Scan barcode
mooncheye's review against another edition
dark
emotional
funny
hopeful
mysterious
medium-paced
4.25
tonimarshall84's review against another edition
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.75
kcfromaustcrime's review against another edition
1.0
FORBIDDEN FRUIT is the 5th book in the Corinna Chapman series by Australian author Kerry Greenwood (probably best known for her Phryne Fisher series). These books are set in modern day, inner Melbourne, are also on the cosier end of the scale. There are enough elements that coincide in both series to make fans of one feel somewhat comfortable in the other. Having never read any of the earlier books in this series, though, I can't comment on whether FORBIDDEN FRUIT is particularly representative, so I comment on it in isolation.
Corrina is a woman who has turned to baking after a life in the professions. Happier, content to the point of delirious, she is even able to just cope with the 4.00am starts. Living in very idealised circumstances, she has a happy home life in a building full of bohemian type characters, all living their own somewhat unorthodox lives. A content love life with Daniel, the main thing making Corinna grumpy in this book is Christmas.
Basically the story is that Daniel, the private investigator, is trying to track down two teenage runaways. Pregnant Brigid and the father of her baby Manny. Neither parents approve of either of the couple, Brigid has been locked up at home awaiting the birth of the unwanted (by her family) child, when she escapes and hits the streets with Manny. Daniel wants to find them because he's been asked by her parents, Corinna wants to find them because she's worried for Brigid's health. Along the way they are assisted / distracted by nuns who run a soup kitchen bus, freegans, maniacal mothers, thunderstorms and naked dancing witches, a donkey named Serena, glace cherries, the heat of a long hot Melbourne summer and meals which are described in somewhat minute detail.
Whilst it could be that all these distractions - and to be frank - meandering down a simply astounding number of irrelevant byways and cul-de-sacs is part of the charm of these books, in FORBIDDEN FRUIT, it just seemed to go on, and on, and on, and on. As did the none-too-subtle hinting about the joys of bohemia and alternative lifestyles and finding your inner whatevers. Not that I'm opposed to any of the elements that were raised by this book - but I just found that the constant bombardment and distractions ended up, well tedious. Every time the plot tried to progress a little, the reader was suddenly down one of those cul-de-sacs with a whinge about something (really, if you don't like Christmas decoration shopping then just don't do it!), or a lauding of "insert bandwagon here". Yes, I know these books are fictional and idealised, and maybe that's part of the problem - I prefer idealised fiction that "shows" rather than "crows".
There are some glimpses of parallels between elements of these books and the Phyrne Fisher series that were interesting - a similar sort of independent, feisty female character with an abandonment of normal conventions. But in FORBIDDEN FRUIT everything just seemed a little too over the top, a little too arch, a little too preachy for comfort. Perhaps this is a book for fans of the series, perhaps there's something about not reading the earlier books that means I missed the point.
Corrina is a woman who has turned to baking after a life in the professions. Happier, content to the point of delirious, she is even able to just cope with the 4.00am starts. Living in very idealised circumstances, she has a happy home life in a building full of bohemian type characters, all living their own somewhat unorthodox lives. A content love life with Daniel, the main thing making Corinna grumpy in this book is Christmas.
Basically the story is that Daniel, the private investigator, is trying to track down two teenage runaways. Pregnant Brigid and the father of her baby Manny. Neither parents approve of either of the couple, Brigid has been locked up at home awaiting the birth of the unwanted (by her family) child, when she escapes and hits the streets with Manny. Daniel wants to find them because he's been asked by her parents, Corinna wants to find them because she's worried for Brigid's health. Along the way they are assisted / distracted by nuns who run a soup kitchen bus, freegans, maniacal mothers, thunderstorms and naked dancing witches, a donkey named Serena, glace cherries, the heat of a long hot Melbourne summer and meals which are described in somewhat minute detail.
Whilst it could be that all these distractions - and to be frank - meandering down a simply astounding number of irrelevant byways and cul-de-sacs is part of the charm of these books, in FORBIDDEN FRUIT, it just seemed to go on, and on, and on, and on. As did the none-too-subtle hinting about the joys of bohemia and alternative lifestyles and finding your inner whatevers. Not that I'm opposed to any of the elements that were raised by this book - but I just found that the constant bombardment and distractions ended up, well tedious. Every time the plot tried to progress a little, the reader was suddenly down one of those cul-de-sacs with a whinge about something (really, if you don't like Christmas decoration shopping then just don't do it!), or a lauding of "insert bandwagon here". Yes, I know these books are fictional and idealised, and maybe that's part of the problem - I prefer idealised fiction that "shows" rather than "crows".
There are some glimpses of parallels between elements of these books and the Phyrne Fisher series that were interesting - a similar sort of independent, feisty female character with an abandonment of normal conventions. But in FORBIDDEN FRUIT everything just seemed a little too over the top, a little too arch, a little too preachy for comfort. Perhaps this is a book for fans of the series, perhaps there's something about not reading the earlier books that means I missed the point.
cimorene1558's review against another edition
4.0
Clearly Corinna and I like a lot of the same things! Cats, Vaughan Williams (especially the divine Fantasia on Christmas), Beverley Nichols, baking and eating the same kinds of things (except sushi--I have an aversion to seaweed and fishiness generally), and that's just in this book! I had to read it out of order because I'm enjoying these so much and I have to wait for the 4th one!
marlynb's review against another edition
5.0
Christmas in Melbourne, Australia. Corinna Chapman hates it.
She hates the heat, the humidity, the crowds of grumpy Christmas shoppers, and most especially, the inane Christmas "music" that seems to be broadcast everywhere.
Daniel, Corinna's lover, has a case. He's searching for a pregnant teenager who has run away from her controlling, fundamentalist Christian parents. Although Daniel has been employed by the parents, he's determined that he won't force the girl to return to them against her will.
As well as supplying baked goods for the greedy Christmas public (with the help of her able apprentice Jason, and shop-assitants Kylie and Gossamer), Corinna feels an obligation to help Daniel in his quest.
Corinna's life is delightfully quirky, comfortable and eminently enviable. She lives in an 8-storey apartment building called Insula, with an motley group of residents who have become a family of sorts caring for and celebrating with each other, the perpetually peevish Mrs. Pemberthy excepted. She is a strong, independent woman who is comfortable being a size 20 (bakers shouldn't be skinny!), and more of her adventures are welcome.
She hates the heat, the humidity, the crowds of grumpy Christmas shoppers, and most especially, the inane Christmas "music" that seems to be broadcast everywhere.
Daniel, Corinna's lover, has a case. He's searching for a pregnant teenager who has run away from her controlling, fundamentalist Christian parents. Although Daniel has been employed by the parents, he's determined that he won't force the girl to return to them against her will.
As well as supplying baked goods for the greedy Christmas public (with the help of her able apprentice Jason, and shop-assitants Kylie and Gossamer), Corinna feels an obligation to help Daniel in his quest.
Corinna's life is delightfully quirky, comfortable and eminently enviable. She lives in an 8-storey apartment building called Insula, with an motley group of residents who have become a family of sorts caring for and celebrating with each other, the perpetually peevish Mrs. Pemberthy excepted. She is a strong, independent woman who is comfortable being a size 20 (bakers shouldn't be skinny!), and more of her adventures are welcome.
elizaeliza's review
4.0
3.5 stars
The mystery in this book is simpler and more streamlined than the other Corrina Chapmans and, combined with being set at Christmas time, made this feel a bit like a Christmas special. Because the mystery elements were somewhat strung out (although they came together very satisfyingly at the end) I was a bit bored in early parts especially in long contemplations about cats and what it is to have pets. But that's Corrina, that's her world.
It was a lovely relaxing book to read in the recent extreme heat.
The mystery in this book is simpler and more streamlined than the other Corrina Chapmans and, combined with being set at Christmas time, made this feel a bit like a Christmas special. Because the mystery elements were somewhat strung out (although they came together very satisfyingly at the end) I was a bit bored in early parts especially in long contemplations about cats and what it is to have pets. But that's Corrina, that's her world.
It was a lovely relaxing book to read in the recent extreme heat.
chayes77's review against another edition
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0