido una gran decepción y no porque fuera un cuento para niños. Los dibujos son preciosos como siempre pero esta leyenda es muy conocida y ha sido mejor contada otras veces. Satrapi no consigue aportar su toque por no decir que los valores que transmite son como mínimos cuestionables. La verdad, esperaba mucho más de la autora.
Reseña completa aquí: http://gutenbergylumiere.blogspot.com.es/2015/02/las-novelas-graficas-de-marjane-satrapi.html
Reseña completa aquí: http://gutenbergylumiere.blogspot.com.es/2015/02/las-novelas-graficas-de-marjane-satrapi.html
ivanssister's review
3.0
Cute short read. I enjoy Satrapi's real life stories better, but it was neat to see more color.
kricketa's review
4.0
a lovely little fairy tale by the author of persepolis. this wasn't what i was expecting, but i really enjoyed it. it made me feel nostalgic and childhoody.
*i put this on the graphic novel shelf because it's marjane satrapi, but it's really more of a picture book. for grown-ups. or teens. maybe some kids? i don't know, i have no idea what kids like.
*i put this on the graphic novel shelf because it's marjane satrapi, but it's really more of a picture book. for grown-ups. or teens. maybe some kids? i don't know, i have no idea what kids like.