Scan barcode
cheesygiraffe's review against another edition
3.0
Although I enjoy this cozy mystery series they are too easy to solve. I always know who done it early on even if I don't know why yet. Recipes looks scrumptious as usual. And I'm glad something is finally blossoming between Phyllis and Sam.
chrissyz's review against another edition
3.0
"There's always bad things happenin' all over the world, but Christmas is still Christmas. It's got a magic all its own, and one part of it is that it helps you forget for awhile those bad things and remember the good."
sandypotato's review against another edition
lighthearted
mysterious
relaxing
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
addy1991's review
3.0
Christmas is a wonderful time of year but it can also be stressful. People try to make perfect holidays, some are lonely, some grieve. Phyllis and her friends keep old traditions going by holding their annual cookie exchange. Things are going well until a neighbor is killed and Phyllis bopped over the head when she finds the body. Of course this makes it personal and she's determined to find out what happened. But ... plenty of secrets come to light during her snooping and she has to figure out which one is worth killing for before the killer catches up with her.
I liked this one better than the previous one but wish she would beat Carolyn in baking contests every now and then since I'm tired of seeing Carolyn gloat and make her usual caustic comments.
I liked this one better than the previous one but wish she would beat Carolyn in baking contests every now and then since I'm tired of seeing Carolyn gloat and make her usual caustic comments.
karen_the_baroness's review
5.0
Will Phyllis be able to figure out who killed the next-door neighbor?
The Christmas Cookie Killer by Livia J. Washburn was a fantastic book. All of the characters are so realistic, and the interrelationships are magnificent. This book is the second that I have read in this series. We have quite a selection of characters in this installment, and I love them all.
The main sleuth is Phyllis Newsom, and she is a retired school teacher in Weatherford, Texas. Phyllis’s son Mike Newsom is a Deputy of the sheriff’s department (enter the local lawman connection). The murderer kills Agnes Simmons in a way that is quite a crime of passion.
The Sleuth
Phyllis Newsom is an elderly lady maybe in her late sixties early seventies and is still full of life. She loves her son, daughter-in-law, and adorable three-year-old grandson by the name of Bobby. Phyllis’s has solved two other mysteries in town before this third mystery. However, this is the first one with Detective Largo leading the case. Phyllis is quite a resourceful woman when she is trying to solve a murder, especially one this close to her home.
I would love being related to Phyllis. Watch for her Lime Snowflake Cookies. I will be featuring them later this month, and I can’t wait to try these myself.
What I like about Phyllis is that she still misses her husband, Kenny. Although she slowly realizes that she may have feelings for Sam. I also really like how she can get people to open up to her. It's like she does it without even trying. Another thing that I love about Phyllis is that she and Carolyn have a great friendship when they aren’t competing against each other, and it shows. I especially enjoy when the two are in the kitchen cooking together.
The only thing that I don’t like about Phyllis is that she doesn't tell law enforcement everything that she found out about the murder. Who cares if it’s hearsay?
The Law Connection
Phyllis’s only son is the law connection in this series. I think this is an excellent twist in the cozy mystery world since it’s usually the love interest — what a sweet little spin. Mike Newsom is a terrific character. I wouldn’t mind having someone like Mike in my life. You can immediately tell that he has been raised right.
What I like about Mike is that he is a great son and tries to be there for his mom whenever he can. Phyllis even calls him a bit overprotective of her. I can see why he is since she likes getting mixed up in cases involving murder. Mike also tries to be the best husband and dad that he can. The last thing that I love about Mike that he is an outstanding deputy. The only thing that I dislike about Mike is that he underestimates his mother's nosiness.
The Case
This case is different than others that I have read in cozy mystery stories. I thought the way that poor Agnes Simmons was killed is horrible. She was strangled with her bathrobe cord in her living room with cookies all over her. What a terrible way to die, it isn't like she could stand up to her murderer in the first place. I thought I had this one, but I was wrong. Word of warning, don’t get too caught up in the red herrings in this one as I did.
Five Stars
The Christmas Cookie Killer by Livia J. Washburn was an exciting tale, and I look forward to reading another one of her mysteries. Ms. Washburn’s includes these lovely recipes. Look out for the Lime Snowflake Cookies later this month. I might do some other recipes from this book as well. I am also in love with this author's style. Ms. Washburn did a fantastic job planting and discrediting the clues to who killed Agnes Simmons. I was utterly stumped, once again, until Phyllis figured it out at the end and it started to click in my mind.
I am giving this book five stars and recommending it to anyone that loves a good cozy mystery. This book comes with some added bookish recipes. So, you can try them out for the upcoming Christmas holiday.
Anyways until the next time enjoy this review brought to you by,
This review was originally posted on Baroness' Book Trove
melmmoore's review against another edition
2.0
Retired teachers who live together, one of whom stumbles upon a murder ever now and again seemed like a fun cozy mystery series to me. (I'm a teacher). Add baking to the mix and this was an easy pick. Unfortunately I didn't feel an affinity towards any of the characters. Nothing to make me read other books I'm the series. Despite red herrings galore it was obvious who the murderer was. This wasn't a hit for me but I can see how it may be for others.
luffy79's review against another edition
3.0
I felt a lot of good things about this book. None of them new things, but that's not a complaint, but it defines the experiences of a fan of cozy mysteries and defines the element of the genre. For once, I'd not like to focus on ratings, and I'd rather say that The Freshly Baked Mystery series are up to my taste. The writing is slightly pedantic and dry, but there's some character progression for some. The writer took great care to describe Sam. He does not walk, he ambles. He doesn't speak, but 'drawls'. The murderer was very satisfactorily found out. I'm at peace with the world and this book played its part in it.