Scan barcode
A review by ellelainey
M.F.K. by Nilah Magruder
3.0
Book – MFK (MFK #1)
Author – Nilah Magruder
Star rating - ★★★☆☆
No. of Pages – 129
Cover – Gorgeous
Genre – Comic, Graphic Novel, Children's, Death
** COPY RECEIVED THROUGH NETGALLEY **
Okay, so this was a strange one for me. The cover and blurb tells us that this is Abbie's story, but it's really not. It's the story of Jaime, the kid who discovers Abbie already on her trek to scatter her mother's ashes, injured and with a dying pet/travel animal. Now, considering the cover shows Abbie travelling with this animal, I find it a bit misleading, because the animal dies on the first page they enter the story and there is no “journey” that matches the image on the cover, within the actual story. Abbie is discovered kneeling beside her dead animal on page one of her part of the story.
The story begins with Jaime helping his grandfather gather sand, which is a thing, apparently. Then it journeys through finding Abbie and her dead pet, taking her back home to be treated, and how she changes everything in their small hick town, in the middle of nowhere, just by being there.
The entire story is told in Jaime's POV, through what he sees and feels, with only a few deviations into Abbie's thoughts about her mother. It explores her magical powers in a fight, which would have been more impressive if we haven't been set up for the big reveal both thanks to the blurb and Jaime's aunt spilling the beans too early.
Overall, this is just a chapter in a bigger story, but it wasn't really my cup of tea. It took too long to get to the point, gave away things that shouldn't have been revealed yet, and failed to keep my attention. The art work was excellent and the plot itself could have been great, but there were a few too many problems for my liking.
Author – Nilah Magruder
Star rating - ★★★☆☆
No. of Pages – 129
Cover – Gorgeous
Genre – Comic, Graphic Novel, Children's, Death
** COPY RECEIVED THROUGH NETGALLEY **
Okay, so this was a strange one for me. The cover and blurb tells us that this is Abbie's story, but it's really not. It's the story of Jaime, the kid who discovers Abbie already on her trek to scatter her mother's ashes, injured and with a dying pet/travel animal. Now, considering the cover shows Abbie travelling with this animal, I find it a bit misleading, because the animal dies on the first page they enter the story and there is no “journey” that matches the image on the cover, within the actual story. Abbie is discovered kneeling beside her dead animal on page one of her part of the story.
The story begins with Jaime helping his grandfather gather sand, which is a thing, apparently. Then it journeys through finding Abbie and her dead pet, taking her back home to be treated, and how she changes everything in their small hick town, in the middle of nowhere, just by being there.
The entire story is told in Jaime's POV, through what he sees and feels, with only a few deviations into Abbie's thoughts about her mother. It explores her magical powers in a fight, which would have been more impressive if we haven't been set up for the big reveal both thanks to the blurb and Jaime's aunt spilling the beans too early.
Overall, this is just a chapter in a bigger story, but it wasn't really my cup of tea. It took too long to get to the point, gave away things that shouldn't have been revealed yet, and failed to keep my attention. The art work was excellent and the plot itself could have been great, but there were a few too many problems for my liking.