Reviews

Dead Men Whistling by Graham Masterton

howtoreadmore's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

charlie_allin's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Graham Masterton is truly a literary genius. This book was truly gripping. I was worried about how this book would turn out, wondering if it would be solely around the drug smuggling or if there would be more gore in it like the earlier books, I was not disappointed, I was glad that in this book Katie’s sexual “appetite” as such was much more reserved which let the story flow, and it didn’t feel as if it was needed. Following Katie’s newest ‘adventures’ trying to find the truly twisted criminals sawing off Garda’s heads and placing whistles in their windpipes and trying to shit down the drug smuggling is truly something of a nightmare. Her finally catching the killers in such exceptional circumstances was truly amazing. The twists and turns and the sad untimely demise of her loving father truly tugs at your heart, I found myself crying with her at the end. The way to book ended with her in the beach finding out about his death was perfectly placed and a good end to it, leaving you wanting more. I cannot wait for his next book later this year.

(I happened this all made sense as it is 2am)

balthazarlawson's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

As usual, Katie Maguire has more things on the go then one would seem capable of handling. She has dead and missing policemen, a dead financier, dead criminals and a growing mistrust among the officers at Anglesea Road Station to deal with. It's all go go go.

Katie in her determined and unwavering manner must overcome all the obstacles that are placed her way to get to the truth and at the same uphold the oath she swore when she joined the police. An oath that is being challenged more often. Her strength of character is what gets her through and her true friends.

Her personal life is not easy either and it also challenges her to uphold the oath.

All this makes for an enjoyable read, even though it is rather gruesome in the normal Graham Masterton manner. There is a grittiness to these novels and is way I enjoy them so much.

canada_matt's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous informative mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

My binge of Irish police procedurals continues with more novels by Graham Masterton. He continues to impresses with stories full of action, criminal goings-on, and strong detective work. There is a great flow to the writing that appears only to get better as Masterton weaves Irish-themed ideas to add an even more flavourful story for those who have followed from the beginning of this collection.

When the body of a Garda officer is found beheaded, many within the Cork police community wonder if it could be terrorism. However, the odd insertion of a tin whistle into the neck stump adds a curious angle to the investigation. Detective Superintendent Katie Macguire wants to get to the bottom of it, especially if someone is targeting her colleagues.

After another Garda is found murdered, with the same whistle placement, DS Macguire is sure this is a pattern. While she would love to deal solely with this, she has some personal matters that require her attention, namely her new lover. While he is a detective working on some dog fighting cases, he appears to have taken matters into his own hands after burning down the home of a known criminal. 

When the two victims of the Garda attacks are confirmed as whistleblowers against their colleagues, things fall into perspective and DS Macguire is keen to see who might be targeting those who want to ensure everyone follows the rules. Three other whistleblowers are identified and placed into protective custody, but they are not entirely safe from whoever is targeting these Garda.

Juggling everything tossed at her, DS Macguire makes the best of it while trying to stay one step ahead of the hungry media folk who surround her at every turn. She is also receiving a great deal of pressure from her superiors, some of whom have voiced a concern at letting a woman climb the ranks of the Garda. A murderer (or group) is out there and DS Macguire will have to stop them, as she is about to ‘blow the whistle’ herself on some happenings that come to her attention. Masterton is brilliant once again and keeps the reader on their toes throughout this stellar piece of writing.

Graham Masterton weaves more Irish police procedurals in this intense series that uses graphic and sometimes gruesome murder as a means of catching the reader’s attention. Strong themes, set in the heart of Ireland, provide this series with a flavouring to which I am not accustomed, but thoroughly enjoy. The author is able to build on character development with ease and finds new ways to add depth to storylines that cross from one novel to the next.

Masterton blends his love of horror writing with a strong sense of mystery and police investigation. The strong narrative development is apparent throughout, as this book is only the latest in a collection of strong pieces. Personal and professional growth is apparent amongst many of the characters, especially DS  Katie Macguire, who has had a number of hurdles in her way that require some attention. This is as it should be with a strong protagonist in a longer series, allowing the reader to build stronger ties as they read more. Masterton offers plot twists and cliffhangers to keep the series evolving, which has left me scrambling to get hold of the next book as soon as I can post a review. While there are only a few books left in the series, I am ready to tackle those that remain and see just how intense things get for DS Macguire and those around her.

Kudos, Mr. Masterton, for another great read.

Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at: 

its_a_novel_idea's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Graham Masterton is truly a literary genius. This book was truly gripping. I was worried about how this book would turn out, wondering if it would be solely around the drug smuggling or if there would be more gore in it like the earlier books, I was not disappointed, I was glad that in this book Katie’s sexual “appetite” as such was much more reserved which let the story flow, and it didn’t feel as if it was needed. Following Katie’s newest ‘adventures’ trying to find the truly twisted criminals sawing off Garda’s heads and placing whistles in their windpipes and trying to shit down the drug smuggling is truly something of a nightmare. Her finally catching the killers in such exceptional circumstances was truly amazing. The twists and turns and the sad untimely demise of her loving father truly tugs at your heart, I found myself crying with her at the end. The way to book ended with her in the beach finding out about his death was perfectly placed and a good end to it, leaving you wanting more. I cannot wait for his next book later this year.

(I happened this all made sense as it is 2am)
More...