A review by rdmathison
Gardener's Son by Cormac McCarthy

4.0

The Gardener's Son is another captivating creation by the literary genius Cormac McCarthy. As someone on a personal quest to devour everything McCarthy has ever penned, I found this screenplay to be a solid addition to his impressive body of work. While it may not have left as indelible a mark on me as some of his other masterpieces, it still holds its own.

Set in the post-Civil War era, The Gardener's Son explores the complex dynamics between two families, the Greggs and the McEvoys, in a small mill town. The story focuses on Robert McEvoy, the son of the mill's gardener, who, after an accident, loses a leg. This event sets off a chain of events that deeply affects both families. The screenplay delves into themes of class conflict, family loyalty, and the harsh realities of industrialization. The narrative is folded around the mysterious circumstances leading to the murder of the mill owner's son, James Gregg, for which Robert is implicated. As the story unfolds, McCarthy masterfully unravels the intricate relationships and social tensions within the town, leading to a climactic and thought-provoking conclusion.

McCarthy's signature style, characterized by a knack for exploring the darker facets of human nature, is without a doubt present in The Gardener's Son. The narrative unfolds in a way that draws you in, and as with all of his works, it is impossible to escape the haunting atmosphere he effortlessly conjures.

The characters, as expected from McCarthy, are multifaceted, leaving room for contemplation long after the story has concluded. While I may not have been as deeply affected by them as I have been by some of his other creations, they still left an impression.

In the grand scheme of Cormac McCarthy's literary brilliance, The Gardener's Son may not shine quite as brightly, but it is still a worthwhile and engaging read. For those on a journey to explore McCarthy's entire body of work, it is an essential piece of the puzzle.