Scan barcode
kathydavie's review
3.0
First in the SPQR historical mystery series revolving around Decius Caecilius Metellus and his interest in snooping, LOL.
My Take
Roberts is using a first-person narration, and it's odd to hear him tell us what's happening now AND of various characters' futures at the same time. Useful, but odd. It does, however, contribute to my feeling of being hit over the head. As though I'm not bright enough to pick up on the clues.
That bit when Roberts introduces the forensics aspect of it with Asklepiodes and his wounds study helped that feeling along. Definitely an eye-rolling moment. The overt patriotism Decius proclaims is very admirable, but it has a juvenile feel to it. It doesn't help that Decius stumbles over so many clues that should have had him questioning events and people much earlier in the story.
Roberts does spend a lot of time informing us of the history of wars and Roman politics; I'm assuming it's to ensure we have a background against which we can follow along with the clues. I just wish it didn't feel quite so much as if he were telling us. Decius' consultation with Cicero, however, was very well done in providing us with background information but disguised as advice.
Like Steven Saylor in Roman Blood, Roberts also relays Roman customs of daily and religious life. There's more of an emphasis in this one on the military service required of Roman men, and a tremendous importance on putting on the toga when paying calls or anytime you want to impress people. I'm also grateful for our current religious practices---I'd hate to be so beholden to omens and portents!
There's a very useful explanation of the difference between plebeians and patricians. Hmm, Roberts has made me curious about Spartacus. All I know is about the movie and that he had been a slave. Now I want to know more.
It's been an interesting blend of books I've been reading lately, and it's set me to thinking about life before radio, television, and the Internet. When people had to entertain themselves. They learned to play instruments, memorize poems and plays, hold dances, perform in theatricals. As much as I love my TV and Internet, I do wish we had a bit more of the community involvement. Yes, and then my second thought, but don't make me participate. Oh, brother, I'm such a hypocrite!
It's obvious from the start that Decius isn't expected to do more than sign off on the investigation. It's also obvious that he's a conservative thinker.
LOL, I did like how Sergius Paulus got around the matter of the disbursement of his estate and slaves!
I'm having a hard time warming up to this. I like the characters---they're certainly colorful!---but there's a feeling of detachment, a coldness to this. And I find I'm getting confused between Saylor's Roma Sub Rosa and Roberts' SPQR. I like Saylor's tale more---it's warmer and pulls me in with the characters as opposed to viewing them---and I'll likely read Saylor's series first.
The Story
A fire at Paramedes' warehouse and a series of murders creates a stir of interest around Metellus the Younger. And it soon becomes obvious that he's expected to stamp this case closed.
The Characters
Decius Caecilius Metellus the Younger is serving as a commissioner for the Commission of Twenty-six and has discovered he has a flair for snooping. Burrus is an old soldier and part of Decius' required entourage. Cato is one of his slaves, the janitor or doorkeeper.
Decius Caecilius Metellus the Elder, a.k.a., Cut-Nose, served under General Marius and is now an Urban Praetor; he'll stand for Consul in two years. The Caecilii Metelli are a plebeian nobility with the only real negative that they are not qualified for certain priesthoods---young Decius sees this as a plus. Aunt Caecilia, the Vestal, was now the Virgo Maxima, the head of the college and of the Temple of the Vestals. The Metellis' patron is Quintus Hortensius Hortalus (his character also appears in Steven Saylor's Roma Sub Rosa series).
Publius Claudis Pulcher is a young hothead and planning to change his patrician status and become a Clodius instead. Claudia is his much brighter sister with plans of her own. Chrysis is her maid. Prince Tigranes of Armenia is on the run from his father, King Tigranes the Elder.
Caius Julius Caesar seems to have shed his propensity for debauchery and debt to pursue a career in politics. On the side of the Populares, no less! He's currently married to Cornelia, a daughter of Cinna. [Decius says that he is "the most brilliantly cold-blooded schemer".] General Marcus Licinius Crassus is one of the richest and a Consul of Rome along with Pompey. And Roberts repeats the "rumors" of Crassus' habit of being the first at a fire.
Sergius Paulus is a freedman, but one of the richest men in Rome. Pepi is the slave who sleeps across his bedroom door. Marcus Ager was another freeman who used to fight under the name of Sinistrus. Paramedes is an Asian Greek from Antioch, and the pirates' representative in Rome. Zabbai is a silk merchant. Hasdrubal sells cloth in Ostia.
Macro is a gang boss with political connections, including being a client of Hortensius. Titus Annius Milo is a former rower who now works for Macro. I suspect he'll be a regular in the cast. A good thing, if so, as I do like him.
General Lucius Licinius Lucullus is battling Mithridates, Rome's most current enemy, and is under fire in Rome. Tribune Gnaeus Quintilius Carbo brings news of the war and Decius gives him warning.
Lucius Satilius runs the gladiator school, Ludus Satilius. Asklepiodes is the physician who has done a study of wounds.
The cautious Rutilius is Commissioner for the Trans-Tiber district; Optimius is Commissioner in charge of the Aventine, Palatine, and Caelian districts. Junius is the Senate freedman who acts as secretary. Quintus Curius is an "extraordinarily dissipated young Senator. Cicero is here as is Tiro, his secretary slave. Lucius Sergius Catilina.
The Forum had been a mass of temples, market stalls, fortune teller's booths, speakers' platforms, a place for men to idle, etc.
The Cover
The cover is gorgeous with a man's surprised face done in a Roman-style mosaic, blood pooling along his jawline and banded top and bottom with marble.
The title is a chess move and I'm not sure if it's Roberts' play on King's Gambit being the first in a series or if it refers to Decius' move within this story.
My Take
Roberts is using a first-person narration, and it's odd to hear him tell us what's happening now AND of various characters' futures at the same time. Useful, but odd. It does, however, contribute to my feeling of being hit over the head. As though I'm not bright enough to pick up on the clues.
That bit when Roberts introduces the forensics aspect of it with Asklepiodes and his wounds study helped that feeling along. Definitely an eye-rolling moment. The overt patriotism Decius proclaims is very admirable, but it has a juvenile feel to it. It doesn't help that Decius stumbles over so many clues that should have had him questioning events and people much earlier in the story.
Roberts does spend a lot of time informing us of the history of wars and Roman politics; I'm assuming it's to ensure we have a background against which we can follow along with the clues. I just wish it didn't feel quite so much as if he were telling us. Decius' consultation with Cicero, however, was very well done in providing us with background information but disguised as advice.
Like Steven Saylor in Roman Blood, Roberts also relays Roman customs of daily and religious life. There's more of an emphasis in this one on the military service required of Roman men, and a tremendous importance on putting on the toga when paying calls or anytime you want to impress people. I'm also grateful for our current religious practices---I'd hate to be so beholden to omens and portents!
There's a very useful explanation of the difference between plebeians and patricians. Hmm, Roberts has made me curious about Spartacus. All I know is about the movie and that he had been a slave. Now I want to know more.
"I'm learning street-level politics from Macro."
"And you're learning Senate-level politics from me," I said.
"You're right. And so far, it looks just like the street."
It's been an interesting blend of books I've been reading lately, and it's set me to thinking about life before radio, television, and the Internet. When people had to entertain themselves. They learned to play instruments, memorize poems and plays, hold dances, perform in theatricals. As much as I love my TV and Internet, I do wish we had a bit more of the community involvement. Yes, and then my second thought, but don't make me participate. Oh, brother, I'm such a hypocrite!
It's obvious from the start that Decius isn't expected to do more than sign off on the investigation. It's also obvious that he's a conservative thinker.
LOL, I did like how Sergius Paulus got around the matter of the disbursement of his estate and slaves!
I'm having a hard time warming up to this. I like the characters---they're certainly colorful!---but there's a feeling of detachment, a coldness to this. And I find I'm getting confused between Saylor's Roma Sub Rosa and Roberts' SPQR. I like Saylor's tale more---it's warmer and pulls me in with the characters as opposed to viewing them---and I'll likely read Saylor's series first.
The Story
A fire at Paramedes' warehouse and a series of murders creates a stir of interest around Metellus the Younger. And it soon becomes obvious that he's expected to stamp this case closed.
The Characters
Decius Caecilius Metellus the Younger is serving as a commissioner for the Commission of Twenty-six and has discovered he has a flair for snooping. Burrus is an old soldier and part of Decius' required entourage. Cato is one of his slaves, the janitor or doorkeeper.
Decius Caecilius Metellus the Elder, a.k.a., Cut-Nose, served under General Marius and is now an Urban Praetor; he'll stand for Consul in two years. The Caecilii Metelli are a plebeian nobility with the only real negative that they are not qualified for certain priesthoods---young Decius sees this as a plus. Aunt Caecilia, the Vestal, was now the Virgo Maxima, the head of the college and of the Temple of the Vestals. The Metellis' patron is Quintus Hortensius Hortalus (his character also appears in Steven Saylor's Roma Sub Rosa series).
Publius Claudis Pulcher is a young hothead and planning to change his patrician status and become a Clodius instead. Claudia is his much brighter sister with plans of her own. Chrysis is her maid. Prince Tigranes of Armenia is on the run from his father, King Tigranes the Elder.
Caius Julius Caesar seems to have shed his propensity for debauchery and debt to pursue a career in politics. On the side of the Populares, no less! He's currently married to Cornelia, a daughter of Cinna. [Decius says that he is "the most brilliantly cold-blooded schemer".] General Marcus Licinius Crassus is one of the richest and a Consul of Rome along with Pompey. And Roberts repeats the "rumors" of Crassus' habit of being the first at a fire.
Sergius Paulus is a freedman, but one of the richest men in Rome. Pepi is the slave who sleeps across his bedroom door. Marcus Ager was another freeman who used to fight under the name of Sinistrus. Paramedes is an Asian Greek from Antioch, and the pirates' representative in Rome. Zabbai is a silk merchant. Hasdrubal sells cloth in Ostia.
Macro is a gang boss with political connections, including being a client of Hortensius. Titus Annius Milo is a former rower who now works for Macro. I suspect he'll be a regular in the cast. A good thing, if so, as I do like him.
General Lucius Licinius Lucullus is battling Mithridates, Rome's most current enemy, and is under fire in Rome. Tribune Gnaeus Quintilius Carbo brings news of the war and Decius gives him warning.
Lucius Satilius runs the gladiator school, Ludus Satilius. Asklepiodes is the physician who has done a study of wounds.
The cautious Rutilius is Commissioner for the Trans-Tiber district; Optimius is Commissioner in charge of the Aventine, Palatine, and Caelian districts. Junius is the Senate freedman who acts as secretary. Quintus Curius is an "extraordinarily dissipated young Senator. Cicero is here as is Tiro, his secretary slave. Lucius Sergius Catilina.
The Forum had been a mass of temples, market stalls, fortune teller's booths, speakers' platforms, a place for men to idle, etc.
The Cover
The cover is gorgeous with a man's surprised face done in a Roman-style mosaic, blood pooling along his jawline and banded top and bottom with marble.
The title is a chess move and I'm not sure if it's Roberts' play on King's Gambit being the first in a series or if it refers to Decius' move within this story.
suzemo's review
4.0
April 2018 review-
Wow, I hadn't even realized that I'd already listened to this book (I guess the audible app barfing my data was useful after all), but I quite liked it. Maybe it's because I was more in the mood for this book?
Fictional Decius Caecilius Metellus, a Roman citizen and office holder, is living in Rome populated with real historical figures - he even interacts with them and makes them part of his investigations. This was a really fun little murder-mystery and I will be following up with the series to see if they continue the same style - I quite liked it, and Simon Vance did a great job of narrating (as always).
May 2015 review -
On it's face, I should love this book - it is the first of a series that takes place in Roman late-Republic/early-Empire times. It's a mystery/thriller with all kinds of fun Roman politics thrown in, but I just couldn't get into it or really enjoy it.
Wow, I hadn't even realized that I'd already listened to this book (I guess the audible app barfing my data was useful after all), but I quite liked it. Maybe it's because I was more in the mood for this book?
Fictional Decius Caecilius Metellus, a Roman citizen and office holder, is living in Rome populated with real historical figures - he even interacts with them and makes them part of his investigations. This was a really fun little murder-mystery and I will be following up with the series to see if they continue the same style - I quite liked it, and Simon Vance did a great job of narrating (as always).
May 2015 review -
On it's face, I should love this book - it is the first of a series that takes place in Roman late-Republic/early-Empire times. It's a mystery/thriller with all kinds of fun Roman politics thrown in, but I just couldn't get into it or really enjoy it.
sandin954's review
3.0
Another historical this one set in ancient Rome. Young Decius Caecilius Metellus is charged with looking into two murders in his district in Rome but finds they might be part of a larger conspiracy. Simon Vance is fast becoming one of my favorite narrators.
tessisreading2's review
3.0
Roberts is very concerned that we know how clever he is, and also that his fictional narrator is The Coolest Ever, whether fighting crime or having threesomes. It was tolerable but not much more.
veronica87's review
3.0
3.5 stars
I listened to the audiobook for this tale of murder in ancient Rome. I can't swear that I followed the plot 100% of the time but I liked the main protagonist, his rather dry humor, and his cynical POV. The narrator added an extra layer of murderous fun.
Story: 3 stars
Narration: 4 stars
I listened to the audiobook for this tale of murder in ancient Rome. I can't swear that I followed the plot 100% of the time but I liked the main protagonist, his rather dry humor, and his cynical POV. The narrator added an extra layer of murderous fun.
Story: 3 stars
Narration: 4 stars
1outside's review
4.0
A great start to a wonderful series of historic detective books. Not only for Ancient Rome enthusiasts. :)
indigooryx's review
adventurous
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.5
roshk99's review
3.0
Decent book, not as good as Lindsey Davis. The premise is very similar to Davis' books, but it doesn't have the same humorous quality.
usbsticky's review
4.0
I've read this book about 10 times and own the entire series. It's a rare historical history that I like. I like this series because I like the writing, which is easy to read and follow. I like the characters and the setting. But most of all I like the protagonist's narration.
The protagonist is one Decius Caecilius Metellus the Younger, scion of a numerous Roman aristocratic family. He's very chatty and gives a very earthy and knowledgeable narration of contemporary Rome.
He chats about everyday historical Roman figures as people he knows in the present or from the future (which is when he dictates the entire series as his memoirs). We get to hear about these characters like Caesar on a contemporary and personal basis. We also get to see and hear Rome, geographically, her peoples, politics and culture the same way. It's like having a travel and historical guide in one.
Spoilers/summary: The mystery part is a bit stretched. The current Consuls and some others conspire to remove a far away general and take away his battles and glory. If we are to believe Decius, it's normal stuff. So what if a few people are murdered along the way? According to Decius, that's everyday stuff too. And if we are to believe his personality, he would have let discretion be the better part of valor (he's forced to do so anyway in the end).
And the plot is a little bit over-complex. With this style of writing, far better to have a simpler plot. The last time I read the book was at least 10 years ago. In the past I've always liked the setting, the characters and the writing far better than I liked the mystery. Today, as a much better reader I agree with my old self. Decius, his narration of Rome and his style is much better than the mystery itself and the reason why I read it so many times. I'm going to read book 2 now.
The protagonist is one Decius Caecilius Metellus the Younger, scion of a numerous Roman aristocratic family. He's very chatty and gives a very earthy and knowledgeable narration of contemporary Rome.
He chats about everyday historical Roman figures as people he knows in the present or from the future (which is when he dictates the entire series as his memoirs). We get to hear about these characters like Caesar on a contemporary and personal basis. We also get to see and hear Rome, geographically, her peoples, politics and culture the same way. It's like having a travel and historical guide in one.
Spoilers/summary: The mystery part is a bit stretched. The current Consuls and some others conspire to remove a far away general and take away his battles and glory. If we are to believe Decius, it's normal stuff. So what if a few people are murdered along the way? According to Decius, that's everyday stuff too. And if we are to believe his personality, he would have let discretion be the better part of valor (he's forced to do so anyway in the end).
And the plot is a little bit over-complex. With this style of writing, far better to have a simpler plot. The last time I read the book was at least 10 years ago. In the past I've always liked the setting, the characters and the writing far better than I liked the mystery. Today, as a much better reader I agree with my old self. Decius, his narration of Rome and his style is much better than the mystery itself and the reason why I read it so many times. I'm going to read book 2 now.