Reviews

Muddy People: A Muslim Coming of Age by Sara El Sayed, Sara El Sayed

jesscondell's review

Go to review page

4.0

Audio book. Easy to listen too and an interesting autobiography.

micht15's review

Go to review page

3.0

Sara’s biography - arriving in Australia from Egypt, living in Brisbane and school in the Redlands. Her relationships with her mother, father and other family members. Peer relationships.

dancingpluto's review

Go to review page

emotional hopeful inspiring reflective relaxing sad medium-paced

4.0

kaitlynhermansen's review

Go to review page

4.0

I enjoyed this. It would be a great memoir for young adults- not particularly deep or lengthy but it was an interesting read.

mckenzierichardson's review

Go to review page

3.0

For more reviews, check out my blog: Craft-Cycle

Written as part of her Master of Fine Arts project, this book gives glimpses into El Sayed's life, both from childhood to adolescents and into adulthood. The book tackles many topics including cancer, parental expectations and double standards, racism, bullying, divorce, friendship, religion, and moving to a different country. It deals largely with El Sayed's family life growing up, moving from Egypt to Australia, and coming to terms with her parents' rules.

There is a broad range to the stories included. Some are humorous, some are heartbreaking, some are insightful, some are a bit dry. There is a lot of ground covered, leading to some interesting anecdotes.

I did find the choppy nature of the storytelling a bit disorienting at times. It was often difficult for me to decern how old El Sayed was in each anecdote, which sometimes led to confusion. At times, there didn't appear to be any message or insight into the experience told. The events just kind of fizzled out by the end of the chapter. I don't believe everything necessarily needs a moral, but it made for a reading experience that was, at times, bland and felt a bit random. There wasn't necessarily a larger element to the story aside from sharing glimpses into her life and her parents' expectations of her.

Overall, a good read that shared some interesting stories.

mayahlove13's review

Go to review page

5.0

PLEASE READ THIS BOOK ITS SO SO SO GOOD.
More...