Scan barcode
jamiejanae_6's review
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Injury/Injury detail, War, Body horror, Death, Deportation, Violence, Grief, Gore, and Racism
Moderate: Sexual content and Stalking
lilifane's review against another edition
emotional
informative
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
This was a very surprising read. The book had been on my shelf for several years and I had no idea what it was actually about. Apparently it's partly a court drama, and I realized I really like those.
The story is set on the fictional island of San Piedro in Puget Sound and centers around a murder trial. The Japanese fisher Kabuo Miyamoto is accused of first degree murder of Carl Heine, a fellow gill fisher, who has been found dead in his fishing nets on an early September morning in 1954. During the trial which takes place in December, we get to know details of the night in question as well as several characters connected to the tragedy, their past and relationships to each other.
What starts (and ends) as a courtroom drama, offers a lot of insight into the characters' past experiences, thoughts and feelings, so you really get to know them intimately and understand their actions throughout the book, even though they not always make the best decisions.
It is a sad and heartbreaking story with important themes like fairness, equality, justice and racism. It also portrays the treatment of Japanese American citizens in the 1930s, 40s and 50s. There are scenes in Japanese internal camps and during WWII battles that are actually hard to read. Especially since David Guterson's writes in a very detailed and sober way.
I really loved this book, it made me feel all kinds of emotions. I was angry, I was sad and frustrated, I cried several times. I also think the plotting was done really well, I did not know how it would end until the very last pages. Really enjoyed the trial and investigation parts and the way details were revealed piece by piece with some unexpected twists and turns. The majority of the book were the characters' flashbacks, though, and they dragged a little in the middle of the book when I wanted to know how the trial was proceeding. It was worth it in the end, though.
The atmosphere was amazing. The setting and the weather really added to the story for me. And I liked the writing style for the most part. There were just some weird choices the author made several times throughout the book. I was very confused by how often characters thought about sex, penises and breasts in very inappropriate moments. And again, these were describes in a very sober way, it was weird and actually unnecessary most of the time.
The story is set on the fictional island of San Piedro in Puget Sound and centers around a murder trial. The Japanese fisher Kabuo Miyamoto is accused of first degree murder of Carl Heine, a fellow gill fisher, who has been found dead in his fishing nets on an early September morning in 1954. During the trial which takes place in December, we get to know details of the night in question as well as several characters connected to the tragedy, their past and relationships to each other.
What starts (and ends) as a courtroom drama, offers a lot of insight into the characters' past experiences, thoughts and feelings, so you really get to know them intimately and understand their actions throughout the book, even though they not always make the best decisions.
It is a sad and heartbreaking story with important themes like fairness, equality, justice and racism. It also portrays the treatment of Japanese American citizens in the 1930s, 40s and 50s. There are scenes in Japanese internal camps and during WWII battles that are actually hard to read. Especially since David Guterson's writes in a very detailed and sober way.
I really loved this book, it made me feel all kinds of emotions. I was angry, I was sad and frustrated, I cried several times. I also think the plotting was done really well, I did not know how it would end until the very last pages. Really enjoyed the trial and investigation parts and the way details were revealed piece by piece with some unexpected twists and turns. The majority of the book were the characters' flashbacks, though, and they dragged a little in the middle of the book when I wanted to know how the trial was proceeding. It was worth it in the end, though.
The atmosphere was amazing. The setting and the weather really added to the story for me. And I liked the writing style for the most part. There were just some weird choices the author made several times throughout the book. I was very confused by how often characters thought about sex, penises and breasts in very inappropriate moments. And again, these were describes in a very sober way, it was weird and actually unnecessary most of the time.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Confinement, Grief, Death, Injury/Injury detail, Racism, War, Gun violence, Racial slurs, Sexual content, Medical content, and Stalking
haileybones's review
challenging
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
Set in the 1950s on an island off the coast of Washington state, Snow Falling On Cedar is a court procedural novel. Told mostly through flashbacks through World War II and the arrest, imprisonment, and theft endured by Japanese-Americans at that time, there are several heavy themes throughout. The author focuses most on racism and the ways people are impacted by trauma. While the set-up is strong, the book ultimately felt too long and its resolutions rushed, unearned, and inauthentic.
David Guterson captures the setting and the people of San Piedro (a fictional island) in a romantic way that enveloped me in nostalgia because I spent a lot of time in Island County growing up. Those memories lent suspense to my experience of the earliest chapters, which I enjoyed. But even I became bored of the long, frequent descriptions of setting. This tendency to over-explain extended to the characters as well. I was walked through their lives in painstaking detail: family history, appearance, childhood, romance, combat experiences, and, unnecessarily in most cases, their sexual histories and preferences.
The issue of racism bears the marks of incomplete understanding. There are "good" moments, resonant characterizations of individual hate and prejudice manifesting into systemic injustices, but the Japanese and Japanese-American characters do not always feel as fully realized as their white counterparts. At times, they fall into into stoic, wooden stereotypes that feel emotionally dissonant to their personality. Some white characters are condemned by the text for their racism while others are allowed to justify their selfish, duplicitous hate without much consequence. In the end, I feltHatsue's instant forgiveness of Ishmael for his inappropriate incel pining and the concealment of crucial evidence of Kabuo's innocence was a step too far and tanked my final rating.
David Guterson captures the setting and the people of San Piedro (a fictional island) in a romantic way that enveloped me in nostalgia because I spent a lot of time in Island County growing up. Those memories lent suspense to my experience of the earliest chapters, which I enjoyed. But even I became bored of the long, frequent descriptions of setting. This tendency to over-explain extended to the characters as well. I was walked through their lives in painstaking detail: family history, appearance, childhood, romance, combat experiences, and, unnecessarily in most cases, their sexual histories and preferences.
The issue of racism bears the marks of incomplete understanding. There are "good" moments, resonant characterizations of individual hate and prejudice manifesting into systemic injustices, but the Japanese and Japanese-American characters do not always feel as fully realized as their white counterparts. At times, they fall into into stoic, wooden stereotypes that feel emotionally dissonant to their personality. Some white characters are condemned by the text for their racism while others are allowed to justify their selfish, duplicitous hate without much consequence. In the end, I felt
Content Warnings
Graphic: Medical trauma, Racism, Sexual content, Death, Gore, Misogyny, Gun violence, Injury/Injury detail, Racial slurs, Violence, War, and Xenophobia
Moderate: Hate crime, Murder, Sexual harassment, Toxic friendship, Toxic relationship, and Blood
Minor: Stalking and Infertility
More...