Reviews

Above the Timberline by Gregory Manchess

hellosagar's review against another edition

4.0

Alright, this story makes no sense, and is hilariously backwards at times, much like the faux-Victorian, Age-of-Exploration society it restores. But you're not reading it for the story. You're reading it for the absolutely gorgeous oil paintings on every page. Each one a winner, and the quantity of art is so much, it'd be worth it just for that!

alyssakwriter's review against another edition

4.0

I really liked this book. It was difficult to follow along at first due to the switching between characters but it was easy enough to follow along once I could distinguish who was who. The visuals were probably the best part. Manchess is a wonderful artist and it clearly shows in this piece of work.

lyleblosser's review against another edition

4.0

Harkens back to the old style adventure stories, only this time very beautifully augmented with the author's brilliant artwork. Wonderfully told, with depth and feeling, and a true sense of mystery and adventure. Would make a splendid cinematic film, but it would be hard to match the visuals presented by the author which truly capture the atmosphere of the tale.

tylerjyoung's review against another edition

adventurous fast-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? Plot
• Strong character development? No
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? No
• Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.5

Great visuals, love the concept, not a great writer. 

cook_memorial_public_library's review against another edition

4.0

A 2017 staff favorite recommended by Andrea.

Check our catalog: https://encore.cooklib.org/iii/encore/search/C__Sabove%20the%20timberline%20manchess__Orightresult__U?lang=eng&suite=gold

zezee's review against another edition

adventurous

• Plot- or character-driven? Plot
• Diverse cast of characters? No

3.0

 
It was a decent story and a good one considering that this is technically Manchess’s debut novel. Gregory Manchess both wrote and painted the pictures for this book. He is an award-winning painter and freelance illustrator whose paintings have appeared in several magazines, such as the National Geographic and the Atlantic Monthly. He has also done illustrations for several books as well, such as Day of the Kraken by Michael Swanwick

I’m not a big fan of science-fiction novels, so if Manchess’s Above the Timberline hadn’t been described as a painted novel, the story wouldn’t have appealed to me much and I probably wouldn’t have read it. But the paintings got me interested and as I read, I became curious about how the story would end: Would Wesley find his father? And did his father find the lost city? Is there something supernatural going on here?

Apart from the painting’s influence, the story is okay and becomes more interesting as the plot progresses. I was surprised that I got hooked on it because despite the cool airship battle at the beginning, I was a bit bored. I think my interest in the story perked up when Wesley had his first crash soon after starting out on his quest. I thought it was hilarious because he’s too damn cocky. And that’s another thing that surprised me, the story has some funny moments, which helped to make it an entertaining read.

Much of the story is narrated through Wesley’s or his father’s journals, which I didn’t mind, but there were some interactions and mentions that made me question the narration format because I’d wonder if someone would really be able to reproduce certain interactions and dialogues in their journals in their entirety. But that was just me nitpicking again. Overall, I didn’t have any problem with the narration format.

However, there were some awkward moments in the story. I was willing to overlook most of them, but the most annoying one to me was the love interest that developed later. I don’t think it was needed and it was odd that we are able to read the love interest’s journal too. It made me wonder if Wesley gained access to her journal since he’s the main character and the one either reading or writing in a journal up until then. It just made me a little confused about who exactly is reading the journals.

My thoughts… on the art:

Stunning, breathtaking paintings (122 oil paintings total) occupy every page helping to bring alive the frozen post-apocalyptic world Manchess has created in Above the Timberline. Usually when I review comics and graphic novels, I first discuss the story then move on to the art, but I’m unable to do so with this book. It’s the description “painted novel” that captured my interest in it and the beautiful paintings that incited excitement and curiosity in me as I read.

Before reading, I assumed there would be nothing but an expanse of white on all the pages to portray the frozen landscape mentioned in the synopsis. But I was way off there. White is indeed used a lot, but there’s also a variety of blues mixed in to give the impression of ice and browns used for the interior of buildings. We even see a bit of the aurora borealis whose ethereal green glow is complemented by the stark dark blues of thick ice formations out in the frozen wastes that seem to stand in awed admiration of the eerie light.

The story mostly takes place out in the open, frozen wild as our protagonist, Wesley Singleton, searches for his father. However, we get glimpses of buildings in the city where Wesley lived as well as a town (I call it a town) he visited while out in the Waste. I love illustrations of buildings and appreciated the design of the ones Manchess included in this book. My favorites of these is a painting of a building partially covered in ice while airships fly overhead. I believe it is the Singleton residence.

Much as I admire the paintings, I must admit that this isn’t my favorite art style. The figures in the paintings are detailed, but aren’t precise. There’s some fuzziness around the edges of some figures because the brushstrokes are noticeable, but that’s just me nitpicking at things because I prefer when there’s a sense of smoothness in an illustration or painting. I don’t like to see the strokes.

But, for an art style that I typically don’t like, I sure love what Manchess has accomplished in this book, especially with a limited color palette because of the setting. Other paintings I love include the airship battle (it’s pretty cool), the polar bears (they’re cute but totally badass), any and every fight scene, and the large ice formations that are clear and with light reflecting off them when portrayed at day but have a dark blue cast with hints of white at their tips when portrayed at night with the aurora borealis stretching across the sky.

Overall: ★★★☆☆

Maybe even 3.5 stars because the story is good and the paintings are absolutely wonderful. I’m glad I received a copy of this book and that I read it. I love this format and I hope that more painted novels will be published. I think the format will work well for fantasy and sci-fi stories as this one did.

P.S.:

Because of the format and story — full-page paintings and an explorer searching for something that probably doesn’t exist or cannot be found, — I couldn’t help thinking of In Search of Lost Dragons by Elian Black’Mor and Carine-M as I read. (See my review here.) It’s about a journalist documenting his search for dragons.

As posted on Zezee with Books. 

its_cold_'s review against another edition

adventurous challenging mysterious tense medium-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix
• Strong character development? It's complicated
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? No
• Flaws of characters a main focus? No

okay, so—
this book is very difficult to rate, so i’ve decided to rate some individual elements of it separately—

* The Art: 5/5 stars, simply breathtaking. like, wow. beyond stunning.

* The Writing: 2/5 stars. i hate to say this, but it was poorly written. i think it would’ve worked better had Manchester gotten someone to write it for him while he did the artwork.
the use of made up “curse words” was a bit cheesy for me, and in general Wesley talked like he was a young teenager, not like a seventeen—almost eighteen year old.
also, the transitions between POVs were clunky at best, and utterly confusing at worst.

* The Characters: 2/5 stars. they were flat and simply underdeveloped.

it felt like Wesley only loved Linea because she was pretty? idk, that romance aspect really rubbed me the wrong way.
*end spoiler*
so, yeah. as an art book, this is showstopping. as a novel, it’s quite lacking. :(

chrstn's review against another edition

3.0

The artwork was BEAUTIFUL!

The story was a little hard to follow. It felt more like a sequel. Like we were missing background information.

bookslovejenna's review against another edition

adventurous mysterious slow-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? Plot
• Strong character development? No
• Loveable characters? No
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

hforsythe26's review against another edition

adventurous lighthearted mysterious medium-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? Plot
• Strong character development? It's complicated
• Loveable characters? Yes
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.5