Scan barcode
aceinit's review
2.0
Review of the individual issues contained in this collection.
I have reached the point in my life where I can officially label myself a bitter old comics fan. I have also solidified my suspicion that I am not going to like the current run of Daredevil no matter what. Yes, comics get retconned all the time, and Marvel is worse about its tendency to do so than most, given it’s love for Changing!Everything!In Ways You Won’t Believe!during its exhausting and often chaotic event of the season.
So I guess I should preface all of my reviews of Soule’s Daredevil by saying I’m biased. Really biased. The preceeding volumes by Mark Waid, which suffered hardest under the current retcon, are some of my favorites. Though I am glad to see Matt back in New York where he belongs, the loss of central characters in his life like Foggy and Kirsten McDuffie hurts badly. The addition of the now especially-terribly-named Blindspot and strange ten-fingered villains do not make up for these losses and radical shifts.
And, in this volume, readers finally find out what happened and how Matt came to be back in New York, with his secret identity intact, a shattered friendship with Foggy and with Kirsten MIA. And, as far as revelation stories go, this one is pretty disappointing. I won’t go into spoilers because I’m writing a review for something that isn’t released yet in trade form, but Soule’s explanation for Matt’s current state of affairs does flash back to stories set up in Waid’s run. But it’s still just so…disappointing. Particularly as the catalyst for all this happening is one of my most hated tropes in all of fiction: the incompetent security guard.
Mild spoilers under the cut, mostly related to musings.
It’s sloppy writing, which leads to a sloppy playout of events. As our titular hero himself says,
There are some interesting items to come out of this volume, though, particularly Father Jordan, the priest Matt confides in, who is definitely more than he seems. I’m ready for a Father Jordan miniseries. Pretty please?
I’m going to keep reading Daredevil, because it’s Daredevil and I want it to eventually get back to a place I like. But I may as well stop holding my breath.
I have reached the point in my life where I can officially label myself a bitter old comics fan. I have also solidified my suspicion that I am not going to like the current run of Daredevil no matter what. Yes, comics get retconned all the time, and Marvel is worse about its tendency to do so than most, given it’s love for Changing!Everything!In Ways You Won’t Believe!during its exhausting and often chaotic event of the season.
So I guess I should preface all of my reviews of Soule’s Daredevil by saying I’m biased. Really biased. The preceeding volumes by Mark Waid, which suffered hardest under the current retcon, are some of my favorites. Though I am glad to see Matt back in New York where he belongs, the loss of central characters in his life like Foggy and Kirsten McDuffie hurts badly. The addition of the now especially-terribly-named Blindspot and strange ten-fingered villains do not make up for these losses and radical shifts.
And, in this volume, readers finally find out what happened and how Matt came to be back in New York, with his secret identity intact, a shattered friendship with Foggy and with Kirsten MIA. And, as far as revelation stories go, this one is pretty disappointing. I won’t go into spoilers because I’m writing a review for something that isn’t released yet in trade form, but Soule’s explanation for Matt’s current state of affairs does flash back to stories set up in Waid’s run. But it’s still just so…disappointing. Particularly as the catalyst for all this happening is one of my most hated tropes in all of fiction: the incompetent security guard.
Mild spoilers under the cut, mostly related to musings.
Spoiler
Now, if you are a guard in one of the places where the world’s worst supervillains are kept, I imagine you are going to be much better vetted and monitored than the guards in this volume are. Which leads to a predictable escape. Which leads to, well, everything else that got us here today.It’s sloppy writing, which leads to a sloppy playout of events. As our titular hero himself says,
Spoiler
“It’s the way children solve problems.” And the whole thing reeks of an overreach I just flat out don’t want to accept. But, again, maybe it’s just because I’m biased and bitter. I was expecting something larger, more significant, particularly given that this series kicked off following an event where Doom set himself up as god and remake the world in his image. But none of that is touched on here. It always seems to be Marvel’s way to have the major world-changing events only change some worlds, while seeming to ignore others. In this case, the event seems to have left Daredevil’s earth entirely unscathed.There are some interesting items to come out of this volume, though, particularly Father Jordan, the priest Matt confides in, who is definitely more than he seems. I’m ready for a Father Jordan miniseries. Pretty please?
I’m going to keep reading Daredevil, because it’s Daredevil and I want it to eventually get back to a place I like. But I may as well stop holding my breath.
helpfulsnowman's review
3.0
Bullseye should have to put an asterisk in his name:
Bullseye: The man who never* misses
*unless it's Daredevil, then he misses pretty frequently.
Bullseye: The man who never* misses
*unless it's Daredevil, then he misses pretty frequently.
mjfmjfmjf's review
3.0
A pretty good book. And it was nice to have a fairly decent explanation of how Matt got his secret identity back. But I just didn't like it much. And I'm not sure anything would make me happy with Marvel rewriting history yet again. Still Daredevil and Matt Murdock are written true to themselves. An okay book with good enough art. Just not a great book.
emmafong's review
2.0
"what if we took everything that emma really liked about the waid run and undid it?"
i wanted to like this run so badly, but i just feel like matt's character is super inconsistent.
i wanted to like this run so badly, but i just feel like matt's character is super inconsistent.
beorn_101's review
4.0
Wow, ok so normally I would be really disappointed that Blindspot isn't featured prominently in this, especially since last we saw he was in a bit of a predicament.
However, despite that disappointment, this volume really delivered. We finally find out how Daredevil's identity and past was wiped from public memory, and it is a fascinating discovery!
This volume, while lighter on the action, really delivers in the emotions and character insight, probably the best in the series since Vol 1.
However, despite that disappointment, this volume really delivered. We finally find out how Daredevil's identity and past was wiped from public memory, and it is a fascinating discovery!
This volume, while lighter on the action, really delivers in the emotions and character insight, probably the best in the series since Vol 1.
More...