Reviews

Masked Man, Black: Pandemic & Protest Poems by Frank X Walker

marchcrow's review

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional funny hopeful reflective sad tense fast-paced

3.5

Not my favorite of his work as a collection - a bit uneven - but there are some real stand out poems. I will be thinking about Severe Weather Warning for a while. 

jakereadstomorrow's review

Go to review page

challenging emotional sad fast-paced

4.5

pickle_burner's review

Go to review page

4.0

I think I read that F. Walker wrote these in a different manner than his normal process for writing and editing poems. Essentially, there was less fuss than a poet and his/her editor might normally provide. If you are a regular reader of poetry and are able to accept this gambit, this collection will provide many revelations both personal and political. As a dad, I related to a lot of what I found in these lines. As a middle aged white guy, I learned a lot and felt the anger, sadness, and hope that permeates this collection. It was illuminating, unsettling, yet also comforting.

If you are one of those folks who might be disinclined to take this "seriously" because of the immediacy in which it was written and published, I guess I might ask that you examine what use art (of any kind) is supposed to serve. When people are dying because of the color of their skin or bc of a the gross failings of the political system, when the world is on fire (literally and figuratively), what sense does it make to sit on a poem and worry over it until it is "perfect?" I would argue that it makes no sense and that different times require different types of art, art that is produced in different ways. There's an immediacy to these poems that should be absorbed, understood, and accounted for by the reader. The "Wasteland" couldn't have been written in the bunkers of WWI.

Personally, I deeply appreciated the tone and format of this book. I appreciated the immediacy. I've been reading Mr. Walker's work since "Affrilachia" came out, and this is a wonderful addition to his work.

shannon26's review

Go to review page

inspiring reflective medium-paced

5.0

katrinflores's review

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional inspiring reflective sad medium-paced

3.75

Def not born out of Frank X Walker’s typical writing process I think you can tell, so I’m looking at it through that lens. Really important look back on the beginning of this pandemic from the POV of a black man. 
More...