A review by jbxdavis
The Constitution of Knowledge by Jonathan Rauch

5.0

A calm, deliberate analysis of truth in public discourse. Rauch provides a solid foundation in the basics of the "reality-based world", which is to say rational thought and liberal thinking (not to be confused with political liberalism). From there he shares his thesis: that adherence to a Constitution of Knowledge with 3 core tenets is vital to modern society. Finally, he explores modern phenomena including misinformation, trolling, and cancel culture, dissecting each and explaining how strict adherence to the Constitution of Knowledge would undermine them. It's a sobering yet inspiring read that will by turns be both invigorating and uncomfortable, depending on your political persuasions. Rauch pulls no punches in calling either side on their bullshit.

My only demerit on this book is that Rauch seems sort of idealistic in his solutions. He asserts that as long as we all play by the rules the best ideas will come out on top, while simultaneously recognizing that there are bad actors who actively seek to undermine those very rules or twist them to their purposes. Rauch is clearly an advocate of free speech, and makes a compelling argument that it is the foundation of a fair, intellectually healthy society. Still, I'm left wondering if there is cause for deplatforming bad actors in situations where Rauch suggests we all simply close our ears and ignore them.

In summary, the book was all I wanted and more. It's intellectually honest, forcing introspection and reconsideration. Society would be better if everyone read it.