Scan barcode
queenterribletimy's review
4.0
I’ve received and ARC from Adrian Collins in exchange of a honest review.
Full review with personal notes: starlitbook.com/2018/05/15/knee-deep-in-grit-two-bloody-years-of-grimdark-fiction-by-adrian-collins/
Adrian Collins and the crew at Grimdark Magazine has decided to put together an anthology featuring 25 authors whose work was published on their pages. And what a good idea it was! When I accepted the ARC I had only known two authors of those featured in this book: Mark Lawrence, whose Broken Empire trilogy I’ve read and Michael R. Fletcher so I dived into the unknown without any idea how it will turn out. The stories are as varied as the authors. We get sci-fi, fantasy, urban fantasy. And of course all of them is grim in their own way: some of them is filled to the brim with bodies, the blood flowing like a red cold river, some of them are more refined and not as much blood filled but featuring characters with questionable moral. The palette is wide, so everyone will find their favorite. For me those stood out the most which affected me emotionally, where the characters had to make a though choice, which made me think about humanity and how much our choices define us or change our lives. The ones which puts a mirror before you and makes you question yourself: would I’ve done the same thing?
The stories that stood out to me the most were:
The Neutral by Anatoly Belilovsky and Mike Gelprin
Damn. That’s the first thing that comes to mind. This one is short (way too short) and a different kind of brutal. It’s not overwritten, we don’t get much of the MC’s personality, he is not important only the choice he makes in the end. And that leaves its mark. This was the first that really touched me emotionally and probably will many more too. The story builds up until that one last moment, when the final decision is made, when everything comes to an end one way or the other.
Shadow Hunter by Adrian Tchaikovsky
Maybe this was the most original one. The world in this story is filled insect-kinded people, with different attributes and gifts granted by the insects they represent. The writing is really good, the character building is detailed despite the length. Apparently the story is set in the world of Mr Tchaikovsky’s Shadows of the Apt series.
A Recipe for Corpse Oil by Siobhan Gallagher
The only remotely funny read out of the 25, maybe that’s made it standing out so much. Well, it’s funny, if you’ve got a certain kind of morbid humor that is. This one didn’t take itself too seriously and puts a twist to assassin stories. The MC is a thief who is caught by a shop owner who asks for his services in exchange of not giving him up. And so our MC is set loose in the city trying to fulfill his side of the bargain.
A Fair Man by Peter Orullian
Another emotionally effective short story about a man who spent his life serving the prince as best as he could, but starts to see the unfairness of the law and the people who enforce it. It had an ancient roman feel to the setting. It also raises questions like how long can you stand by without doing anything to prevent innocent people to die? How far would you go to save your loved one? And how do you pay back someone who saved your life?
Lessons of Necessity by T.C. Powell
When a story starts with a 12 years old handing a knife to his mom with a moving zombie at his feet, you know it’s not going to be an easy read. And it’s not. This one will make many repelled. It’s hard to decide where to put this. Not classic grimdark, it’s more about morale and again, choices. Be it bad and right. As a short story it’s well written, tight, heart wrenching. And will leave you conflicted and wondering: would I have done the same thing?
Bad Seed by Mark Lawrence
I’m sure I don’t have to introduce Mr Lawrence to those who like the grimdark genre. The book starts and ends with him as he wrote the introduction. This short story was published in the first issue of Grimdark Magazine. This was also one of the best, but that’s expected from Mark Lawrence. If you are familiar with the Broken Empire trilogy, then Brother Kent’s name will ring a bell. Now you can learn about his past, and how did he become the man he was. Was he a good man or a bad one just because he was born to kill?
Others I'd like give a shout out too, because they were good as well, but this review would go on forever if I started to gush about them too:
Ashes by Tara Calaby
The Woman I Used to Be by Gerri Leen
The Red Wraith by Nicholas Wisseman
Boomer Hunter by Sean Patrick Hazlett
Redemption Waits by Mike Brooks
All the Lovely Brides by Kelly Sandoval
Drone Strikes for Fun and Profit by Aaron Fox-Lerner
Brazen Dreams by Matthew Ward
The Right Hand of Decay by David Annandale
The Line by T. R. Napper
The King Beneath the Waves by Peter Fugazzotto
At the Walls of Sinnlos by Michael R. Fletcher
Whatever you are looking for in grimdark, you sure will find it in this anthology. You’ll go on a roller coaster ride, you’ll question your life, your morales, you’ll dive deep into blood and gore. You’ll watch characters fight and die for love, for glory, for revenge, for whatever they find worth to fight for. Sometimes you’ll cheer for them, sometimes against them. You’ll find new authors to follow and most probably will walk away like a different man (or women) with a million questions swarming in your head. At the end of the day, this is what makes a book remarkable: if it makes you think, and if that you carry it around in your head and soul even long after you put it down. Knee-Deep in Grit will make that to you: gets under your skin, plants itself in your head and no matter how much you try, you’ll never be able to look at people the same way. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
Full review with personal notes: starlitbook.com/2018/05/15/knee-deep-in-grit-two-bloody-years-of-grimdark-fiction-by-adrian-collins/
Adrian Collins and the crew at Grimdark Magazine has decided to put together an anthology featuring 25 authors whose work was published on their pages. And what a good idea it was! When I accepted the ARC I had only known two authors of those featured in this book: Mark Lawrence, whose Broken Empire trilogy I’ve read and Michael R. Fletcher so I dived into the unknown without any idea how it will turn out. The stories are as varied as the authors. We get sci-fi, fantasy, urban fantasy. And of course all of them is grim in their own way: some of them is filled to the brim with bodies, the blood flowing like a red cold river, some of them are more refined and not as much blood filled but featuring characters with questionable moral. The palette is wide, so everyone will find their favorite. For me those stood out the most which affected me emotionally, where the characters had to make a though choice, which made me think about humanity and how much our choices define us or change our lives. The ones which puts a mirror before you and makes you question yourself: would I’ve done the same thing?
The stories that stood out to me the most were:
The Neutral by Anatoly Belilovsky and Mike Gelprin
Damn. That’s the first thing that comes to mind. This one is short (way too short) and a different kind of brutal. It’s not overwritten, we don’t get much of the MC’s personality, he is not important only the choice he makes in the end. And that leaves its mark. This was the first that really touched me emotionally and probably will many more too. The story builds up until that one last moment, when the final decision is made, when everything comes to an end one way or the other.
Shadow Hunter by Adrian Tchaikovsky
Maybe this was the most original one. The world in this story is filled insect-kinded people, with different attributes and gifts granted by the insects they represent. The writing is really good, the character building is detailed despite the length. Apparently the story is set in the world of Mr Tchaikovsky’s Shadows of the Apt series.
A Recipe for Corpse Oil by Siobhan Gallagher
The only remotely funny read out of the 25, maybe that’s made it standing out so much. Well, it’s funny, if you’ve got a certain kind of morbid humor that is. This one didn’t take itself too seriously and puts a twist to assassin stories. The MC is a thief who is caught by a shop owner who asks for his services in exchange of not giving him up. And so our MC is set loose in the city trying to fulfill his side of the bargain.
A Fair Man by Peter Orullian
Another emotionally effective short story about a man who spent his life serving the prince as best as he could, but starts to see the unfairness of the law and the people who enforce it. It had an ancient roman feel to the setting. It also raises questions like how long can you stand by without doing anything to prevent innocent people to die? How far would you go to save your loved one? And how do you pay back someone who saved your life?
Lessons of Necessity by T.C. Powell
When a story starts with a 12 years old handing a knife to his mom with a moving zombie at his feet, you know it’s not going to be an easy read. And it’s not. This one will make many repelled. It’s hard to decide where to put this. Not classic grimdark, it’s more about morale and again, choices. Be it bad and right. As a short story it’s well written, tight, heart wrenching. And will leave you conflicted and wondering: would I have done the same thing?
Bad Seed by Mark Lawrence
I’m sure I don’t have to introduce Mr Lawrence to those who like the grimdark genre. The book starts and ends with him as he wrote the introduction. This short story was published in the first issue of Grimdark Magazine. This was also one of the best, but that’s expected from Mark Lawrence. If you are familiar with the Broken Empire trilogy, then Brother Kent’s name will ring a bell. Now you can learn about his past, and how did he become the man he was. Was he a good man or a bad one just because he was born to kill?
Others I'd like give a shout out too, because they were good as well, but this review would go on forever if I started to gush about them too:
Ashes by Tara Calaby
The Woman I Used to Be by Gerri Leen
The Red Wraith by Nicholas Wisseman
Boomer Hunter by Sean Patrick Hazlett
Redemption Waits by Mike Brooks
All the Lovely Brides by Kelly Sandoval
Drone Strikes for Fun and Profit by Aaron Fox-Lerner
Brazen Dreams by Matthew Ward
The Right Hand of Decay by David Annandale
The Line by T. R. Napper
The King Beneath the Waves by Peter Fugazzotto
At the Walls of Sinnlos by Michael R. Fletcher
Whatever you are looking for in grimdark, you sure will find it in this anthology. You’ll go on a roller coaster ride, you’ll question your life, your morales, you’ll dive deep into blood and gore. You’ll watch characters fight and die for love, for glory, for revenge, for whatever they find worth to fight for. Sometimes you’ll cheer for them, sometimes against them. You’ll find new authors to follow and most probably will walk away like a different man (or women) with a million questions swarming in your head. At the end of the day, this is what makes a book remarkable: if it makes you think, and if that you carry it around in your head and soul even long after you put it down. Knee-Deep in Grit will make that to you: gets under your skin, plants itself in your head and no matter how much you try, you’ll never be able to look at people the same way. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
eyed's review
3.0
I ended up having mixed feelings about this book, which is the outcome for a lot of anthologies for me. Not every story is for everyone, so you just have to enjoy the stories that are for you. There were definitely stories for me in here but I expected to be really into more of them than I was.
What it came down to was while all the stories fell in the grimdark genre some were just bloody violent fight scenes. I love fight scenes but for me they were lacking the story that makes me care about the outcome of the action. This is something I did not know I needed from a short story before I read this book. Due to this I had some clear favorites that were more emotionally grimdark than the others. Here they are in order they appeared not the order of my enjoyment.
The Right Hand of Decay by David Annandale
This story was about the ongoing war between Harrod and the Grey Queen and just how far they were willing to go to achieve complete victory over the others.
Brazen Dreams by Matthew Ward
This one was sci-fi which I am not really into but The twists this story that started out as a simple heist took came as quite a surprise. Enough so to add it to my favorites.
Drone Strikes For Fun and Profit by Aaron Fox-Lerner
I am not sure what sub-genre this falls into exactly but it was extremely wild, all the more scary because I could definitely see something like this happening in our not so far future.
All the Lovely Brides by Kelly Sandoval
This one was pretty intense. It is about a Lord/God and his string of brides and the sacrifices they must make to keep him and his people healthy and prosperous.
A Recipe For Corpse Oil by Siobahn Gallagher
About a pick pocket who is asked to help get the ingredients for corpse oils. It involves him acquiring twelve chins and it is quite an interesting story.
The Woman I Used to Be by Gerri Leen
A dope story about a woman with amnesia after a space shuttle crash. This story was pretty fucking crazy and went places I definitely did not expect.
Ashes by Tara Calaby
This one was extremely dark and fantastically well written. Not action grimdark but grimdark for your soul and I loved it. It is a new spin on Cinderella as she feels just as trapped by being a princess as she did by her evil step family.
Against the Encroaching Darkness by Aliette De Bodard
A story about the sometimes impossible decisions one must make as a leader. This one was pretty intense.
Bad Seed by Mark Lawrence
I had read this one before in Road Brothers but I enjoyed it again this time through.
The rest of the stories for me ranged from just ok to pretty good. My opinion on some stories contained within are skewed because with the exception of Robin Hobb's The Liveship Traders I do not enjoy stories on boats. Hopefully I will find some that can change my mind on this.
Overall it was a good read. I got to read some stories by authors I enjoy and learned about some I had been previously unfamiliar with. Regardless of how I felt about the stories in this book I will be looking into their other work. I am aware that short stories are the time for them to experiment and play so I will be interested to see how their full length tales are.
If you are a fan of any of the authors listed on this book or a fan of grimdark in general then this is something you should definitely check out.
What it came down to was while all the stories fell in the grimdark genre some were just bloody violent fight scenes. I love fight scenes but for me they were lacking the story that makes me care about the outcome of the action. This is something I did not know I needed from a short story before I read this book. Due to this I had some clear favorites that were more emotionally grimdark than the others. Here they are in order they appeared not the order of my enjoyment.
The Right Hand of Decay by David Annandale
This story was about the ongoing war between Harrod and the Grey Queen and just how far they were willing to go to achieve complete victory over the others.
Brazen Dreams by Matthew Ward
This one was sci-fi which I am not really into but The twists this story that started out as a simple heist took came as quite a surprise. Enough so to add it to my favorites.
Drone Strikes For Fun and Profit by Aaron Fox-Lerner
I am not sure what sub-genre this falls into exactly but it was extremely wild, all the more scary because I could definitely see something like this happening in our not so far future.
All the Lovely Brides by Kelly Sandoval
This one was pretty intense. It is about a Lord/God and his string of brides and the sacrifices they must make to keep him and his people healthy and prosperous.
A Recipe For Corpse Oil by Siobahn Gallagher
About a pick pocket who is asked to help get the ingredients for corpse oils. It involves him acquiring twelve chins and it is quite an interesting story.
The Woman I Used to Be by Gerri Leen
A dope story about a woman with amnesia after a space shuttle crash. This story was pretty fucking crazy and went places I definitely did not expect.
Ashes by Tara Calaby
This one was extremely dark and fantastically well written. Not action grimdark but grimdark for your soul and I loved it. It is a new spin on Cinderella as she feels just as trapped by being a princess as she did by her evil step family.
Against the Encroaching Darkness by Aliette De Bodard
A story about the sometimes impossible decisions one must make as a leader. This one was pretty intense.
Bad Seed by Mark Lawrence
I had read this one before in Road Brothers but I enjoyed it again this time through.
The rest of the stories for me ranged from just ok to pretty good. My opinion on some stories contained within are skewed because with the exception of Robin Hobb's The Liveship Traders I do not enjoy stories on boats. Hopefully I will find some that can change my mind on this.
Overall it was a good read. I got to read some stories by authors I enjoy and learned about some I had been previously unfamiliar with. Regardless of how I felt about the stories in this book I will be looking into their other work. I am aware that short stories are the time for them to experiment and play so I will be interested to see how their full length tales are.
If you are a fan of any of the authors listed on this book or a fan of grimdark in general then this is something you should definitely check out.
More...