Reviews

Charm City: A Walk Through Baltimore by Madison Smartt Bell

gphamadi's review

Go to review page

3.0

maybe one day i'll pick this book up again, but as someone who just wants to know baltimore a little bit better while living nearby but only traveling to it maybe once a month...the book is frustratingly visual but not visual enough. i like the concept - literally, just an author ambling through different neighborhoods and whatnot, attempting to tell snapshots of peoples and buildings passing by, but it was just that -- little blurbs rather than a full narrative that drew me in.

yulelogue's review

Go to review page

3.0

It’s fine. Probably more useful if you are planning a trip to Baltimore. I thought the final chapter was out of place. And there’s a middle section where the writer is at a club watching his buddy’s band that was pretty boring and outside the scope of the overall book.

ejdecoster's review

Go to review page

2.0

Meh.

shnuggs's review

Go to review page

2.0

I really wanted to like this book - it's about Baltimore, particularly parts that I know and love. The author, a noted novelist who also teaches at Goucher, takes a number of walks through different stretches of Baltimore - a walk down York Road from Northern Parkway to the Inner Harbor, a walk up Charles Street (which I do myself at least thrre times a week), a walk through Dickeyville (never did this one but it sounds fun). What bothered me was there were a bunch of factual errors - he mentioned streets crossing each other that are in fact parallel, he cites a local foundation's office being on he wrong street - things that would have been so easy to fact-check. It wasn't an awful book but it was disappointing.

lanikei's review

Go to review page

4.0

Picked this book up for my dad's Xmas present since he had really enjoyed his visit earlier this year. While I was waiting to be picked up, I started skimming the first few pages and got totally sucked in. I had to wrap up his copy, but fortunately Cristin had a copy herself.

Borrowed Cristin's copy and TORE THROUGH IT. I think my dad will love it.

The book is essentially a walking tour through some areas of Baltimore and includes the author's reflections, local history, and a lot of local flavor. He is joined on his walk by several locals, including [author: Laura Lippmann], the author of the Tess Monaghan mysteries. He walks up the same stretch of Charles that I walked twice a day, and there haven't been all that many changes apparently.

The bits that the author walks through are fascinating and neatly described in all their glory - and lack thereof. He touches on little bits of Baltimore history that show some of the quirks of the city. Unfortunately, he spends more time than necessary on some things - his description of a Latin dance club comes to mind - and doesn't take a particularly extensive tour of the city. I don't think it's much of a travel guide, but it does give a feel for the mood of the neighborhoods he crosses through.

I was disappointed that he didn't make it through Hampden since I find that to be a particularly intriguing neighborhood that I'm sure has many interesting stories and factoids hidden under its kitsch. He also doesn't touch on the Painted Ladies - the Victorian houses so frequently photographed. In fact, there aren't photos in the book at all, which is a shame.

I did love this book, though I'll give it 4 stars since I don't think the execution was absolutely perfect. Still, highly recommended if you are new to Baltimore, like me, or like learning weird local history in a narrative writing style.
More...