Scan barcode
kathydavie's review against another edition
5.0
Third in The Circle Opens fantasy series for middle-grade readers and seventh in the Emelan Universe revolving around four magically gifted children. The focus in Cold Fire is on Daja as she travels with Frostpine through the empire of Namorn. They are currently staying in Kugisko on Kadsaep Island.
If you're interested, there is a chronological listing of the Emelan books on my website.
My Take
It begins with a metaphor: Daja learning to skate. A skill that's new to her just as learning meditation and magic will be new to Nia and Jory.
I do enjoy Pierce's writing — I haven't yet read a book of hers that I didn't like. Parents will appreciate the moral lessons that Pierce imparts with a very light hand. Kids will appreciate the fun, fantasy, and adventures. Parents of twins may also find this useful as Nia and Jory may look alike but their temperaments and skills are completely different.
Cold Fire involves heroic bad guys as well as good guys and girls. The host family is a treat with Mom and Dad strict yet giving parents. They insist on the children learning, but they are flexible enough to adjust to the potential of their girls.
One of the many positives is Daja's wanting to create something new. A firesuit that will help Ben battle the fires that crop up around town and allow him to more easily save people. There is one particular incident with Frostpine that will crack up the kids with its absurdity. Poor Frostpine is so cold in Kugisko, that one day he takes off all his clothes and sits in the fire to warm up. Good thing he's a fire mage!!
On the negative side, it can be a hard story with the deaths the arsonist causes, and the death that awaits the guilty party at the end.
It doesn't take long to come to the conflict in the story. It is horrible. A firebug who wants praise and goes after it in the most reprehensible way. Glorying in the power of death over life. And Ben's mother is a NIGHTMARE! I reckon even story parents should be licensed before being able to have babies! Her son goes mute and wooden when she's around. The servants wear dull garb, get little to eat, and are whipped much too often. She counts out each grain of food and each splinter of wood. She is a master of insulting through supposed compliments.
Cold Fire is a lesson in control, of letting go, of being respectful to others, of acceptance.
The Story
Ladradun is a true hero in Daja's eyes. Brave enough to run into a burning building with no ability other than courage. It's this intrepid act that inspires Daja to create fire gauntlets and think deep about a firesuit.
That's the fun part of their stay. The not-so fun is when Daja discovers two young mages and learns she must teach them how to handle their abilities! It's the price she must pay for being taught her own magic.
The bad is a string of fires that plague Kugisko. Someone is setting bigger and bigger fires, and people are dying.
The Characters
Daja Kisubo is traveling with her mentor, the firemage Frostpine, to learn new techniques — and to take her mind off her friends who are also traveling.
Kolborn, a merchant, and Matazi Bancanor, his wife and a former seamstress, are the family who are hosting Daja and Frostpine. Kol is the head of the Kugisko Goldsmiths' Guild which controls the city's banks and one of Frostpine's friends from school. Niamara and Jorality "Jory" are their twelve-year-old twins who have been told they have no magic. Peigi is the eight-year-old. Eidart is a son. Anyussa is the Bancanor cook. Serg is the footman.
Bennat Ladradun, a non-mage, is one of the island merchants, of House Ladradun. He learned about fire at Godsforge's knee and, thankfully, has brought firefighting techniques home to the wooden city of Kigusko. Yulanny is one of the Ladradun maids. Kofrinna is the wife who died along with their children. Ravvi Morrachane Ladradun is Ben's mother and a right bitch. Cheap, mean, and nasty whose mere presence causes those around her to become wooden. The Alakut Island brigade does a terrible job.
The Mages' Society
Heluda Salt is the magistrate's mage. Master Northice is the head of the society and thinks all women are beautiful. Camoc Oakborn is a wood- and carpentry-mage with a prosperous woodworking shop. He's one of those who accepts Daja as a proper mage. Arnen is a senior-mage student. Other carpentry-mages include Ashstaff and Beechbranch. Olennika Potcracker in Blackfly Bog is the best cook-mage (she was once the Empress' personal cook!) and runs a hospital kitchen — Yogiry's Hospital — for the poor.
Domanus Moykep is the head of a ship-building family. His youngest son's boys need wives. It's their stable that burns down. Gruzha is a blind girl trapped in a burning boardinghouse. Teraud Voskajo may be an ugly man, but he is also the kindest and the leader of the smith's guild. Nushenya is his wife. Eoban is a very rude guest at a party. Olaksan Jossaryk's house also goes up in flames. Lisl is one of the many children there. Olaksan's wife, Chiora, is Romachko Skuretty's mistress. Romachko Skuretty is the head of the council who turned down a request for funds.
Pawel Godsforge is a renowned fire-mage. Ambient magic is a magic that is already in things. Viymese is a Namornese term for a female mage. The First Dedicate of the Fire temple in Winding Circle was once a general named Skyfire. It's his form of meditation that Daja adopts for Jory.
Yogiry is a goddess in Namorn; Griantein is a god of warmth and light. Vrohain the Judge is a god of justice. Qunoc is the mother of the earth and its seed while Baion is the god of killing ice. Eilig is the goddess of spring and freedom.
The Cover and Title
The cover is coolly warm as Daja skates across the gray frozen ice, a fireball in her hand while a fire claims a distant house that night.
The title is a blend of the Namornese winter, Daja's gift, and the string of arson fires that beset Kugisko that winter in its Cold Fire.
If you're interested, there is a chronological listing of the Emelan books on my website.
My Take
It begins with a metaphor: Daja learning to skate. A skill that's new to her just as learning meditation and magic will be new to Nia and Jory.
I do enjoy Pierce's writing — I haven't yet read a book of hers that I didn't like. Parents will appreciate the moral lessons that Pierce imparts with a very light hand. Kids will appreciate the fun, fantasy, and adventures. Parents of twins may also find this useful as Nia and Jory may look alike but their temperaments and skills are completely different.
Cold Fire involves heroic bad guys as well as good guys and girls. The host family is a treat with Mom and Dad strict yet giving parents. They insist on the children learning, but they are flexible enough to adjust to the potential of their girls.
One of the many positives is Daja's wanting to create something new. A firesuit that will help Ben battle the fires that crop up around town and allow him to more easily save people. There is one particular incident with Frostpine that will crack up the kids with its absurdity. Poor Frostpine is so cold in Kugisko, that one day he takes off all his clothes and sits in the fire to warm up. Good thing he's a fire mage!!
On the negative side, it can be a hard story with the deaths the arsonist causes, and the death that awaits the guilty party at the end.
It doesn't take long to come to the conflict in the story. It is horrible. A firebug who wants praise and goes after it in the most reprehensible way. Glorying in the power of death over life. And Ben's mother is a NIGHTMARE! I reckon even story parents should be licensed before being able to have babies! Her son goes mute and wooden when she's around. The servants wear dull garb, get little to eat, and are whipped much too often. She counts out each grain of food and each splinter of wood. She is a master of insulting through supposed compliments.
Cold Fire is a lesson in control, of letting go, of being respectful to others, of acceptance.
"That's what Traders do — we find roads, and we follow them.
Trader and Bookkeeper keep your balances high and your debts low."
The Story
Ladradun is a true hero in Daja's eyes. Brave enough to run into a burning building with no ability other than courage. It's this intrepid act that inspires Daja to create fire gauntlets and think deep about a firesuit.
That's the fun part of their stay. The not-so fun is when Daja discovers two young mages and learns she must teach them how to handle their abilities! It's the price she must pay for being taught her own magic.
The bad is a string of fires that plague Kugisko. Someone is setting bigger and bigger fires, and people are dying.
The Characters
Daja Kisubo is traveling with her mentor, the firemage Frostpine, to learn new techniques — and to take her mind off her friends who are also traveling.
Kolborn, a merchant, and Matazi Bancanor, his wife and a former seamstress, are the family who are hosting Daja and Frostpine. Kol is the head of the Kugisko Goldsmiths' Guild which controls the city's banks and one of Frostpine's friends from school. Niamara and Jorality "Jory" are their twelve-year-old twins who have been told they have no magic. Peigi is the eight-year-old. Eidart is a son. Anyussa is the Bancanor cook. Serg is the footman.
Bennat Ladradun, a non-mage, is one of the island merchants, of House Ladradun. He learned about fire at Godsforge's knee and, thankfully, has brought firefighting techniques home to the wooden city of Kigusko. Yulanny is one of the Ladradun maids. Kofrinna is the wife who died along with their children. Ravvi Morrachane Ladradun is Ben's mother and a right bitch. Cheap, mean, and nasty whose mere presence causes those around her to become wooden. The Alakut Island brigade does a terrible job.
The Mages' Society
Heluda Salt is the magistrate's mage. Master Northice is the head of the society and thinks all women are beautiful. Camoc Oakborn is a wood- and carpentry-mage with a prosperous woodworking shop. He's one of those who accepts Daja as a proper mage. Arnen is a senior-mage student. Other carpentry-mages include Ashstaff and Beechbranch. Olennika Potcracker in Blackfly Bog is the best cook-mage (she was once the Empress' personal cook!) and runs a hospital kitchen — Yogiry's Hospital — for the poor.
Domanus Moykep is the head of a ship-building family. His youngest son's boys need wives. It's their stable that burns down. Gruzha is a blind girl trapped in a burning boardinghouse. Teraud Voskajo may be an ugly man, but he is also the kindest and the leader of the smith's guild. Nushenya is his wife. Eoban is a very rude guest at a party. Olaksan Jossaryk's house also goes up in flames. Lisl is one of the many children there. Olaksan's wife, Chiora, is Romachko Skuretty's mistress. Romachko Skuretty is the head of the council who turned down a request for funds.
Pawel Godsforge is a renowned fire-mage. Ambient magic is a magic that is already in things. Viymese is a Namornese term for a female mage. The First Dedicate of the Fire temple in Winding Circle was once a general named Skyfire. It's his form of meditation that Daja adopts for Jory.
Yogiry is a goddess in Namorn; Griantein is a god of warmth and light. Vrohain the Judge is a god of justice. Qunoc is the mother of the earth and its seed while Baion is the god of killing ice. Eilig is the goddess of spring and freedom.
The Cover and Title
The cover is coolly warm as Daja skates across the gray frozen ice, a fireball in her hand while a fire claims a distant house that night.
The title is a blend of the Namornese winter, Daja's gift, and the string of arson fires that beset Kugisko that winter in its Cold Fire.
carlyxdeexx's review against another edition
4.0
Hello, Daja’s book! Some things that stood out to me about this one.
1) Pierce is really great at bringing attention to light/white skin. Oftentimes there’s this absence of skin color that occurs for white characters, which then creates a bizarre contrast when black characters are introduced and their skin is immediately mentioned as a key descriptor. It falls into the whole “default whiteness” issue that arises a LOT in media. That problem doesn’t exist here—Pierce indiscriminately references skin color, so we clearly see our dark- and light-skinned characters, no default assumed. It’s refreshing!
2) I am again reminded of how dark (yet sanitized?) these books manage to be. The villain of this one is truly terrifying.
3) Sandry’s book really pales in comparison to Briar’s and Daja’s. I’m wondering if Tris’s will top the rest. I do, however, kind of agree with other reviewers concerning the balance between Daja’s story and those of her students. Unlike the other books, in which the student would be something of a secondary protagonist, this book doesn’t focus on the perspectives of Daja’s students at all. They are purely tertiary to her other pursuits.
Namorn is a great setting—the concept of the frozen canals connecting all of the islands and serving as highways when frozen is such a treat to imagine. It’s fitting that I’m freezing in the bus’s intense air conditioning as I’m writing this. Like Frostpine, I’m looking forward to a warmer locale.
1) Pierce is really great at bringing attention to light/white skin. Oftentimes there’s this absence of skin color that occurs for white characters, which then creates a bizarre contrast when black characters are introduced and their skin is immediately mentioned as a key descriptor. It falls into the whole “default whiteness” issue that arises a LOT in media. That problem doesn’t exist here—Pierce indiscriminately references skin color, so we clearly see our dark- and light-skinned characters, no default assumed. It’s refreshing!
2) I am again reminded of how dark (yet sanitized?) these books manage to be. The villain of this one is truly terrifying.
3) Sandry’s book really pales in comparison to Briar’s and Daja’s. I’m wondering if Tris’s will top the rest. I do, however, kind of agree with other reviewers concerning the balance between Daja’s story and those of her students. Unlike the other books, in which the student would be something of a secondary protagonist, this book doesn’t focus on the perspectives of Daja’s students at all. They are purely tertiary to her other pursuits.
Namorn is a great setting—the concept of the frozen canals connecting all of the islands and serving as highways when frozen is such a treat to imagine. It’s fitting that I’m freezing in the bus’s intense air conditioning as I’m writing this. Like Frostpine, I’m looking forward to a warmer locale.
violetlantern's review against another edition
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
midici's review against another edition
4.0
Another re-read of Cold Fire. Of all the Circle Opens books, this one might be my least favourite. Which isn't to say that it's not good, or that I don't like it, but I find the other three in this quartet to be more engaging.
yaboywillyshakes's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Murder, Child death, Fire/Fire injury, and Death
Moderate: Physical abuse and Grief
Minor: Adult/minor relationship
tinynavajo's review against another edition
5.0
What happens when someone you thought a friends does something so horrible, you cannot understand why? Then what happens if they do that using a gift you made for them, to do good, to save lives? Daja has to figure it out quickly, before more lives are lost.
tani's review against another edition
4.0
My favorite of the series so far, and given how I'm stalled on Shatterglass, likely to stay that way. I find myself quite fond of Daja and her practical mind, and the villain in this one was certainly the most complex. Good stuff.
rini's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
freesiaelect's review against another edition
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.5