Scan barcode
macthekat's review against another edition
3.0
a hunting story about humans... and how it isn't machine parts that take away their humanity but their actions. beautiful imagery and bizarre word pictures. a bit confusing because of the compressed form but that is part of the charm of reading short fiction
Merged review:
A captivating story about a miner with no hope in a situation where she has no hope of getting out until she do.
It's quite a short story but it manages to build a world that you feel you know how it is working. You understand the protagonist and care for her. I just realised that I am not sure of the protagonist's gender - she felt female to me, but what do I know?
I do however think the Uncanny Magazine has spoiled me - I expect more emotional punch from the short stories I read.
Merged review:
Not a fan of second person, but dark and hunting. I ended up caring, not about the protagonist but about the plot and the world. Neat trick in that short a story
Merged review:
Interesting story of memory and identity. If I had to rate it I think I would land on 3 stars. It kept me interested, but not terribly emotionally invested
Merged review:
Blah, that ended before it really got interesting. more like the start of a story, than a story.
Merged review:
A captivating story about a miner with no hope in a situation where she has no hope of getting out until she do.
It's quite a short story but it manages to build a world that you feel you know how it is working. You understand the protagonist and care for her. I just realised that I am not sure of the protagonist's gender - she felt female to me, but what do I know?
I do however think the Uncanny Magazine has spoiled me - I expect more emotional punch from the short stories I read.
Merged review:
Not a fan of second person, but dark and hunting. I ended up caring, not about the protagonist but about the plot and the world. Neat trick in that short a story
Merged review:
Interesting story of memory and identity. If I had to rate it I think I would land on 3 stars. It kept me interested, but not terribly emotionally invested
Merged review:
Blah, that ended before it really got interesting. more like the start of a story, than a story.
competencefantasy's review against another edition
5.0
Turns out I like Neil Clarke's editing style just as much in anthologies as in Clarkesworld. I was one of the kickstarter backers for this book, and I am so delighted with the result.
The theme works smoothly, and the stories feel both coherent and full of variety. Some of my personal highlights were
Married by Helena Bell
Tender by Rachel Swirsky (content warning for self harm on this one)
Small Medicine by Genevieve Valentine
Tongtong’s Summer by Xia Jia
The theme works smoothly, and the stories feel both coherent and full of variety. Some of my personal highlights were
Married by Helena Bell
Tender by Rachel Swirsky (content warning for self harm on this one)
Small Medicine by Genevieve Valentine
Tongtong’s Summer by Xia Jia
mercwolfmoor's review
3.0
A mixed bag. Overall, I was not impressed with a good chunk of it. There were a handful of stories I liked and that stood out; the rest ranged from dull to infuriating to forgettable. I was hoping to like this, because the unifying theme--cyborgs--is one I’m always interested in. Mostly I ended up disappointed.
“Always the Harvest” by Yoon Ha Lee
A fairly strong start to the anthology; the story ends up being something of a love song between a cyborg and a planet, and it’s very sweet.
“A Cold Heart” by Tobias S. Buckell
A mercenary named Pepper tries to retrieve stolen memories and finds new things to live for. Another fairly solid story; it didn’t really pull me in how I’d hoped but had some cool moments.
“The Sarcophagus” by Robert Reed
I got utterly bored two pages in, skimmed the rest, then got thoroughly fed up with the immature, infantilized beings of the worldship. (I have very little patience with characters who are noted to be hundreds and thousands of years old and act like spoilt adolescents. And everyone seemed to be a total jerk in this story, so I didn’t bother.)
“Oil of Angels” by Chen Quiufan, translated by Ken Liu
Another about memory loss, genetic memory, and relationships between mothers and daughters. Pretty good.
“What I’ve Seen With Your Eyes” by Jason K. Chapman
A brother modifies his sister’s optics. She acts as a Watson to his Sherlock, and mostly relays past events while theoretically helping a detective with her brother’s murder. So-so. A bit of problematic language the way Lisa refers to herself, though.
“No Place to Dream, But a Place to Die” by Elizabeth Bear
Miners get trapped during an explosion/cave-in and work to get free while becoming sorta-friends. Nothing really stood out for me in this one. It felt more bland and less punchy than some of Bear’s other short work.
“Married” by Helena Bell
There seems to be a subset of recent SF in which the narrator is distant, detached and never really has a feeling. This is one; a woman cannot cope with her husband’s change into a fully metallic person (due to tech that saved him from cancer). Mostly depressing.
“Come Away From” by Madeline Ashby
Started interesting (if on a sensitive topic of school shootings) and then falls apart 3/4ths of the way through. I didn’t care that it was a set-up, it just all seemed utterly pointless and I have no idea what the ending is trying to say.
“Negative Space” by Amanda Forrest
Forced/forcible memory loss is apparently a theme, because this is the third one in the anthology. A girl tries to get away from people who want her memories because they think she’s a savant, so she self-lobotomizes herself in the end. I found it unengaging and rather tedious.
“Fusion” by Greg Mellor
Got completely lost and absolutely bored two pages in, didn’t finish.
“Taking the Ghost” by A.C. Wise
I liked the idea of this one (ghosts power metallic prosthetics in a semi-post-apocalyptic world) but got irritated that literally all the women mentioned are dead or killed off. I had no emotional engagement with this one.
“Honeycomb Girls” by Erin Cashier
This one basically left me infuriated. In a post-apoc world, the only thing (ONLY) women, who are very few in number, are good for is being used for sex by multiple men in strictly ordered segregations. And then once they get pregnant, they disappear and are replaced by female sex-bots.
“The Regular” by Ken Liu
Like Criminal Minds, with a cyborg ex-cop PI. So yeah, murdered sex workers are the central conflict here. I did like the protagonist, Ruth, but the Watcher’s scenes didn’t work for me. Ending was solid, at least.
“Tender” by Rachel Swirsky
Rage-bait. A woman wants to commit suicide and her husband continually modifies her body to make her invulnerable, without her consent. That’s it. There’s no plot other than her thinking of killing herself, and him changing her body without permission. Hated it.
“Tongtong’s Summer” by Xia Jia, translated by Ken Liu
I apparently missed this one while skipping around with the reading. About the titular Tongtong and robot grandparents. Sweet in places.
“Musee De L’Ame Seule” by E. Lily Yu
A story about disability and adapting. Sweet and upbeat by the end.
“Wizard, Cabalist, Ascendant” by Seth Dickinson
A lot of the context and discussion of this went over my head, and I had no real interest or attachment to the characters. Did not leave much impact, like some of Dickinson’s work has.
“Memories and Wire” by Mari Ness
Yet another one where a woman (appears to) commit suicide. This one has more of a plot than “Tender” and an attempt at characterization. Still did not like it.
“God Decay” by Rich Larson
A super-athlete finds out his mods are going to kill him in about two years. Decent, although abelist in the backstory (because of course you can’t be an olympian if you’re in a wheelchair? UGH).
“Small Medicine” By Genevieve Valentine
Girl and her robot-replaced grandmother do stuff. Apparently. Mostly the girl misses her real grandma and then there is some kind of museum opening. It really did nothing for me.
“Mercury in Retrograde” by Erin Hoffman
Mercury is trying to escape her mother, gets hacked and has adventures trying to rebuild her life. Fun in places. I liked Digit, but nothing in particular stood out to me.
“Coastlines of the Stars” by Alex Dally MacFarlane
Some very shiny ideas and nice prose in here; I mostly liked it.
“The Cumulative Effects of Light Over Time” by E. Catherine Tobler
Tedious, confusing in places, and did absolutely nothing for me. The narrator is a chimera (modified human, apparently) making her way down a ship. There’s endless, repetitive descriptions of mud. So much mud. Because you can’t forget mud, right? Mud. Something something mud and then the narrator finds out that her former friend (lover?) was turned into an alien host or something. The end. I did not like this one.
“Synecdoche Oracles” by Benjanun Sriduangkaew
I liked this one a lot--the prose is gorgeous and there are so many shiny ideas and it also has Luhna (genderfluid space general). I did not quite grok the entire meaning of the plot between Charina and Luhna, but it was fun to read. Actual space opera.
“Collateral” by Peter Watts
I got only a few pages in before losing interest completely and skipping the rest.
“Seventh Sight” by Greg Egan
This is another one I liked quite a lot--people can modify their eye implants to see far more colors on the spectrum. The story follows a guy and his eventual wife as they explore the possibilities of enhanced eyesight, until computers are able to mimic it and they have to rethink their priorities. It’s engaging and fun and has a nice ending. Good close-out to the anthology.
“Always the Harvest” by Yoon Ha Lee
A fairly strong start to the anthology; the story ends up being something of a love song between a cyborg and a planet, and it’s very sweet.
“A Cold Heart” by Tobias S. Buckell
A mercenary named Pepper tries to retrieve stolen memories and finds new things to live for. Another fairly solid story; it didn’t really pull me in how I’d hoped but had some cool moments.
“The Sarcophagus” by Robert Reed
I got utterly bored two pages in, skimmed the rest, then got thoroughly fed up with the immature, infantilized beings of the worldship. (I have very little patience with characters who are noted to be hundreds and thousands of years old and act like spoilt adolescents. And everyone seemed to be a total jerk in this story, so I didn’t bother.)
“Oil of Angels” by Chen Quiufan, translated by Ken Liu
Another about memory loss, genetic memory, and relationships between mothers and daughters. Pretty good.
“What I’ve Seen With Your Eyes” by Jason K. Chapman
A brother modifies his sister’s optics. She acts as a Watson to his Sherlock, and mostly relays past events while theoretically helping a detective with her brother’s murder. So-so. A bit of problematic language the way Lisa refers to herself, though.
“No Place to Dream, But a Place to Die” by Elizabeth Bear
Miners get trapped during an explosion/cave-in and work to get free while becoming sorta-friends. Nothing really stood out for me in this one. It felt more bland and less punchy than some of Bear’s other short work.
“Married” by Helena Bell
There seems to be a subset of recent SF in which the narrator is distant, detached and never really has a feeling. This is one; a woman cannot cope with her husband’s change into a fully metallic person (due to tech that saved him from cancer). Mostly depressing.
“Come Away From” by Madeline Ashby
Started interesting (if on a sensitive topic of school shootings) and then falls apart 3/4ths of the way through. I didn’t care that it was a set-up, it just all seemed utterly pointless and I have no idea what the ending is trying to say.
“Negative Space” by Amanda Forrest
Forced/forcible memory loss is apparently a theme, because this is the third one in the anthology. A girl tries to get away from people who want her memories because they think she’s a savant, so she self-lobotomizes herself in the end. I found it unengaging and rather tedious.
“Fusion” by Greg Mellor
Got completely lost and absolutely bored two pages in, didn’t finish.
“Taking the Ghost” by A.C. Wise
I liked the idea of this one (ghosts power metallic prosthetics in a semi-post-apocalyptic world) but got irritated that literally all the women mentioned are dead or killed off. I had no emotional engagement with this one.
“Honeycomb Girls” by Erin Cashier
This one basically left me infuriated. In a post-apoc world, the only thing (ONLY) women, who are very few in number, are good for is being used for sex by multiple men in strictly ordered segregations. And then once they get pregnant, they disappear and are replaced by female sex-bots.
“The Regular” by Ken Liu
Like Criminal Minds, with a cyborg ex-cop PI. So yeah, murdered sex workers are the central conflict here. I did like the protagonist, Ruth, but the Watcher’s scenes didn’t work for me. Ending was solid, at least.
“Tender” by Rachel Swirsky
Rage-bait. A woman wants to commit suicide and her husband continually modifies her body to make her invulnerable, without her consent. That’s it. There’s no plot other than her thinking of killing herself, and him changing her body without permission. Hated it.
“Tongtong’s Summer” by Xia Jia, translated by Ken Liu
I apparently missed this one while skipping around with the reading. About the titular Tongtong and robot grandparents. Sweet in places.
“Musee De L’Ame Seule” by E. Lily Yu
A story about disability and adapting. Sweet and upbeat by the end.
“Wizard, Cabalist, Ascendant” by Seth Dickinson
A lot of the context and discussion of this went over my head, and I had no real interest or attachment to the characters. Did not leave much impact, like some of Dickinson’s work has.
“Memories and Wire” by Mari Ness
Yet another one where a woman (appears to) commit suicide. This one has more of a plot than “Tender” and an attempt at characterization. Still did not like it.
“God Decay” by Rich Larson
A super-athlete finds out his mods are going to kill him in about two years. Decent, although abelist in the backstory (because of course you can’t be an olympian if you’re in a wheelchair? UGH).
“Small Medicine” By Genevieve Valentine
Girl and her robot-replaced grandmother do stuff. Apparently. Mostly the girl misses her real grandma and then there is some kind of museum opening. It really did nothing for me.
“Mercury in Retrograde” by Erin Hoffman
Mercury is trying to escape her mother, gets hacked and has adventures trying to rebuild her life. Fun in places. I liked Digit, but nothing in particular stood out to me.
“Coastlines of the Stars” by Alex Dally MacFarlane
Some very shiny ideas and nice prose in here; I mostly liked it.
“The Cumulative Effects of Light Over Time” by E. Catherine Tobler
Tedious, confusing in places, and did absolutely nothing for me. The narrator is a chimera (modified human, apparently) making her way down a ship. There’s endless, repetitive descriptions of mud. So much mud. Because you can’t forget mud, right? Mud. Something something mud and then the narrator finds out that her former friend (lover?) was turned into an alien host or something. The end. I did not like this one.
“Synecdoche Oracles” by Benjanun Sriduangkaew
I liked this one a lot--the prose is gorgeous and there are so many shiny ideas and it also has Luhna (genderfluid space general). I did not quite grok the entire meaning of the plot between Charina and Luhna, but it was fun to read. Actual space opera.
“Collateral” by Peter Watts
I got only a few pages in before losing interest completely and skipping the rest.
“Seventh Sight” by Greg Egan
This is another one I liked quite a lot--people can modify their eye implants to see far more colors on the spectrum. The story follows a guy and his eventual wife as they explore the possibilities of enhanced eyesight, until computers are able to mimic it and they have to rethink their priorities. It’s engaging and fun and has a nice ending. Good close-out to the anthology.
More...