Scan barcode
richardleis's review
5.0
First time subscriber, first issue of Analog I've read, and I loved everything in it!
Fiction
"Progress Report" by Ragnar Vajra follows the protagonist on an alien planet from their first conscience thoughts to increasing awareness and intelligence, as the mystery about how they came to be there and what they are meant to do unfolds. The technology involved in the protagonist's rapid development is so interesting and it also serves as a unique tool for the writer to fill in backstory and build the world. The characters' diction is a lot of fun and the diary-like telling over a span of several days is captivating.
"Detroit Hammersmith, Zero-Gravity Toilet Repairman (Retired)" by Suzanne Palmer brings the protagonist out of retirement to investigate failing toilets on a space station. What he finds leads to even bigger mysteries, and a role he wasn't expecting to play in diplomatic talks being held on the station. This is a really fun story with great characters and aliens and a nice twist that amusingly bugs the hell out of Hammersmith.
"Deep Waters Call Out to What is Deeper Still" by Sarah Frost presents a different mystery: what goes on in the mind of a squid? The protagonist is a scientist and animal mind-whisperer at a facility that hooks up animal like swordfish to their own virtual heavens. The history and ethics of such a zoo aren't really explored in this story, but the protagonist is a caring soul who goes out of zir way to make the transition for the animals as painless and fruitful as possible. The latest addition to the facility knows something is missing, and the protagonist must find out why the squid is so unhappy. There's a parallel plot of friendship, perhaps more, that leads to an emotional mind-melding moment.
I see some other reviewers struggled with the pronouns in this piece. I particularly liked how the story is not about the protagonist's gender identity, and that they simply refer to themselves with their preferred pronouns. I'm looking forward to more gender fluidity in my reading, without gender necessarily being the thrust of the plot. It's just nice to see people from a variety of backgrounds with various identities participating in thought-provoking science fiction stories.
"Silhouettes" by Dave Creek includes the personal notes and science reports of an 87 year old exoplanet explorer who for reasons to be revealed didn't bother to participate in rejuvenation technologies back on Earth. He's alone and studying the reproductive cycles of aliens on planet Keleni, a planet of short days and fierce winds. As details about the exoplanet and its aliens are revealed, so are those about his past. Another great story in an issue full of wonderful world-building.
"Adventures in Family Bonding" by W. Michael Beachy has a breezy title and writing style that belie the really dark places and dystopian future this story eventually reveals. It starts out simple enough: grandma gets a call from her son, wondering if she can babysit her grandson for a week or two. Something's not quite right about the relationship between mother and son, and things only get worse from there. The last image is terrifying, or maybe gratifying, depending on the reader.
"Dreams of the Rocket Men" by C. Stuart Hardwick recounts the youth of a boy caught up in his elderly neighbor's interest in rockets, and though the science fiction is light and comes nearer to the end, the fiction leading there is wonderful and heart-breaking in turn. A very heartfelt story.
"Nesting Dolls" by Jacob A. Boyd feels very alien and strange as it follows two boys onboard a generational vessel making its way across the void between the Milky Way and another galaxy. The vessel and its layers are inventive, as are the layers of storytelling. This is a gripping tale, one that is also quite dark and even cruel.
Finally, I almost missed the short poem on page 74, "Paint It Black" by Bruce Boston. In fact, I didn't miss it, but I didn't know what it was until I reread the table of contents just now. It's a very short poem. I would love to learn more about it.
Nonfiction
Trevor Quachri's opening editorial "Captain America's Bathroom" merges a little memoir with a survey of comic book superheroes and his maturing understanding of them, especially Captain America. There's a nice parallel drawn between discrimination against transgender people and Captain America's origins. Definitely a must-read.
Edward M. Lerner provides a quick primer in the first part of "A Mind of Its Own" about artificial intelligence. This is a good review of concepts we've been hearing a lot about in the field lately, and I was thankful for the summary. Looking forward to the second part!
My favorite essay in the issue is "Pluto's Perplexing Polygons" by Richard A. Lovett. Lots of great details and speculation about processes in Sputnik Planum on Pluto determined from the first close-up images taken by New Horizons last year. There's a quick summary of the mission, but the bulk of the essay is about models of the processes that form the polygons in Sputnik Planum, and what these models say about the youthfulness of this region. Pluto turned out to be beyond anyone's expectations, and this essay does a great job capturing that wonder and making me impatient for a Pluto-Charon orbiter!
Don Sakers has a nice list of books to check out in "The Reference Library," and spends some time surveying how science fiction and religion come together over time in various novels and short stories. It was fun reading about the first novel by Madeline Ashby titled Company Town because I was surprised to realize I knew the plot from a short story by her I read and enjoyed what seems like a long time ago. I'm going to have to check this one out.
Fiction
"Progress Report" by Ragnar Vajra follows the protagonist on an alien planet from their first conscience thoughts to increasing awareness and intelligence, as the mystery about how they came to be there and what they are meant to do unfolds. The technology involved in the protagonist's rapid development is so interesting and it also serves as a unique tool for the writer to fill in backstory and build the world. The characters' diction is a lot of fun and the diary-like telling over a span of several days is captivating.
"Detroit Hammersmith, Zero-Gravity Toilet Repairman (Retired)" by Suzanne Palmer brings the protagonist out of retirement to investigate failing toilets on a space station. What he finds leads to even bigger mysteries, and a role he wasn't expecting to play in diplomatic talks being held on the station. This is a really fun story with great characters and aliens and a nice twist that amusingly bugs the hell out of Hammersmith.
"Deep Waters Call Out to What is Deeper Still" by Sarah Frost presents a different mystery: what goes on in the mind of a squid? The protagonist is a scientist and animal mind-whisperer at a facility that hooks up animal like swordfish to their own virtual heavens. The history and ethics of such a zoo aren't really explored in this story, but the protagonist is a caring soul who goes out of zir way to make the transition for the animals as painless and fruitful as possible. The latest addition to the facility knows something is missing, and the protagonist must find out why the squid is so unhappy. There's a parallel plot of friendship, perhaps more, that leads to an emotional mind-melding moment.
I see some other reviewers struggled with the pronouns in this piece. I particularly liked how the story is not about the protagonist's gender identity, and that they simply refer to themselves with their preferred pronouns. I'm looking forward to more gender fluidity in my reading, without gender necessarily being the thrust of the plot. It's just nice to see people from a variety of backgrounds with various identities participating in thought-provoking science fiction stories.
"Silhouettes" by Dave Creek includes the personal notes and science reports of an 87 year old exoplanet explorer who for reasons to be revealed didn't bother to participate in rejuvenation technologies back on Earth. He's alone and studying the reproductive cycles of aliens on planet Keleni, a planet of short days and fierce winds. As details about the exoplanet and its aliens are revealed, so are those about his past. Another great story in an issue full of wonderful world-building.
"Adventures in Family Bonding" by W. Michael Beachy has a breezy title and writing style that belie the really dark places and dystopian future this story eventually reveals. It starts out simple enough: grandma gets a call from her son, wondering if she can babysit her grandson for a week or two. Something's not quite right about the relationship between mother and son, and things only get worse from there. The last image is terrifying, or maybe gratifying, depending on the reader.
"Dreams of the Rocket Men" by C. Stuart Hardwick recounts the youth of a boy caught up in his elderly neighbor's interest in rockets, and though the science fiction is light and comes nearer to the end, the fiction leading there is wonderful and heart-breaking in turn. A very heartfelt story.
"Nesting Dolls" by Jacob A. Boyd feels very alien and strange as it follows two boys onboard a generational vessel making its way across the void between the Milky Way and another galaxy. The vessel and its layers are inventive, as are the layers of storytelling. This is a gripping tale, one that is also quite dark and even cruel.
Finally, I almost missed the short poem on page 74, "Paint It Black" by Bruce Boston. In fact, I didn't miss it, but I didn't know what it was until I reread the table of contents just now. It's a very short poem. I would love to learn more about it.
Nonfiction
Trevor Quachri's opening editorial "Captain America's Bathroom" merges a little memoir with a survey of comic book superheroes and his maturing understanding of them, especially Captain America. There's a nice parallel drawn between discrimination against transgender people and Captain America's origins. Definitely a must-read.
Edward M. Lerner provides a quick primer in the first part of "A Mind of Its Own" about artificial intelligence. This is a good review of concepts we've been hearing a lot about in the field lately, and I was thankful for the summary. Looking forward to the second part!
My favorite essay in the issue is "Pluto's Perplexing Polygons" by Richard A. Lovett. Lots of great details and speculation about processes in Sputnik Planum on Pluto determined from the first close-up images taken by New Horizons last year. There's a quick summary of the mission, but the bulk of the essay is about models of the processes that form the polygons in Sputnik Planum, and what these models say about the youthfulness of this region. Pluto turned out to be beyond anyone's expectations, and this essay does a great job capturing that wonder and making me impatient for a Pluto-Charon orbiter!
Don Sakers has a nice list of books to check out in "The Reference Library," and spends some time surveying how science fiction and religion come together over time in various novels and short stories. It was fun reading about the first novel by Madeline Ashby titled Company Town because I was surprised to realize I knew the plot from a short story by her I read and enjoyed what seems like a long time ago. I'm going to have to check this one out.
tpietila's review
2.0
An uneven issue. Something pretty good, something pretty bad.
Progress Report • novella by Rajnar Vajra
Some sorts of animals slowly learn things day by day. Apparently, the food it eats gives it new information and even new memories. Memories of a strange alien creature, a human. And learning is interspaced by tests of character. Why is he getting alien memories and what are the tests for? An excellent story with interesting characters. ****
Detroit Hammersmith, Zero-Gravity Toilet Repairman (Retired) • novelette by Suzanne Palmer
An important diplomatic meeting is coming up on a space station and the toilets are clogging with strange frog-like creatures. What is going on? And what is most important, how can it be stopped so that the talks will not fail? Okay, humorous story, but it is nothing really exceptional and doesn’t really work for me. **½
Deep Waters Call Out to What is Deeper Still • shortstory by Sarah Frost
Fish in an aquarium are being taken care of in a virtual sea environment. A caretaker also somehow mends with their mind to evaluate if everything is going well. Then she is supposed to go into the mind of an octopus which is not adjusting. More of a scene than a real story. I would have liked more background and more details. I didn’t really care much for it. **½
Silhouettes • shortstory by Dave Creek
The old man is alone, observing strange animals on a planet with heavy winds. His health is failing and he ponders his life. It's a short bittersweet story. Apparently its the end of a character who has been in at least one earlier story by the same author. ***-
Dreams of the Rocket Men • novelette by C. Stuart Hardwick
A young man befriends an elderly man who builds and designs rockets. Together they design novel hobbyist rocket models and slowly that leads to a career for the young man. He eventually is part of a group who makes some real progress on a rocket design. A very good story which could have been longer. ****-
Nesting Dolls • novelette by Jacob A. Boyd
A slower than light generation ship is on its way to another galaxy (!!? A the author apparently doesn't have the slightest idea about distances between galaxies). For some strange reason the ship is built from concentric levels, so the oldest technology is used inside. When more advanced tech was designed on the Earth, ship was overtaken by a new one, and then the new level have been built over the old ship. (Hard to imagine more senseless and stupid approach). A child is kidnapped by inhabitants of a deeper level. Some stupid shit happens then and in the end the ship stops on different planets looking for a habitable one. Between galaxies? Usually the stories in Analog make some technological sense - I wonder if the current editor has any science education? The writing is slightly better than the plot and background, but it certainly couldn't have been worse. **-
Progress Report • novella by Rajnar Vajra
Some sorts of animals slowly learn things day by day. Apparently, the food it eats gives it new information and even new memories. Memories of a strange alien creature, a human. And learning is interspaced by tests of character. Why is he getting alien memories and what are the tests for? An excellent story with interesting characters. ****
Detroit Hammersmith, Zero-Gravity Toilet Repairman (Retired) • novelette by Suzanne Palmer
An important diplomatic meeting is coming up on a space station and the toilets are clogging with strange frog-like creatures. What is going on? And what is most important, how can it be stopped so that the talks will not fail? Okay, humorous story, but it is nothing really exceptional and doesn’t really work for me. **½
Deep Waters Call Out to What is Deeper Still • shortstory by Sarah Frost
Fish in an aquarium are being taken care of in a virtual sea environment. A caretaker also somehow mends with their mind to evaluate if everything is going well. Then she is supposed to go into the mind of an octopus which is not adjusting. More of a scene than a real story. I would have liked more background and more details. I didn’t really care much for it. **½
Silhouettes • shortstory by Dave Creek
The old man is alone, observing strange animals on a planet with heavy winds. His health is failing and he ponders his life. It's a short bittersweet story. Apparently its the end of a character who has been in at least one earlier story by the same author. ***-
Dreams of the Rocket Men • novelette by C. Stuart Hardwick
A young man befriends an elderly man who builds and designs rockets. Together they design novel hobbyist rocket models and slowly that leads to a career for the young man. He eventually is part of a group who makes some real progress on a rocket design. A very good story which could have been longer. ****-
Nesting Dolls • novelette by Jacob A. Boyd
A slower than light generation ship is on its way to another galaxy (!!? A the author apparently doesn't have the slightest idea about distances between galaxies). For some strange reason the ship is built from concentric levels, so the oldest technology is used inside. When more advanced tech was designed on the Earth, ship was overtaken by a new one, and then the new level have been built over the old ship. (Hard to imagine more senseless and stupid approach). A child is kidnapped by inhabitants of a deeper level. Some stupid shit happens then and in the end the ship stops on different planets looking for a habitable one. Between galaxies? Usually the stories in Analog make some technological sense - I wonder if the current editor has any science education? The writing is slightly better than the plot and background, but it certainly couldn't have been worse. **-
sarrie's review
4.0
This was my first actual print copy of this magazine. There were a few great stories, and a few ok stories. I definitely enjoyed it, and will try and pick up the next issue. I particularly liked the first and I believe it was the second story. I didn't particularly pay attention to the non-fiction while reading this, it was my sick day reads the past few days, but I'll keep it on the shelf to return to. The AI article looked fairly interesting, if not a bit dense for my fevered brain.
More...