Scan barcode
kathydavie's review against another edition
5.0
Twenty-first in Inspector Ian Rutledge, the British historical detective mystery series that revolves around a Scotland Yard detective who struggles with PTSD and is haunted by the ghost of the corporal he had to shoot. This story starts in June 1910 in England.
My Take
It's all about the pursuit of truth, no matter what.
It's an intriguing start — and reminds me of Alex Grecian's The Yard (Scotland Yard's Murder Squad, 1), with its initial inciting incident. It also demonstrates Rutledge's compassion for his fellow man. A good turn that results in another.
We see the investigation through Ian's eyes in third person simple subjective point-of-view, hearing his thoughts, his emotions, his interpretation of the clues that begin to open up. And The Black Ascot drove me mad as Todd dribbled out these itty, bitty clues that started the wheels turning, making me wonder which way this revival of a cold case would go. How Ian would find Alan Barrington, and if he'd remember what actually happened at his front door.
It's some cast of characters! A few scummy ones, one who was truly evil, and quite a few decent ones. Along with a number who never spoke out, which doesn't say much for their characters. And I found it very interesting that Sergeant Gibson actually stood up for Rutledge several times...since Gibson doesn't like Rutledge.
I'm with Ian when it comes to wondering why the Yard didn't put some investigative feet on the ground when he "shot himself". Makes me wonder about that murder investigation during Black Ascot as well.
I do have a niggle. Sort of minor. But Todd was rather vague in a number of minor areas, including what Jane Warden was doing in that first house, and these little things drove me crazy.
The Story
It's the little things, the impressions that rouse Inspector Ian Rutledge's curiosity...and suspicions. Yes, the little things that begin to add up once Rutledge re-opens a ten-year-old murder case and re-examines the facts, the feelings. Those that didn't make it into any report.
Then his sanity is suddenly brought into question by a shocking turn of events. His sister Frances, Melinda Crawford, and Dr Fleming stand by him, but there is no greater shame than suicide. Questioning himself, he realizes that he cannot look back. The only way to save his career — much less his sanity — is to find Alan Barrington and bring him to justice.
But is this elusive murderer still in England?
The Characters
Inspector Ian Rutledge is a roving detective for Scotland Yard. Corporal Hamish McLeod is the soldier he was forced to shoot near the end of World War I. Frances is his beloved sister who married Peter a short while ago.
Melinda Crawford is an old family friend with high (and mighty) connections who lives in Kent. She also appears in Todd's Bess Crawford series. Shanta is her Indian housekeeper. Jason is the butler. Angeline is a gullible friend of Melinda's.
David Trevor is an architect and Ian's godfather who lives in Scotland. Morag is his housekeeper. Young Ian and Fiona are his grandchildren. Ross Trevor had been David's son and almost a brother to Ian.
Jean is the woman who broke off her engagement with Ian. Kate Gordon is her cousin (No Shred of Evidence, 18); Mrs Gordon is her mother and despises Ian.
Alan Barrington and two others, college friends, were all in love with Blanche Richmond. Only Alan is remanded for her murder. Ellis lives in Kenya and is the cousin who is Barrington's heir. Hathaway had been the old steward. Jonathan Strange is one of the partners at Broadhurst, Broadhurst, and Strange, the law firm that oversees the Barrington estates. Arnold Livingston is the current steward for the estate.
Blanche first married Mark Thorne. Harold Fletcher-Munro, a financial wizard, is her second husband. His London housekeeper is Mrs Shaw. Franklin is his driver.
St Mary's
The Richmonds were the squires of the village. The Hollands bought the Richmond home. The Ramseys were close friends of the family; their daughter, Louise, had been one of Blanche's friends. Louise married Donald Villiers who was killed in the war. Elizabeth works as a waitress at an inn.
Ullswater, Cumberland
Jane Warden was one of Blanche's best friends. Her fiancé, Robin, died. Mrs Davenport is the cook; Mrs Jordan is the housekeeper. During the war, Lieutenants Darling, Browning, and Clive Maitland and Captain Austin recuperated at the house. Mrs Rhodes is the housekeeper at Jane's own house.
Near Chichester, Sussex
Lorraine Belmont and her family have always been Catholic. Maud is the housekeeper? cook? Mark's father had been a solicitor. The bitter Sara Thorne, Mark's sister, still lives in the village.
Sandwich
Julia is Jonathan's sister married to a local solicitor, Gardener. Jonathan's father runs a jewelry store. Jonathan owns a house here which is run by Mr and Mrs Billingsley. The blind Alfred Morrow is a frequent visitor to the house. Mrs Porter is an aunt, I think. Oliver Ranson is the vicar.
Wendover, outside Dover
The overprotective Morrows live here. Rollins is their driver. Mrs Parkinson is their housekeeper. Williams is the lady's maid. (Lizzie is Williams' eldest sister. Nan is a sister who is housekeeper for an MP; Josephine is lady's maid to a barrister's wife; and, Marie had been a nursing Sister during the war and now works in Harley Stret.) Inspector Windom is investigating a murder and a beating. Sister Stevens is the nurse on duty that night; Sister Marvin in the morning. Jenny Harold had been a hooker with a heart.
Near Ascot
Frank and Sally Bradley had had a farm where the accident occurred. Nate Bradley is a third cousin who married Felicity Bradley, Frank's daughter, and now runs the farm. Freddy had been Frank's nephew, Felicity's cousin. Tommy is one of the farmhands today.
Helmsley, Gloucestershire
Constable Biggins takes offense. Mr Waters is a solicitor and Nell's uncle. Her father is the Vicar...and a coward.
Bramley, Worcestershire
Harold was the grandfather, John the father, and Clive Maitland the son who went to war after dying in a climbing accident. Dorian Alders is the rector at St James. Jasper is the family dog. And the Maitland home was sold to the Barnards who also took on the Maitland law firm. Mr Seton had been the previous rector.
Scotland Yard
Chief Superintendent Jameson is Rutledge's superior, and he hates Rutledge. Sergeant Gibson is Rutledge's contact at the Yard. Inspector Kendall is working a case. Chief Inspector Telford is assigned to the investigation at the end.
Dr Fleming is the psychiatrist who treated Rutledge after the war. Sister Peterson is one of the nurses at the clinic. Policemen who have died or retired since include Chief Inspector Hawkins, Inspector (Lieutenant) Johnson investigated Thorne's disappearance, Chief Superintendent Bowles was Rutledge's previous jerk of a boss, Constable Grant was the cop who was first on scene, and Inspector Putnam is the man Ian's father hoped could dissuade his son (Sally is his welcoming wife).
Jimsy Poole is a retired and famous journalist who now runs a bar. Millie "M.R." Hill wants to follow in her father's footsteps as a journalist.
Eddie Wade is an ex-convict, recently released. Mary is his wife, and they had two children: Timmy and Ellie. Sadie Milling is his nasty mother-in-law. His sister married Hans. Cousin Maude was also ashamed. Danny was a fellow inmate.
The Cover and Title
The cover is a misty grayish green of a stormy sky in the background. In the foreground, the silhouette of a jockey atop a horse clears a hurdle. At the very top in yellow is a very tiny testimonial while an info blurb, in yellow, is at least twice as big below that. The authors' name is below this in white, and the title is in yellow, slightly overlapping the horse.
The title refers to an event, The Black Ascot of 1910, when all the attendees at Ascot wore black in mourning for King Edward VII.
My Take
It's all about the pursuit of truth, no matter what.
It's an intriguing start — and reminds me of Alex Grecian's The Yard (Scotland Yard's Murder Squad, 1), with its initial inciting incident. It also demonstrates Rutledge's compassion for his fellow man. A good turn that results in another.
We see the investigation through Ian's eyes in third person simple subjective point-of-view, hearing his thoughts, his emotions, his interpretation of the clues that begin to open up. And The Black Ascot drove me mad as Todd dribbled out these itty, bitty clues that started the wheels turning, making me wonder which way this revival of a cold case would go. How Ian would find Alan Barrington, and if he'd remember what actually happened at his front door.
It's some cast of characters! A few scummy ones, one who was truly evil, and quite a few decent ones. Along with a number who never spoke out, which doesn't say much for their characters. And I found it very interesting that Sergeant Gibson actually stood up for Rutledge several times...since Gibson doesn't like Rutledge.
I'm with Ian when it comes to wondering why the Yard didn't put some investigative feet on the ground when he "shot himself". Makes me wonder about that murder investigation during Black Ascot as well.
I do have a niggle. Sort of minor. But Todd was rather vague in a number of minor areas, including what Jane Warden was doing in that first house, and these little things drove me crazy.
The Story
It's the little things, the impressions that rouse Inspector Ian Rutledge's curiosity...and suspicions. Yes, the little things that begin to add up once Rutledge re-opens a ten-year-old murder case and re-examines the facts, the feelings. Those that didn't make it into any report.
Then his sanity is suddenly brought into question by a shocking turn of events. His sister Frances, Melinda Crawford, and Dr Fleming stand by him, but there is no greater shame than suicide. Questioning himself, he realizes that he cannot look back. The only way to save his career — much less his sanity — is to find Alan Barrington and bring him to justice.
But is this elusive murderer still in England?
The Characters
Inspector Ian Rutledge is a roving detective for Scotland Yard. Corporal Hamish McLeod is the soldier he was forced to shoot near the end of World War I. Frances is his beloved sister who married Peter a short while ago.
Melinda Crawford is an old family friend with high (and mighty) connections who lives in Kent. She also appears in Todd's Bess Crawford series. Shanta is her Indian housekeeper. Jason is the butler. Angeline is a gullible friend of Melinda's.
David Trevor is an architect and Ian's godfather who lives in Scotland. Morag is his housekeeper. Young Ian and Fiona are his grandchildren. Ross Trevor had been David's son and almost a brother to Ian.
Jean is the woman who broke off her engagement with Ian. Kate Gordon is her cousin (No Shred of Evidence, 18); Mrs Gordon is her mother and despises Ian.
Alan Barrington and two others, college friends, were all in love with Blanche Richmond. Only Alan is remanded for her murder. Ellis lives in Kenya and is the cousin who is Barrington's heir. Hathaway had been the old steward. Jonathan Strange is one of the partners at Broadhurst, Broadhurst, and Strange, the law firm that oversees the Barrington estates. Arnold Livingston is the current steward for the estate.
Blanche first married Mark Thorne. Harold Fletcher-Munro, a financial wizard, is her second husband. His London housekeeper is Mrs Shaw. Franklin is his driver.
St Mary's
The Richmonds were the squires of the village. The Hollands bought the Richmond home. The Ramseys were close friends of the family; their daughter, Louise, had been one of Blanche's friends. Louise married Donald Villiers who was killed in the war. Elizabeth works as a waitress at an inn.
Ullswater, Cumberland
Jane Warden was one of Blanche's best friends. Her fiancé, Robin, died. Mrs Davenport is the cook; Mrs Jordan is the housekeeper. During the war, Lieutenants Darling, Browning, and Clive Maitland and Captain Austin recuperated at the house. Mrs Rhodes is the housekeeper at Jane's own house.
Near Chichester, Sussex
Lorraine Belmont and her family have always been Catholic. Maud is the housekeeper? cook? Mark's father had been a solicitor. The bitter Sara Thorne, Mark's sister, still lives in the village.
Sandwich
Julia is Jonathan's sister married to a local solicitor, Gardener. Jonathan's father runs a jewelry store. Jonathan owns a house here which is run by Mr and Mrs Billingsley. The blind Alfred Morrow is a frequent visitor to the house. Mrs Porter is an aunt, I think. Oliver Ranson is the vicar.
Wendover, outside Dover
The overprotective Morrows live here. Rollins is their driver. Mrs Parkinson is their housekeeper. Williams is the lady's maid. (Lizzie is Williams' eldest sister. Nan is a sister who is housekeeper for an MP; Josephine is lady's maid to a barrister's wife; and, Marie had been a nursing Sister during the war and now works in Harley Stret.) Inspector Windom is investigating a murder and a beating. Sister Stevens is the nurse on duty that night; Sister Marvin in the morning. Jenny Harold had been a hooker with a heart.
Near Ascot
Frank and Sally Bradley had had a farm where the accident occurred. Nate Bradley is a third cousin who married Felicity Bradley, Frank's daughter, and now runs the farm. Freddy had been Frank's nephew, Felicity's cousin. Tommy is one of the farmhands today.
Helmsley, Gloucestershire
Constable Biggins takes offense. Mr Waters is a solicitor and Nell's uncle. Her father is the Vicar...and a coward.
Bramley, Worcestershire
Harold was the grandfather, John the father, and Clive Maitland the son who went to war after dying in a climbing accident. Dorian Alders is the rector at St James. Jasper is the family dog. And the Maitland home was sold to the Barnards who also took on the Maitland law firm. Mr Seton had been the previous rector.
Scotland Yard
Chief Superintendent Jameson is Rutledge's superior, and he hates Rutledge. Sergeant Gibson is Rutledge's contact at the Yard. Inspector Kendall is working a case. Chief Inspector Telford is assigned to the investigation at the end.
Dr Fleming is the psychiatrist who treated Rutledge after the war. Sister Peterson is one of the nurses at the clinic. Policemen who have died or retired since include Chief Inspector Hawkins, Inspector (Lieutenant) Johnson investigated Thorne's disappearance, Chief Superintendent Bowles was Rutledge's previous jerk of a boss, Constable Grant was the cop who was first on scene, and Inspector Putnam is the man Ian's father hoped could dissuade his son (Sally is his welcoming wife).
Jimsy Poole is a retired and famous journalist who now runs a bar. Millie "M.R." Hill wants to follow in her father's footsteps as a journalist.
Eddie Wade is an ex-convict, recently released. Mary is his wife, and they had two children: Timmy and Ellie. Sadie Milling is his nasty mother-in-law. His sister married Hans. Cousin Maude was also ashamed. Danny was a fellow inmate.
The Cover and Title
The cover is a misty grayish green of a stormy sky in the background. In the foreground, the silhouette of a jockey atop a horse clears a hurdle. At the very top in yellow is a very tiny testimonial while an info blurb, in yellow, is at least twice as big below that. The authors' name is below this in white, and the title is in yellow, slightly overlapping the horse.
The title refers to an event, The Black Ascot of 1910, when all the attendees at Ascot wore black in mourning for King Edward VII.
valefimbres's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
kathieboucher's review against another edition
4.0
Semi-cozy and enjoyable although Inspector spends an awful lot of time driving around, back and forth, from place to place.
aoosterwyk's review against another edition
2.0
Lots of driving, back and forth, not my favorite of this series.
nicoleankenmann's review
4.0
Audiobook: 10hr 40m
Inspector Ian Rutledge is at his best in a mystery, and this woven tale is no exception. Another great installment in a series that I already love. Also, I could -- and do -- happily listen to Simon Prebble (narrator) all day long.
Keep them coming, Charles Todd!
Inspector Ian Rutledge is at his best in a mystery, and this woven tale is no exception. Another great installment in a series that I already love. Also, I could -- and do -- happily listen to Simon Prebble (narrator) all day long.
Keep them coming, Charles Todd!
400mom's review
4.0
I have read a few of the books in this series and they have grown on me. The time frame is just 100 years ago, after WWI, and it is surprising and sad what the attitude was toward returning soldiers who suffered from "shell shock".
alliepeduto's review
3.0
This was a solid historical mystery! While I felt like it was slightly meandering storyline, I ultimately really enjoyed the detective and the overall conclusion. There were so many little details scattered throughout the story, and the setting of post WWI hit all the right notes for me from a historical perspective. I felt the focus on mental health and the stigma that so many soldiers had to face was particularly poignant, and it serves to highlight how far as a society we have come and how far we still need to go.
nvdm's review against another edition
emotional
mysterious
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? N/A
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.75
abeth_parker's review against another edition
5.0
This is now one if my top fave Inspector Rutledge novels, along with "Legacy of the Dead" and "A Cold Treachery".
I enjoy all of the novels in this series, but some stand out, and this is one. It is well-paced, and keeps you guessing. I would not have guessed how this story turned out.
I enjoy all of the novels in this series, but some stand out, and this is one. It is well-paced, and keeps you guessing. I would not have guessed how this story turned out.
judyward's review against another edition
4.0
I would actually give this book a 4.5. I love the Inspector Ian Ruthledge books by Charles Todd and this one is no exception. My recommendation is to read these books in order because of the character development.