Reviews

The Shadow Project by Herbie Brennan

alifromkc1907's review

Go to review page

3.0

Follow Rainbow Reviews on Facebook @RainbowReviews
Instagram @RainbowReviewsKC
Website: http://rainbowreviews.wix.com/rainbowreviews2018

Facts:
Rating: 3.11✨/5✨
Recommended? Not so much.
Movie Availability: No

Review Points:

Gut Instinct Reaction (Gut Instinct Score: 3)
This book was severely underwhelming. I read it in one sitting, but struggled to get through it from the beginning. I hate writers who rotate through their characters chapter after chapter - and this book did a poor job of it anyways, so it was the biggest force against me.
Characters:
Who were the main characters? (Character Score: 4)
Danny is the main character. He breaks into this supposedly top secret facility (yeah, I know, horrible introduction right?) posing as a house to steal and he gets caught and then is forced to join this top secret group for Britain's CIA to help his grandma get better.
Michael is another teen agent who should have more impact and story time, but doesn't.
Opal is another teen agent who's dad (Sir Rowland) runs the program. She is probably more of the focus of the story despite Danny being the main character.
Were the characters credible? I suppose they are. I mean, Danny seems to be the most authentic because he comes from this and that and he tends to be the most forthcoming with his life. We hardly know a thing about Michael, even though we should know more since he plays such a huge role from the beginning and has some weird thing with Opal. And Opal is fine. I don't feel one way or another towards her because her story is about her actions, not about who she is.
Who was your favorite character? Why? I really didn't feel anything towards any particular character.
Could you relate to any of the characters in the story? I mean, I guess we're back to Danny - he had a shit life before the Project and then he is forced to do it to prevent anything from happening to his grandma. But, I can't really relate to him so much as I can empathize for him.
Was the book believable? (Believability Score: 3) It wasn't super hard to believe - I mean, for as long as I can remember, we've had movies about Spy Kid and Agent Cody Banks and so on. So, do I think there's probably a select number of teenagers being recruited to the CIA or whatever? Yeah, probably. I don't buy into voo-doo this, or psychic that, and this entire book revolved around those concepts, so I'm just not really on board.
Was the book similar to several books or did it seem to have enough unique components? (Uniqueness Score: 2) This entire book is exactly like a million other books except for this whole telepathy/floating in space thing.
Was the writing fluid and coherent? Were there parts of the story that jumped around or felt disconnected from the original thought? (Writing Style Score: 2) This book was written horribly. I wanted to put it down from the first 10 pages, but I feel like if I'm going to spend the money on a book, I should give it at least a quarter of the book. It never got better. The chapters jumped from location to location; character to character; different spaces in time. I even skipped a series of chapters because it was the exact same moment in time told from a different character's perspective.
Was the book packed with a punch or were there more periods of slow paced writing? (Excitement Factor Score: 3) The first half of the book was basically a snooze. The middle chunk of it was fine, and then the last half where they finish off the bad guy was the most exciting part of the book and it lasted about 40 pages.
What was the story about? (Story Line Score: 3) I'm still not really sure on this one... I mean, we know Danny, Opal, and Michael are all teen spies, and then something happens to Opal and Danny is supposed to save the day. All that happens, but it never really made sense. Arms dealers - got it. Teen spies - got it. All the science-y stuff, however, was hard to follow.
Did the title fit in with the story's theme, message, or tone? (Title Relevance Score: 5) All fine and dandy.
Did the artwork on the cover and/or dust jacket fit in with the story's theme, message, or tone? (Artwork Relevance Score: 3) These are supposed to be teen spies and the dude on the front looks like Matt Damon, so I'm not exactly sure how that one works out.


My Opinion:

Did you like the book? Not really. I mean, it was fine and it took up a few hours of my night, so there's that. But, it wasn't like I was all excited about it. It felt more like an obligation.
What was your favorite part of the book? The beginning, honestly. Danny playing games with good cop/bad cop.
Do you have a least favorite part of the book? Mostly everything about Danny gets to the hospital to check on his grandma, which was about page 50.
If you could change something, what would it be? I wouldn't have picked it up at Half Price Books.

My Recommendation:

Would you recommend this book to another person? Not unless it was a hardcore sci-fi fan between the ages of 11 and 14.




roshk99's review

Go to review page

2.0

Ok children's adventure novel, the main character is decent, but not impressive, the idea is very cliche. There are probably a million books out there with extremely similar plots and this one does not stand out

anniemariek's review

Go to review page

4.0

First Look: 5/5 I won this in one of those Inkpop Weekly Challenges. The cover is so cool, and the premise is awesome and unique.

Setting: 3/5 I could have gone either way, here. It was set mostly in England, which is a place I'd like to go, but I never really got a feel for it.

Characters: 4/5 I liked Danny. He had a definite personality, and he was well fleshed-out. Michael and Opal had a bit of depth, but not as much. Everyone else was very, very flat. Except Dorothy. She was hilarious. I nearly laughed out loud when she said "There's no place like home." I still can't figure out if that was intentional.

Plot: 4/5 I loved it. I really did. The action started on page one, and did not stop until the end. I did feel, though, like the whole thing was really rushed. There was no time to take anything in. It all happened too fast. Don't get me wrong; I loved the amount of action, but there was nothing to balance it out. The climax felt rushed in particular, and the ending didn't have a sense of finality to it.

Uniqueness: 5/5 I wasn't sure what to expect with the whole out-of-body-experience thing. I was pleasantly surprised. I mean, how often do you get to read a YA spy thriller...with a paranormal twist?

Writing: 4/5 It wasn't really anything special, but it flowed smoothly. There was never anything to distract me from the story.

Likes: I loved the paranormal twist. Teenage spies trained to leave their bodies and use astral projection to go on missions? Let's see Spy Kids top that one. And besides, how can you not love the old grandma?

Not-so-great: Danny was a little too quick to trust the Shadow Project. And vice versa, the Shadow Project was a little too quick to take him on. It didn't feel realistic.

Total Score: 4/5 This was exciting. I practically inhaled it. It will appeal to paranormal* fans, as well as people who like thrillers of the Alex Rider variety (but this is better!). It was a bit rushed, but I still very much enjoyed it; in fact, I'll probably hand this one down to my brother**. A solid four stars.



*Paranormal in the traditional ghosts and spirits sense. Not the Edward-I-love-your-vampireness-you-smell-good-I'm-obsessed-with-you-and-your-glitter sense.

*Who is reading Artemis Fowl right now. I take my recommending very seriously, of course. :)

Read even more reviews at http://anniesepicblog.blogspot.com!

bookbriefs's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This book was just ok. I liked it and if there are other books I would probably read them, but I this book didn't draw me completely into its world like other books have.

The idea of the book is an interesting one. It has a lot of potential. It is about teenagers that can "step" outside of their body. Because of this unique gift they are utilized as spy of sorts.

It was different than anything else I have read so I was really hopefully it would be a good action/suspense book. But there was not much character development or continuity. I felt like I was just kind of coasting along in their world. I was not very excited.

Maybe this book was just setting up the stage and future books will have more character development.
More...