Scan barcode
kellyhager's review
5.0
I read Wuthering Heights in college but I didn't really remember it. (Actually at the same time I read Jane Eyre, which April Linder has also updated/reimagined, although I haven't read Jane yet.) I mention that so if you haven't read Wuthering Heights, you know that's not a prerequisite for loving Catherine.
There is a lot of Wuthering Heights in this, at least in terms of Hence/Heathcliff being incredibly moody and Catherine being incredibly privileged, but it's also completely its own novel. I don't remember Catherine's daughter being a big piece of Wuthering Heights, but again, I haven't read it in almost 15 years.
While I loved both stories (the flashbacks of Catherine and the modern-day story of Chelsea trying to learn about her mom), I think I preferred Chelsea. Both are great, however, and neither aspect of the story dragged for me.
I think people who love Wuthering Heights will find much to enjoy in this retelling, but again, it's not at all mandatory to have read (or liked) Wuthering Heights.
I do want to re-read it now and I also really want to read Jane.
Highly recommended.
There is a lot of Wuthering Heights in this, at least in terms of Hence/Heathcliff being incredibly moody and Catherine being incredibly privileged, but it's also completely its own novel. I don't remember Catherine's daughter being a big piece of Wuthering Heights, but again, I haven't read it in almost 15 years.
While I loved both stories (the flashbacks of Catherine and the modern-day story of Chelsea trying to learn about her mom), I think I preferred Chelsea. Both are great, however, and neither aspect of the story dragged for me.
I think people who love Wuthering Heights will find much to enjoy in this retelling, but again, it's not at all mandatory to have read (or liked) Wuthering Heights.
I do want to re-read it now and I also really want to read Jane.
Highly recommended.
More...