Scan barcode
Reviews
March Was Made of Yarn: Reflections on the Japanese Earthquake, Tsunami, and Nuclear Meltdown by
claudia_marcela's review against another edition
emotional
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? N/A
3.5
patchworkbunny's review against another edition
4.0
Like all anthologies, there are going to be stories you love and some that you just don't care for. The collection is much more focused on the after rather than the actual events of March 2011. One thing I've always found Japanese writers do so well is making the mundane into something more. It just so happens that the earthquake, tsunami and resulting nuclear disaster taints this every day life now.
We get two versions of God Bless You 2011, a walk with a bear in the Japanese countryside. One was written in 1993 and the other reworked in 2011 to show the changes of the world after radiation had leaked into the environment from the Fukushima Daiichi disaster. The story takes on a whole new dimension because of it.
Perhaps it's because I have a friend with a box obsession, but I loved Box Story. When there is a shortage of boxes, someone comes up with the idea of breeding them and citizens are given breeding boxes to care for. In The Charm a woman returns to her home town feeling helpless but with a desire to do something to help. Lulu introduces a dog made of air, created in the minds of children in an evacuation centre, something to make things easier. Ride on Time is told from the perspective of a surfer, anticipating the legendary wave.
It seems telling that the one writer who chooses to detail the actual horror of the day is not Japanese. David Peace's After the Disaster, Before the Disaster comes at the end of the collection and really drives home what happened. I don't think the book would have been as enjoyable if this had been the tones throughout but it's important to acknowledge. It's all too easy for the rest of the world to forget and this book is a thought-provoking reminder.
Whilst the book is primarily made up of short stories, there is also poetry, manga and a journalistic piece.
We get two versions of God Bless You 2011, a walk with a bear in the Japanese countryside. One was written in 1993 and the other reworked in 2011 to show the changes of the world after radiation had leaked into the environment from the Fukushima Daiichi disaster. The story takes on a whole new dimension because of it.
Perhaps it's because I have a friend with a box obsession, but I loved Box Story. When there is a shortage of boxes, someone comes up with the idea of breeding them and citizens are given breeding boxes to care for. In The Charm a woman returns to her home town feeling helpless but with a desire to do something to help. Lulu introduces a dog made of air, created in the minds of children in an evacuation centre, something to make things easier. Ride on Time is told from the perspective of a surfer, anticipating the legendary wave.
It seems telling that the one writer who chooses to detail the actual horror of the day is not Japanese. David Peace's After the Disaster, Before the Disaster comes at the end of the collection and really drives home what happened. I don't think the book would have been as enjoyable if this had been the tones throughout but it's important to acknowledge. It's all too easy for the rest of the world to forget and this book is a thought-provoking reminder.
Whilst the book is primarily made up of short stories, there is also poetry, manga and a journalistic piece.
mariomenti's review against another edition
4.0
I read this to remember the 10th anniversary of 東日本大震災, the Tohoku earthquake, tsunami and nuclear meltdown in Fukushima, tomorrow (March 11).
Published a year after the event, it's a really interesting collection of short stories from Japanese writers, addressing the disaster in different ways.
Yoko Tawada's "The Island of Eternal Life" is a kind of sketch of what was to become her novel "The Last Children of Tokyo", while the bleakest, angriest and most harrowing piece is a short manga by Brother & Sister Nishioka ("The Crows and The Girl").
But I think my favourite was Shinji Ishii's "Lulu", a magical, almost child-like story of translucent women and an imaginary dog (Lulu of the title) that helps orphaned children in an emergency evacuation centre come to terms with their trauma and grief. It's simple in some ways, but so emotionally charged and beautifully written it will stay with you for a long time.
Published a year after the event, it's a really interesting collection of short stories from Japanese writers, addressing the disaster in different ways.
Yoko Tawada's "The Island of Eternal Life" is a kind of sketch of what was to become her novel "The Last Children of Tokyo", while the bleakest, angriest and most harrowing piece is a short manga by Brother & Sister Nishioka ("The Crows and The Girl").
But I think my favourite was Shinji Ishii's "Lulu", a magical, almost child-like story of translucent women and an imaginary dog (Lulu of the title) that helps orphaned children in an emergency evacuation centre come to terms with their trauma and grief. It's simple in some ways, but so emotionally charged and beautifully written it will stay with you for a long time.
envy7sins's review against another edition
3.0
This is a book made up of many individual authors' stories. To be honest, I found many of the stories to be difficult to follow, maybe just being too abstract for me personally. But there were a few that I enjoyed reading, particularly 'Lulu', 'Little Eucalyptus Leaves' and 'After the disaster, before the disaster'.
qwordyq's review against another edition
3.0
We read selections of this for a class and I figured I would just read the whole thing. There are some very thought provoking stories and others that just didn’t resonate as much with me. I think my top three were The Charm, Pieces, and March Yarn.
More...