Reviews

Einen Puntk Abzug für die schlechte Übersetzung... Manche Sätze haben gar keinen Sinn ergeben und von der Grammatik fange ich besser gar nicht erst an... Die Geschichte hat mich total positiv überrascht. Ich bin total verliebt in die Fuzzies und Jack. Ich kam nicht drum rum ständig an Gizmo oder Ewoks zu denken. Einfach süß. Die zweite Hälfte des Buches war dann umso ernster. Es ging um die Frage, ab wann man eine Spezies als intelligentes Volk bezeichnen kann. Mir hat die Natur-Kultur Debatte sehr gut gefallen. Und, obwohl das Buch in den 60ern geschrieben worden ist, das Thema immer noch relevant.

dylex's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous funny fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.5

shadrachanki's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous lighthearted medium-paced

4.0

robertcollins's review

Go to review page

emotional hopeful

4.0

macthekat's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Loved it. It was wonderful, interesting and adorable. The fact that for half the book I didn't really want the plot to start because I was spellbound and didn't want anything bad to happen to anyone. By The end the book made me stay up easy past my bedtime, though I have stopped doing that.
A fascinating contemplation on sentient wrapped up in an adorable story about little furry creatures and friendship.

mynameisnemo's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

My brother and I once had a discussion that involved the question 'if you could go back in time to any point and change one thing, what would you do?'

My brother said that, given any point in time and any change, he would go back and convince H. Beam Piper that he would be a successful writer and not to kill himself.

Given that, the profound influence that one of my favourite people in the world experienced at the hand of the writing of this man, I figured it would probably be good to read some of his works.

So today I started and finished my first H. Beam Piper book. I need a little more of a sample size to be convinced if my brother's impression is the same for me, but I have to say it has been a long time since I started and finished a new book all in the same day.

This is a book that has it all. A space colony on an unspecified world, a long court proceeding, a hint of mystery, a lot of discussion of psychology, and a happy ending. Also cute fuzzy creatures. I mean, who can resist? I really like how much time is given in this book to attempting to define what sapience is. There is very little question of right and wrong in this story, and no question of who is on what side other than one very obvious exception, but the question of sapience, while obviously important to the plot, seems to be the greater point of contemplation behind this novel for the author and I very much appreciate the framing in which he opted to explore it.

Speaking of that one little obvious exception, I also enjoyed the flavourings here and there of cold war era political and military tactics. It was a great reminder of the environment in which the story was born but also it was fun to imagine those circumstances applying on another planet in the distant future. Given the current state of affairs in America, it's not hard to see how those sort of machinations might reoccur in another time and place.

Lastly, I also wanted to mention how much I loved the naming of the colonies. Naming them after various deities was an absolute stroke of genius on the part of Piper and definitely puts his works, in a mechanical sense, apart from any other contemporary era science fiction that I have read.

More...