A review by emmaisabelle
Miracle Creek by Angie Kim

dark emotional mysterious sad medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.0

While it was definitely engrossing and I enjoyed the mystery-courtroom drama mix, I found the focus on neurotypical characters when so much of the book revolves around autism and people of autism pretty unappealing. The constant onslaught of ableist language and ideas was a LOT. It really just left me thinking “What is the point of hearing all these people talk about how much they hate people with autism and how autism is a disease that needs to be fixed?” Not once did the characters with autism have a voice in this book. 

That said I think the way Kim explores the truth of what happened, the way people invent stories to fit their own narratives and emotions, and how witnesses’ memories are formed by the complex context leading to the events of the book was fascinating. While it was sometimes jarring to switch POV so many times, I do think Kim is really good at managing all those different opinions, memories, thoughts, personalities, etc. She really raises interesting questions about truth/memory, guilt/innocence, and parenthood. I just could not handle the rampent ableism nor did I really see the point of going that hard on it. I’m just not sure the book needed that much hatred of autistic people in it lol, even if it’s pretty clear Kim is not her characters and doesn’t share their thoughts. 

Overall an engrossing courtroom thriller-mystery but just too put off by the incessant ableism of the characters. If you read, just be prepared for two hundred pages of characters discussing how autistic children are problems that need to be fixed.  
Expand filter menu Content Warnings