Scan barcode
A review by jersy
The Devil and the Dark Water by Stuart Turton
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
After adoring Turton's previous book I was expecting this to be a favourite of the year. While I liked the mystery at the core of the book, which was really intriguing and provided an unexpected ending, there were some things about this book that just didn't entirely work for me.
The biggest influence on this only earning 3 stars were the characters. Some of them were interesting and I would have liked to spend more time reading about Creesjie and Lia, for example, but what we got from everyone wasn't enough to make them unique or compelling. Arent was fine as a main character, but Sara is your typical too modern woman in historical fiction, which is not only cliché and jarring but I wish there was just more to her.
Speaking of historical, this book does not attempt to be an accurate representation of it's time period, but I think it uses it's set pieces well to tell a fun story. However, it does feel like a lot of other historical adventurous mysteries and was a lot more conventional than Turton's previous book. This will probably make it more accessible to a lot of readers, but for me this meant a lot less original ideas and memorable details.
Something I really enjoyed, on the other hand, was the writing style. It's succinct and has a lot of charm, creating a tone that fit the characters well. There was some repetition, caused by many characters working on the case, having to share new information with everyone, but aside from that there wasn't anything distracting.
This isn't a book I rate 3 stars because it's disappointing, but because it just isn't that special in the ways that matter to me. It's really fun, though, so if you don't expect it to be as mindblowing as The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle and just want a mystery novel with an interesting setting, go ahead and pick it up.
The biggest influence on this only earning 3 stars were the characters. Some of them were interesting and I would have liked to spend more time reading about Creesjie and Lia, for example, but what we got from everyone wasn't enough to make them unique or compelling. Arent was fine as a main character, but Sara is your typical too modern woman in historical fiction, which is not only cliché and jarring but I wish there was just more to her.
Speaking of historical, this book does not attempt to be an accurate representation of it's time period, but I think it uses it's set pieces well to tell a fun story. However, it does feel like a lot of other historical adventurous mysteries and was a lot more conventional than Turton's previous book. This will probably make it more accessible to a lot of readers, but for me this meant a lot less original ideas and memorable details.
Something I really enjoyed, on the other hand, was the writing style. It's succinct and has a lot of charm, creating a tone that fit the characters well. There was some repetition, caused by many characters working on the case, having to share new information with everyone, but aside from that there wasn't anything distracting.
This isn't a book I rate 3 stars because it's disappointing, but because it just isn't that special in the ways that matter to me. It's really fun, though, so if you don't expect it to be as mindblowing as The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle and just want a mystery novel with an interesting setting, go ahead and pick it up.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Animal death
Minor: Blood, Emotional abuse, Death, Child abuse, and Domestic abuse