Scan barcode
offworldcolony's review against another edition
5.0
An incredibly thoughtful elseworld looking at Selina's life after Bruce. In a world where most of the heroes are dead and the villains, without the nemeses they craved and focussed on, have retired or found a calling of sorts. Cliff Chiang writes a great retirement story for each of his anti-heroes, he manages to give suitable and loving endings to most of the characters we love in a way that many other mainline series haven't been able to. I want to see an entire series around the events leading to and immediately after "Fool's Night". It's a touching meld of incredible art and playing with the franchise. It's delicate and bold and painful and tragic and cathartic. It's every bit as good as everyone says. The book is well paced and flows as well as the best comics I've enjoyed.
adenhailemariam's review against another edition
4.0
The art was great and Chiang is what drew me to the book.
There was a “getting the band back together” vibe I enjoyed and reading these people we know as villains grow older and think differently was interesting.
The relationships between the characters seemed lived in and new connections were built well.
Batman’s influence is here though he doesn’t show up much.
Still not sure if the promise/reveal of Orpheus worked for me (and I’m not sure if Orpheus is an established Batman concept). Around the same time we learned about Orpheus at the end, there was some magic happening that took me out of the story. Until then, it was stuff that seemed more realistic (even Ivy) for whatever that means in a superhero-based story. At the end, I still liked the characters working together.
Harvey Dent and Barbara Gordon were well featured.
There was a “getting the band back together” vibe I enjoyed and reading these people we know as villains grow older and think differently was interesting.
The relationships between the characters seemed lived in and new connections were built well.
Batman’s influence is here though he doesn’t show up much.
Still not sure if the promise/reveal of Orpheus worked for me (and I’m not sure if Orpheus is an established Batman concept). Around the same time we learned about Orpheus at the end, there was some magic happening that took me out of the story. Until then, it was stuff that seemed more realistic (even Ivy) for whatever that means in a superhero-based story. At the end, I still liked the characters working together.
Harvey Dent and Barbara Gordon were well featured.
mustbemagik's review against another edition
4.0
Really insane that Cliff Chiang did the writing, art, and coloring for this entire book. It’s a blast of a time too, and really lends itself to the DC Black Label branding without coming off as forcibly edgy or anything like that. It’s mature because the characters are older and have been through the worst parts of their life, each hanging on by a thread by the time Lonely City picks up. Having lost so much, it’s all about moving on, and the book handles that to great effect.
unladylike's review against another edition
5.0
This is everything a good stand-alone Gotham-based graphic novel/miniseries should be. The fact that one creator did almost every aspect of it, and in a very labor-intensive, carefully structured way, blows my mind. I really hope he makes more like this for DC Black Label.
brandonadaniels's review against another edition
4.0
Cliff Chang’s masterpiece. It’s an amazing feet of cartooning that you almost never see in mainstream comics; he even lettered this!
That said, the story didn’t completely work for me. The pacing seemed a little off, and I wasn’t crazy about the larger cast.
That said, the story didn’t completely work for me. The pacing seemed a little off, and I wasn’t crazy about the larger cast.
crypticbutton's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
informative
mysterious
sad
fast-paced
4.5
hellocookie's review against another edition
5.0
Everything I could possibly want in a Catwoman book.
kitkaty731's review against another edition
Loved it! Except post Gotham a straight Edward Nygma does not compute for me but that’s a personal issue