Reviews

I loved the complex personalities and plot of the sisters in little women. The characters and plots of these short stories were one dimensional in comparison.

lindapatin's review against another edition

Go to review page

lighthearted

4.0

msutton7613's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Three short stories written by LMA. Quaint cute stories. Good for preteen girls. Simpler times but some was sad.

Good to read around Christmas time.

dwheeler11's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Happy stories, where people are truly nice and kind (even though they sometimes need help to discover it), and everything works out well in the end.

etwal_lanwit's review

Go to review page

fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

2.0

pixieauthoress's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Although the title of this book is "Kate's Choice" there are actually two other stories, "What Love Can Do" and "Gwen's Adventure in the Snow." I have to admit that the last story is actually my favourite, not the main one. Written for newspapers or magazines when Alcott was first embarking on her writing career, these remained undiscovered until recently. Each of the stories centres around Christmas in some way. In the title-story, Kate is left orphaned just before Christmas and moves from England to America to be with her father's relatives. It was his wish that she visit each of his brothers in turn and choose who she wanted to live with. But Kate discovers her father's mother, alone in her big family home, and sets about bringing all of the relatives together at Christmas in order to cheer up her grandmother. In "What Love Can Do" the neighbours of a poverty-stricken family overhear the children talking about how they can't afford any Christmas gifts and decided to surprise them. And in my personal favourite, "Gwen's Adventure in the Snow", Gwen and her cousins go for a sleigh ride and are struck by a blizzard. Sheltering in the family summer house, they have to make do with the few supplies they can scrounge and camp out until the storm is over. I think this one is my favourite because, as a child, I always adored stories about children "playing house" with the odds and ends that they discover in a shed, cellar, tree-house, abandoned house, etc.

This book would be perfect for any Alcott fan, young or old. The editor has included lots of background information about Alcott, her writing and what can be learned from these stories, which would be interesting to a collector. And the shortness of the stories and the large print make the book perfect for a child who has enjoyed having "Little Women" read to them but isn't ready for full-length chapter books yet. While those unfamiliar with Alcott's work may find the stories rather predictable, long-standing fans will adore this and recognise her typical characters and values immediately. The presentation of this book is also beautiful, a little hardback with a lovely cover and illustrations and decorative fonts throughout. The perfect stocking filler for a girl who loves old-fashioned stories. 8/10

More...