Scan barcode
ckeithjohnson's review against another edition
3.0
This was my favorite of the Force Awakens books in this little series. Luke's adventure, and Han's were both good, this one I really connected with for some reason. Possibly because I like Empire and the opening scenes of Return of the Jedi more than anything else in Star Wars, and this was a sort of bridge between the two.
Good and quick read for young Star Wars fans.
Good and quick read for young Star Wars fans.
calbowen's review against another edition
2.0
And the final installment of the useless 'filler' novels of Star Wars: The Force Awakens. The only good thing that comes out of this is the mention of a particular ship at the end of this, which I believe was just a throw in sentence, because it felt awkward in mentioning.
Again, a better behind the scenes story could have been told, such as Princess Leia's set-up as the bounty hunter to go rescue Han Solo from Jabba the Hutt. It is the same time period, so why not tell the story that would be more interesting. How did she come upon the uniform? Did someone teach her the language or did she already know it? Did anyone try to stop her or did she sneak away after the droids departed?
Overall, the three stories were disappointing in their subject matter not the writing itself. But, presented with stories that no one cares about with throw away characters, why bother. I say to pass on all three.
Again, a better behind the scenes story could have been told, such as Princess Leia's set-up as the bounty hunter to go rescue Han Solo from Jabba the Hutt. It is the same time period, so why not tell the story that would be more interesting. How did she come upon the uniform? Did someone teach her the language or did she already know it? Did anyone try to stop her or did she sneak away after the droids departed?
Overall, the three stories were disappointing in their subject matter not the writing itself. But, presented with stories that no one cares about with throw away characters, why bother. I say to pass on all three.
eahoffm2's review against another edition
adventurous
inspiring
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.75
kellbells's review against another edition
3.0
The best of this trio of chapter books, with some actual character development for Leia.
jenny_librarian's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
3.0
I didn’t love this book for several reasons, but even the premise is flawed in my eyes. I cannot believe that Leia would come up with a plan that would knowingly endanger innocent people just to give the Rebellion a chance to rally their forces. It just doesn’t sound like her. Had any other character brought it up and she went grudgingly along, I might have agreed. But this is too far fetched.
Then you have the characters that join her on this ludicrous quest. They’re all stereotypes, and I might’ve been fine with it, if it hadn’t been for Antrot. Antrot is so autistic-coded that it hurts. And not in the good way. He’s a walking autistic stereotype, down to the tech genius and the robotic talk. They don’t need a droid in this book because Antrot serves that purpose. And that makes me extremely mad.
Most of the book was forgettable. The action was mediocre. The conversation didn’t provide any new light on the Rebellion or the Empire (except for the interrogation droid thing at the end, and that was just uncomfortable to read). We don’t even know why or how the Imperial officer found them.
I’m disappointed. I thought other reviews were exaggerating because it’s a MG novel and adults tend to forget those are targeting tweens, but it’s just not a good book. I’m hoping the other two are better…
Then you have the characters that join her on this ludicrous quest. They’re all stereotypes, and I might’ve been fine with it, if it hadn’t been for Antrot. Antrot is so autistic-coded that it hurts. And not in the good way. He’s a walking autistic stereotype, down to the tech genius and the robotic talk. They don’t need a droid in this book because Antrot serves that purpose. And that makes me extremely mad.
Most of the book was forgettable. The action was mediocre. The conversation didn’t provide any new light on the Rebellion or the Empire (except for the interrogation droid thing at the end, and that was just uncomfortable to read). We don’t even know why or how the Imperial officer found them.
I’m disappointed. I thought other reviews were exaggerating because it’s a MG novel and adults tend to forget those are targeting tweens, but it’s just not a good book. I’m hoping the other two are better…
Content Warnings
Graphic: Ableism
Moderate: Death, War, and Torture
nikshelby's review against another edition
4.0
Yay! More Star Wars!
Some random quotes:
>>> "Everyone who helps us suffers because of it. That's how the Empire keeps people living in fear. By demonstrating that anything other than utter obedience brings brutality. The only way we can stop such evil is by ridding the galaxy of those who commit such acts. There is no negotiating with evil people."
>>> "Our faith means obligations. Such as standing in opposition to evil. Our obligation 'tis to do our duty. The consequences are not for us to determine."
Some random quotes:
>>> "Everyone who helps us suffers because of it. That's how the Empire keeps people living in fear. By demonstrating that anything other than utter obedience brings brutality. The only way we can stop such evil is by ridding the galaxy of those who commit such acts. There is no negotiating with evil people."
>>> "Our faith means obligations. Such as standing in opposition to evil. Our obligation 'tis to do our duty. The consequences are not for us to determine."
jmitschke's review against another edition
I'm no good at scary things that go bump in the dark anymore. Bummer because I love Princess Leia and wanted more of her story.
teachinsci's review against another edition
3.0
This story, which takes place between the Empire Strikes Back and a Return of the Jedi has a problem. For those who read what is now Star Wars Legends books, this story takes the place of the novel Shadows of the Empire. That book, which was action packed and introduced new and powerful opponents, was one I enjoyed quite a bit when I read it. This book was more a morality tale with some connections between Empire and Return thrown in.
The characters were almost tropes... the mercenary (kinda) pilot, the tech geek, the computer nerd, and the military hard-ass go on a mission with the princess-cum-general Leia. The mission and her life leading up to it actually made sense and captured the disarray of the Rebellion following Hoth. Because of the limits of the story, however, some of the movement between scenes and the parts that were out of Leia's direct sight are hidden to us. What is surprising is that this first person narration style did not give us more in the way of introspection and internal conflict that would be expected had this been a hook aimed at an older audience.
All-in-all, not bad, but not a great book by any means.
The characters were almost tropes... the mercenary (kinda) pilot, the tech geek, the computer nerd, and the military hard-ass go on a mission with the princess-cum-general Leia. The mission and her life leading up to it actually made sense and captured the disarray of the Rebellion following Hoth. Because of the limits of the story, however, some of the movement between scenes and the parts that were out of Leia's direct sight are hidden to us. What is surprising is that this first person narration style did not give us more in the way of introspection and internal conflict that would be expected had this been a hook aimed at an older audience.
All-in-all, not bad, but not a great book by any means.