Scan barcode
pizzamyheart's review against another edition
3.0
This version combines multiple tellings of Aladdin and Sinbad. I liked that they included the genie of the ring. It was a key point of the story excluded from the famous Disney film. I found the story itself to be jumpy and underdeveloped. The imagery was well done but a bit dark for my taste. I thought it didn't mesh with the story of Aladdin. It reminded me more of The Prince of Persia or Assassin's Creed.
I would have liked to see more character development or a longer story. There was room to improve.
I would have liked to see more character development or a longer story. There was room to improve.
jljaina's review against another edition
4.0
A very strong 4, almost 4.5 stars. The artwork is gorgeous! I love all the dark shadowing done and the intricate details at other times. I just loved the images! The story was a well done take on the story of Aladdin that follows most closely to the Arabian Nights. However there are some differences too, especially when you add in Sinbad. But you can never go wrong adding him to the tales!
If you are looking for a happy, genie-singing Disney style tale, go away now. This is not that. This is much more mature and darker. And I loved it for that! My only gripe is some story parts and dialogue seem a bit jumpy and Like the writers needed more panels to flesh out their side of the tale better. Still, very enjoyable collection and one that has earned a spot on my shelves to stay.
If you are looking for a happy, genie-singing Disney style tale, go away now. This is not that. This is much more mature and darker. And I loved it for that! My only gripe is some story parts and dialogue seem a bit jumpy and Like the writers needed more panels to flesh out their side of the tale better. Still, very enjoyable collection and one that has earned a spot on my shelves to stay.
More...