Scan barcode
calbowen's review
4.0
This is such a well done series - I enjoy the time period and the play with Clockwork devices and turning the old Fantasy Tropes into newer, fresher ones.
This is book three, but this is NOT a trilogy, as the Epilogue opens the door for a follow on book (a total of seven, if I were a betting man, alchemically speaking of course).
At this point, if you have not read books 1 and 2, then you WILL see plot points revealed from the previous books.
I enjoy the Madder brothers the most. They come off as new world, or even our world, versions of Dwarves, with that same fun and humor that I like from my dwarves. This is all conjecture, as I do not know the root of the ideas from Devon Monk, but that is how they read to me.
There is romance, and the characterizations of two couples (one in book one and then a second in book two) which continue one here. It is not over-bearing, and played out believably.
My only true complaint is that with multiple story-lines going on at the same time, each chapter changes Point of View, which makes it hard sometimes to get into a characters moment, but it has been done well enough, and each chapter ends as it should, with a stab and twist to make you want to know what happens to them next.
I ended 2014 on a high note with Ink and Paper, and look forward to another year of great stories.
This is book three, but this is NOT a trilogy, as the Epilogue opens the door for a follow on book (a total of seven, if I were a betting man, alchemically speaking of course).
At this point, if you have not read books 1 and 2, then you WILL see plot points revealed from the previous books.
I enjoy the Madder brothers the most. They come off as new world, or even our world, versions of Dwarves, with that same fun and humor that I like from my dwarves. This is all conjecture, as I do not know the root of the ideas from Devon Monk, but that is how they read to me.
There is romance, and the characterizations of two couples (one in book one and then a second in book two) which continue one here. It is not over-bearing, and played out believably.
My only true complaint is that with multiple story-lines going on at the same time, each chapter changes Point of View, which makes it hard sometimes to get into a characters moment, but it has been done well enough, and each chapter ends as it should, with a stab and twist to make you want to know what happens to them next.
I ended 2014 on a high note with Ink and Paper, and look forward to another year of great stories.
kathydavie's review
5.0
Third in The Age of Steam steampunk series for young adults set in the Old West and revolving around Cedar Hunt, a man under a Pawnee curse, and Rose Small, a deviser.
It's a case of science fiction meets the paranormal with a dash of James Bond in the Old West. You can't miss with this one.
My Take
It's so odd that I adore Monk's The Age of Steam series and her Allie Beckstrom series drove me nuts. Probably because Allie was such a stupid character, and I adore Rose Small and Cedar Hunt (he's the primary of the two — and they're not a couple!)
Rose is a woman after my own heart. She's absolutely fascinated by how things work and itches to discover how the bunks hinge, what keeps the heat so even, putting a boiler together — with a few improvements, lol. Nor does she put up with a cheating, lying man! At least, not until she has all the facts and examines her heart.
That ice-faring "vessel" the Madders create is ingenious, as is the platform they have for the horses. It's this and other adventures that make me think James Bond with Cage and Rose as Bond and Bondette as they sway, swing, and jump from one action to the next.
It's a conflict of honor, of an old promise made for favors up against the Holder destroying the earth. And it's a position which makes Cedar laugh, for the Madders are finally experiencing what it's like to be forced. That won't be the only time the Madders get thwarted either, lol.
I'll be curious to learn more about Mr. Thomas Wicks. He's something of a mystery, especially with the subtle hints Monk drops. What I don't understand is his attitude toward Cage/Hinks. If he truly is who he claims he is, then what's with his statements about the captain?
I'm also curious why this conglomeration of leaves and straw would tell Hunt to run, especially as I read further into the story. I suppose it could be those weapons the sheriff and his men are wielding that encourages this Strange to bargain. You can't blame Hunt and his party for being very wary.
What does the VB stand for?
Woo, the tension at that breakfast table is running hot, like the coffee and bacon. Sums up Vosbrough's character very quickly, and I can understand why the brothers wanted to avoid Des Moines. You can't fault the Madders for their provocative calm and bored insults. It only made me laugh and wonder how they were gonna get outta this one.
I don't get these former members of Kyne's congregation. There's one woman who was a child with John, and as soon as his father died, she stopped going to the church. Then her kid goes missing, and all of a sudden, John is acceptable again when she goes to beg him for help. WTF?
Opportunities to circumvent the Pawnee curse crop up in here. It's a balance in switching the burden from one person to another, several times.
And why oh why didn't Rose keep a better eye on that clockwork dragonfly?
The Story
It's bad news all around as a blizzard is holding up the group searching for the Holder: Cedar, Wil, Mae, Miss Dupuis, and the Madders. They'll die if they don't find shelter soon, and the Madders are refusing to consider Des Moines, the closest place they can shelter.
It's Des Moines that will determine their immediate fate, for the Madders have a promise to fulfill and dozens of children to find while the Guard has a wary curiosity about why "one of the richest families in the country" is interested in such a well-located city.
Meanwhile, Rose is ready to kill. That no-good, cheating, low-life Captain Lee Hink has been playing her for a fool while she's been busy repairing his ship.
It's glim-worked metal that will be the danger.
The Characters
Cedar Hunt is an educated man, a university teacher who lost his wife and child. A man with a Pawnee curse that forces him to pursue the Strange. His brother, Wil, is also cursed but in the opposite "direction". He's a wolf until the full moon when he turns human, unlike Cedar who turns wolf at the full moon. Cedar is in love with Mae Rowan-Lindson, a witch.
The inquisitive Rose Small is an orphan and a deviser to whom the plants used to talk. She's in love with Marshal Paisley Cadwaller Hink Cage, a.k.a., Captain Lee Hink of the Swift whom we first met in Tin Swift, 2. Mr. Seldom is Hink's second-in-command. Guffin swears in a number of languages, and Lum Ansell sings opera. The doves are part of Cage's spy network.
The Madder brothers are Alun, Bryn, and Cadoc, all miners and devisers. They also have a prior acquaintance with Wicks.
Miss Sophie Dupuis is a very educated woman with a law degree, fortunately, and acquainted with the Madder brothers. She's part of the Guard, a secretive group working to get rid of the Strange.
Thomas Wicks is an educated and polite man with an interest in Rose.
Des Moines
Father John Kyne was a young Indian boy when he was adopted by Lars Kyne to whose father, Holland Kyne, the Madders owed three favors. Now Kyne is a preacher in Des Moines.
Killian Vosbrough is the mayor. His family are the New York Vosbroughs, millionaires with a very bad reputation. Killian has a brother and a sister in Chicago and New York respectively. Hob and Sal are some of the men who work for him. Directly.
Lydia Daffin is the heiress to the Daffin Coal Company. Charles Evans Lowry is a real estate developer.
Sheriff Burchell, Deputy Greeley, and Mr. Peters (his daughter Florence is one of those taken) work as the town law enforcement. George Hensling claims that Father Kyne has gone nuts.
The previous mayor was Roy Atkinson. A man who refused to do immoral things.
Hays City, Kansas is…
…where Mae's coven lives on their farm. Miss Adaline, Margaret, and Sarah are part of that coven. Sweet Annie's Saloon is a bar and bordello. The elder Mr. Travis repairs watches. Miss Bucker runs a lending library. Mr. Davis is a tinker who gets drunk every evening.
Elbert Gregor (Dead Iron, 1) was the blacksmith's son who had been kidnapped by Mr. Shunt whom Hunt killed in Tin Swift, 2. The Strange are "unholy creatures from myth and legend intent on killing good folk" who need to use our bodies to operate in our world. The Holder is a dangerous artifact that has been divided into seven pieces, and any one of those pieces could destroy our world.
The Cover and Title
The cover is a pale gray structural background with Cedar Hunt in his long brown duster, goggles pushed up on his head, his bandolier around his neck, his pistol in one hand, and a diving helmet lantern in the other. The title and author's name are in copper, cold copper.
The title is all about a cursed metal, one that sends people mad if they touch it. Trust me, Cold Copper will kill you.
It's a case of science fiction meets the paranormal with a dash of James Bond in the Old West. You can't miss with this one.
My Take
It's so odd that I adore Monk's The Age of Steam series and her Allie Beckstrom series drove me nuts. Probably because Allie was such a stupid character, and I adore Rose Small and Cedar Hunt (he's the primary of the two — and they're not a couple!)
Rose is a woman after my own heart. She's absolutely fascinated by how things work and itches to discover how the bunks hinge, what keeps the heat so even, putting a boiler together — with a few improvements, lol. Nor does she put up with a cheating, lying man! At least, not until she has all the facts and examines her heart.
That ice-faring "vessel" the Madders create is ingenious, as is the platform they have for the horses. It's this and other adventures that make me think James Bond with Cage and Rose as Bond and Bondette as they sway, swing, and jump from one action to the next.
It's a conflict of honor, of an old promise made for favors up against the Holder destroying the earth. And it's a position which makes Cedar laugh, for the Madders are finally experiencing what it's like to be forced. That won't be the only time the Madders get thwarted either, lol.
I'll be curious to learn more about Mr. Thomas Wicks. He's something of a mystery, especially with the subtle hints Monk drops. What I don't understand is his attitude toward Cage/Hinks. If he truly is who he claims he is, then what's with his statements about the captain?
I'm also curious why this conglomeration of leaves and straw would tell Hunt to run, especially as I read further into the story. I suppose it could be those weapons the sheriff and his men are wielding that encourages this Strange to bargain. You can't blame Hunt and his party for being very wary.
What does the VB stand for?
Woo, the tension at that breakfast table is running hot, like the coffee and bacon. Sums up Vosbrough's character very quickly, and I can understand why the brothers wanted to avoid Des Moines. You can't fault the Madders for their provocative calm and bored insults. It only made me laugh and wonder how they were gonna get outta this one.
I don't get these former members of Kyne's congregation. There's one woman who was a child with John, and as soon as his father died, she stopped going to the church. Then her kid goes missing, and all of a sudden, John is acceptable again when she goes to beg him for help. WTF?
Opportunities to circumvent the Pawnee curse crop up in here. It's a balance in switching the burden from one person to another, several times.
And why oh why didn't Rose keep a better eye on that clockwork dragonfly?
The Story
It's bad news all around as a blizzard is holding up the group searching for the Holder: Cedar, Wil, Mae, Miss Dupuis, and the Madders. They'll die if they don't find shelter soon, and the Madders are refusing to consider Des Moines, the closest place they can shelter.
It's Des Moines that will determine their immediate fate, for the Madders have a promise to fulfill and dozens of children to find while the Guard has a wary curiosity about why "one of the richest families in the country" is interested in such a well-located city.
Meanwhile, Rose is ready to kill. That no-good, cheating, low-life Captain Lee Hink has been playing her for a fool while she's been busy repairing his ship.
It's glim-worked metal that will be the danger.
The Characters
Cedar Hunt is an educated man, a university teacher who lost his wife and child. A man with a Pawnee curse that forces him to pursue the Strange. His brother, Wil, is also cursed but in the opposite "direction". He's a wolf until the full moon when he turns human, unlike Cedar who turns wolf at the full moon. Cedar is in love with Mae Rowan-Lindson, a witch.
The inquisitive Rose Small is an orphan and a deviser to whom the plants used to talk. She's in love with Marshal Paisley Cadwaller Hink Cage, a.k.a., Captain Lee Hink of the Swift whom we first met in Tin Swift, 2. Mr. Seldom is Hink's second-in-command. Guffin swears in a number of languages, and Lum Ansell sings opera. The doves are part of Cage's spy network.
The Madder brothers are Alun, Bryn, and Cadoc, all miners and devisers. They also have a prior acquaintance with Wicks.
Miss Sophie Dupuis is a very educated woman with a law degree, fortunately, and acquainted with the Madder brothers. She's part of the Guard, a secretive group working to get rid of the Strange.
Thomas Wicks is an educated and polite man with an interest in Rose.
Des Moines
Father John Kyne was a young Indian boy when he was adopted by Lars Kyne to whose father, Holland Kyne, the Madders owed three favors. Now Kyne is a preacher in Des Moines.
Killian Vosbrough is the mayor. His family are the New York Vosbroughs, millionaires with a very bad reputation. Killian has a brother and a sister in Chicago and New York respectively. Hob and Sal are some of the men who work for him. Directly.
Lydia Daffin is the heiress to the Daffin Coal Company. Charles Evans Lowry is a real estate developer.
Sheriff Burchell, Deputy Greeley, and Mr. Peters (his daughter Florence is one of those taken) work as the town law enforcement. George Hensling claims that Father Kyne has gone nuts.
The previous mayor was Roy Atkinson. A man who refused to do immoral things.
Hays City, Kansas is…
…where Mae's coven lives on their farm. Miss Adaline, Margaret, and Sarah are part of that coven. Sweet Annie's Saloon is a bar and bordello. The elder Mr. Travis repairs watches. Miss Bucker runs a lending library. Mr. Davis is a tinker who gets drunk every evening.
Elbert Gregor (Dead Iron, 1) was the blacksmith's son who had been kidnapped by Mr. Shunt whom Hunt killed in Tin Swift, 2. The Strange are "unholy creatures from myth and legend intent on killing good folk" who need to use our bodies to operate in our world. The Holder is a dangerous artifact that has been divided into seven pieces, and any one of those pieces could destroy our world.
The Cover and Title
The cover is a pale gray structural background with Cedar Hunt in his long brown duster, goggles pushed up on his head, his bandolier around his neck, his pistol in one hand, and a diving helmet lantern in the other. The title and author's name are in copper, cold copper.
The title is all about a cursed metal, one that sends people mad if they touch it. Trust me, Cold Copper will kill you.
amybraunauthor's review
5.0
This book was awesome. Just awesome. I wasn't sure where the story would go, but it took a fun turn and changed how I looked at the Strange. The story was divided up mostly between Cedar and Rose's POV's, which meant we were taken on two different adventures. It was great to see old characters and new, especially given how much I missed Hink. The action was steady and strong, and one point at the end caused me to lose a little sleep. It was that intense. The characters were just as loveable as always, and while I adore Cedar, I have to say that Rose stole the show. That girl is just amazing, and I love her strength, her curiosity and quirks. The romance was emotional and deep for both main characters, which I also really enjoyed. While the plot rounded out in the end, there were a lot of major questions left unanswered, including one MAJOR one that happened with Cedar. I'm hoping this means there will be more books (there HAVE to be, considering the epilogue ended with a "cliffhanger" that almost made me scream), because I love this series and have more questions. I want to know more about the world, the Strange, the curse, the witches, and I NEED more Cedar, Hink, Rose, Mae, Madders, and Wil in my life. I need them! Don't miss out on this book!
abigcoffeedragon's review
4.0
This is such a well done series - I enjoy the time period and the play with Clockwork devices and turning the old Fantasy Tropes into newer, fresher ones.
This is book three, but this is NOT a trilogy, as the Epilogue opens the door for a follow on book (a total of seven, if I were a betting man, alchemically speaking of course).
At this point, if you have not read books 1 and 2, then you WILL see plot points revealed from the previous books.
I enjoy the Madder brothers the most. They come off as new world, or even our world, versions of Dwarves, with that same fun and humor that I like from my dwarves. This is all conjecture, as I do not know the root of the ideas from Devon Monk, but that is how they read to me.
There is romance, and the characterizations of two couples (one in book one and then a second in book two) which continue one here. It is not over-bearing, and played out believably.
My only true complaint is that with multiple story-lines going on at the same time, each chapter changes Point of View, which makes it hard sometimes to get into a characters moment, but it has been done well enough, and each chapter ends as it should, with a stab and twist to make you want to know what happens to them next.
I ended 2014 on a high note with Ink and Paper, and look forward to another year of great stories.
This is book three, but this is NOT a trilogy, as the Epilogue opens the door for a follow on book (a total of seven, if I were a betting man, alchemically speaking of course).
At this point, if you have not read books 1 and 2, then you WILL see plot points revealed from the previous books.
I enjoy the Madder brothers the most. They come off as new world, or even our world, versions of Dwarves, with that same fun and humor that I like from my dwarves. This is all conjecture, as I do not know the root of the ideas from Devon Monk, but that is how they read to me.
There is romance, and the characterizations of two couples (one in book one and then a second in book two) which continue one here. It is not over-bearing, and played out believably.
My only true complaint is that with multiple story-lines going on at the same time, each chapter changes Point of View, which makes it hard sometimes to get into a characters moment, but it has been done well enough, and each chapter ends as it should, with a stab and twist to make you want to know what happens to them next.
I ended 2014 on a high note with Ink and Paper, and look forward to another year of great stories.
hannas_heas47's review
5.0
I think I'm becoming a steam punk fanatic, I love this series. The only thing I hate is that it takes so long between books. At least with the Allie Beckstrom series I purchased it at the end and I was able to read them all at once. I love Cedar Hunt and Rose, they are my favorite characters. After the first book I really thought they'd be a couple but it seems they are destined for others. I purchased this book so I will definitely buy more from this author. I would definitely recommend this set of books if you like steam punk. This author really knows how to spin a wild tale.
mjfmjfmjf's review
3.0
Book 3 in a steampunk western series I read primarily for the Endeavour Award. This one got a bit out of hand - too many threads, too much plot - it just basically felt rushed. And the character interaction was a bit too obvious and it just wasn't deep enough. And it doesn't help that I'm not particularly a steampunk nor a western fan. Still, a readable book in a readable series.
rclz's review
5.0
This is good. I'm really enjoying this series and I can't wait to see what mischief the next book brings.
cmbohn's review
I decided not to finish this one since the story wasn't going anywhere and the reviews all said the series doesn't have a conclusion. The first book was really creepy. Too bad about this one.
suzrae73's review
4.0
Another great installment on this series! I can't tell you how much I enjoy all these characters and the predicaments they get themselves into!!!! Very excited to see what they get themselves into next! Hope I don't have to wait too long!