A review by a_a_ron3891
Gaslight Grimoire: Fantastic Tales of Sherlock Holmes by Barbara Roden, David Stuart Davies, Rick Kennett, Chris Roberson, Chico Kidd, Matthew J. Elliott, Charles Prepolec, Barbara Hambly, Kim Newman, Phil Cornell, Martin Powell, Bob Madison, Christopher Sequeira, Peter Calamai, J.R. Campbell

3.0

A collection of largely successful pastiches, only one outright miss in the bunch (Lost World crossover w/Professor Challenger - garbage). A lot of efforts like these end up trying too hard, when often it seems like Conan Doyle dashed out a lot of the canon without trying at all. I did enjoy the last story that was absent Holmes & Watson entirely, featuring Moran & Moriarty in a ridiculous bit of fun that made me wish for a Breaking Bad style incarnation of that duo.