Scan barcode
kaywhiteley's review
emotional
funny
lighthearted
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
3.75
It’s hard to rate this book because when it was good, it was fantastic. But when it was boring, holy shit did it drag.
I really loved some parts. I loved their romance and Farrell’s conflict with his family. I enjoyed how the book went through the AIDS crisis and other important parts of queer history. And it was quite funny at times.
The problem is that it would just get sooooo slow and boring and I’d find myself counting how many pages until the end. I’m not sure if the good parts were worth the boring parts.
I really loved some parts. I loved their romance and Farrell’s conflict with his family. I enjoyed how the book went through the AIDS crisis and other important parts of queer history. And it was quite funny at times.
The problem is that it would just get sooooo slow and boring and I’d find myself counting how many pages until the end. I’m not sure if the good parts were worth the boring parts.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Homophobia
miloblue's review
Barely made it through the first chapter. What a pretentious piece of garbage. The writing sucked, and i couldn’t see myself liking the characters at all.
book_lizard42's review
5.0
I think I may have found the book of the gift-giving season. Oh, my gosh. Hilarious, heart-breaking, nothing short of brilliant, with flashes of melodrama worthy of Dynasty. It's one of those rare books that I NEED a physical copy of so I can sleep with it under my pillow.
slammders's review
challenging
emotional
funny
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
Broke my heart a million times but also made me laugh constantly. I adored the characters and loved their voices
kirstencc's review
4.0
5 ⭐️ for writing, 4 for overall plot. This is one of, if not the, wittiest books I’ve read. A beautiful story of all things gay, in the best possible way. And being unapologetically yourself. I highly recommend.
jimothymax's review against another edition
emotional
funny
hopeful
inspiring
lighthearted
reflective
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
ndizz87's review
3.0
This novel took me far longer to finish than I had anticipated. If I have to pinpoint the moment I stopped reading and put the book down for at least a month and half, I would say it was the glaring preposterousness that became the hallmark of Nate and Farrell’s relationship. When I selected the book I figured that it would be yet another gushy romance, and while that’s somewhat the case, there came a point where the suspension of disbelief broke and I just couldn’t buy it anymore. I put it down, but rallied and resolved to finish what I started. While on the whole it never completely sold me, it did manage to gain back enough ground to give it a three out of five stars in the end.
The story centers around a lower middle-class New Jersey Jewish kid, Nate, experiencing college in the big city he’d always dreamed of, 1970s Queer New York City. While there, he inexplicably begins a relationship with one of the most attractive and wealthiest fellow student, Farrell Covington. Farrell has decided, without much thought, that the two of them are immortal lovers, destined to spend the rest of their lives with one another. As the years progress, they are stereotypically pulled apart, but always manage to come back together. Their relationship never truly falters no matter what life throws at them through failed off-Broadway plays, attempts to steal inheritances, Hollywood and its Queer doublethink back in the day, years (and I do mean years…even after they’ve reunited) of being separated, and of course…the heralding of the AIDS crisis in the 1980s.
My biggest issue is with the relationship itself. Nate is written well, but presented as rather ordinary, my guess is, in order to make Farrell pop off the page as much as he does. And boy, does he pop. Farrell is a larger than life character and this novel wants you to know that. The way he speaks is quite assured and extremely ridiculous, though it ends up growing on you. The way these two meet, doesn’t make any sense. Farrell has the entire world at his feet and he goes for the awkward kid in a bear fur coat randomly in the library one day. And there’s no questioning it. Nothing the novel throws at their relationship gives you even the slightest indication that there could be potential for the reader to question the longevity of their relationship. After Farrell’s father passes away, the most salient roadblock gets quickly snuffed out. Everything after that is just them doing life for another twenty or thirty years…which, okay, sure, I guess. After the most dramatic element of the novel magically resolves itself, I found a majority of what comes after a trifle boring.
The one thing that this novel has going for it is wit and humor. Most of what comes out of Farrell’s mouth is nearly always hilarious and with a certain sharp, Oscar Wilde-esque wit that is highly quotable. This quality in Farrell both makes him a memorable character yet gives this reader no real sense of the human that I suspect Farrell was. Even as I read the final section of the novel, I never really felt like I knew the character. It was as if the author made every effort not to allow me to. The story is very much from Nate’s perspective but I couldn’t help but continue to feel as though Farrell was this amusing thinly-veiled caricature.
As a reader, I simply couldn’t connect with the Shakespearian love story that feels preposterous and somewhat boring. The novel spans fifty years and this reader felt time at certain points slow to an agonizing crawl. The characters, while memorable for their wit and humor, are still out of focus. Their blurred characterizations strain an already tenuous logic for why these two feel they’re even meant for one another. Even so, it’s undeniable that this novel was well written and the witty humor jumps off the page more often than not. That alone was a saving grace. It is made apparent that style does, in fact, have its limits.
The story centers around a lower middle-class New Jersey Jewish kid, Nate, experiencing college in the big city he’d always dreamed of, 1970s Queer New York City. While there, he inexplicably begins a relationship with one of the most attractive and wealthiest fellow student, Farrell Covington. Farrell has decided, without much thought, that the two of them are immortal lovers, destined to spend the rest of their lives with one another. As the years progress, they are stereotypically pulled apart, but always manage to come back together. Their relationship never truly falters no matter what life throws at them through failed off-Broadway plays, attempts to steal inheritances, Hollywood and its Queer doublethink back in the day, years (and I do mean years…even after they’ve reunited) of being separated, and of course…the heralding of the AIDS crisis in the 1980s.
My biggest issue is with the relationship itself. Nate is written well, but presented as rather ordinary, my guess is, in order to make Farrell pop off the page as much as he does. And boy, does he pop. Farrell is a larger than life character and this novel wants you to know that. The way he speaks is quite assured and extremely ridiculous, though it ends up growing on you. The way these two meet, doesn’t make any sense. Farrell has the entire world at his feet and he goes for the awkward kid in a bear fur coat randomly in the library one day. And there’s no questioning it. Nothing the novel throws at their relationship gives you even the slightest indication that there could be potential for the reader to question the longevity of their relationship. After Farrell’s father passes away, the most salient roadblock gets quickly snuffed out. Everything after that is just them doing life for another twenty or thirty years…which, okay, sure, I guess. After the most dramatic element of the novel magically resolves itself, I found a majority of what comes after a trifle boring.
The one thing that this novel has going for it is wit and humor. Most of what comes out of Farrell’s mouth is nearly always hilarious and with a certain sharp, Oscar Wilde-esque wit that is highly quotable. This quality in Farrell both makes him a memorable character yet gives this reader no real sense of the human that I suspect Farrell was. Even as I read the final section of the novel, I never really felt like I knew the character. It was as if the author made every effort not to allow me to. The story is very much from Nate’s perspective but I couldn’t help but continue to feel as though Farrell was this amusing thinly-veiled caricature.
As a reader, I simply couldn’t connect with the Shakespearian love story that feels preposterous and somewhat boring. The novel spans fifty years and this reader felt time at certain points slow to an agonizing crawl. The characters, while memorable for their wit and humor, are still out of focus. Their blurred characterizations strain an already tenuous logic for why these two feel they’re even meant for one another. Even so, it’s undeniable that this novel was well written and the witty humor jumps off the page more often than not. That alone was a saving grace. It is made apparent that style does, in fact, have its limits.
eb2114's review
emotional
funny
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
ahobbitsreadinglist's review
emotional
funny
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5