Scan barcode
nightwithbooks's review against another edition
3.0
It's actually 3,5. It was cute read, but too much descriptions...
https://nightwithbook.wordpress.com/2018/06/16/%d0%be%d1%82%d0%b2%d1%8a%d0%b4%d0%b7%d0%b5%d0%bc%d1%8f-%d0%bd%d0%b0-%d1%82%d0%b0%d1%85%d0%b5%d1%80%d0%b5-%d0%bc%d0%b0%d1%84%d0%b8-%d0%bc%d0%bd%d0%b5%d0%bd%d0%b8%d0%b5-%d0%b4%d0%b5%d1%81/
https://nightwithbook.wordpress.com/2018/06/16/%d0%be%d1%82%d0%b2%d1%8a%d0%b4%d0%b7%d0%b5%d0%bc%d1%8f-%d0%bd%d0%b0-%d1%82%d0%b0%d1%85%d0%b5%d1%80%d0%b5-%d0%bc%d0%b0%d1%84%d0%b8-%d0%bc%d0%bd%d0%b5%d0%bd%d0%b8%d0%b5-%d0%b4%d0%b5%d1%81/
lexalehnus's review against another edition
4.0
It was okay! 4 stars. I did like the characters, but I wasn't huge on the setting/kind of plot. It was pretty interesting and kept me engaged, but a lot of it didn't make much sense or felt like it was happening just to happen. Partially my fault though because I didn't realize it was an Alice in Wonderland retelling until the middle of the book (which is an embarrassingly long time considering the main character's name is Alice) and I'm not a huge fan of Alice in Wonderland, so I was setting myself up for failure. I still liked it enough, though! And I do plan on reading the sequel/companion novel.
enur's review
5.0
Alice, Ferenorman denilen renklerle kaplı, sihrin çok tutumlu ve düzenli kullanıldığı bir dünyada yaşayan 12 yaşındaki bir kız. Ferenorman ve sakinleri renklerle kaplıyken Alice'in hiç rengi yoktur. Bu onun için derin bir yara. Üstelik babası 3 yıl önce ortadan kaybolduğundan beri onu teselli eden kimsesi de yok. Annesi ve 3 erkek kardeşinden de aradığı ilgi, alakayı göremeyen Alice'in tek bir hayali var. 12 yaşındayken Teslimiyet denilen bir aşamadan geçiyorlar. Herkes yeteneklerini sergiliyor ve buna göre bir görev alıyor. Alice, en iyisi olmak istiyor. Tam da bu zamanda ona daha önce tüm Ferenorman'daki en çirkin kız olduğunu söyleyen ve onu çok inciten Oliver Newbanks tekrar karşısına çıkıyor. Kendi teslimiyet görevinde Alice'e ihtiyacı olduğunu söyleyip babasını bulabileceği bir yolculuğa, Ötediyar'a gitmeyi teklif ediyor. (Burada biraz Alice Harikalar Diyarında ve Yeşilin Kızı Anne harmanlanmış gibi değil mi?)
311 sayfadan oluşan kısa bir kitap. Fantastik kurgularda dünyayı okuyucuya aktarmak zor olduğundan zaman yani sayfa istiyor. Ötediyar'da biz hem Ferenorman'ı hem Ötediyar'ı okuyoruz ve ikisinin de nasıl dünyalar olduğunu, kültürlerini, yapısını macera yaşarken an an öğreniyoruz. Bir yandan da karakterleri tanıdık. Bütünlük açısından çok takdir ettim.
Bu yetişkinlere yönelik bir kitap değil. Bence kitabı okumadan önce, okurken bunu hatırlamak gerekiyor. Modern yazarlık sebebiyle ortadan kaybolmamasını umduğum bir masal anlatımıyla yazılmış. İçerikte klasik masal anlatımındaki karanlık unsurlar da var. Verilmek istenilen mesajlar da bu unsurlar kullanılarak aktarılmış. Hâlâ bu şekilde kitaplar yazabilen, hikayeler anlatabilen yazarların varlığı çok kıymetli. Yetişkin bir okur olarak tümüyle bayıldım.
311 sayfadan oluşan kısa bir kitap. Fantastik kurgularda dünyayı okuyucuya aktarmak zor olduğundan zaman yani sayfa istiyor. Ötediyar'da biz hem Ferenorman'ı hem Ötediyar'ı okuyoruz ve ikisinin de nasıl dünyalar olduğunu, kültürlerini, yapısını macera yaşarken an an öğreniyoruz. Bir yandan da karakterleri tanıdık. Bütünlük açısından çok takdir ettim.
Bu yetişkinlere yönelik bir kitap değil. Bence kitabı okumadan önce, okurken bunu hatırlamak gerekiyor. Modern yazarlık sebebiyle ortadan kaybolmamasını umduğum bir masal anlatımıyla yazılmış. İçerikte klasik masal anlatımındaki karanlık unsurlar da var. Verilmek istenilen mesajlar da bu unsurlar kullanılarak aktarılmış. Hâlâ bu şekilde kitaplar yazabilen, hikayeler anlatabilen yazarların varlığı çok kıymetli. Yetişkin bir okur olarak tümüyle bayıldım.
mayling23's review against another edition
4.0
“Alice would choose to love herself, different and extraordinary, every day of the week.”
If you are looking for a cute, magical and whimsical read with a beautiful flowery writing style, this book is that one. I truly enjoyed the way the book was written, character development, the magic system...everything was so unique. And also can we just admit that that cover is splendid? Even though I loved this story very much, I couldn't give it 5 stars because of that ending. I found it too rushed and not that satisfying yet I still think this book is worth your time.
However, I don't know if I 100% agree with the fact this is supposed to be "a middle grade" story. Although I see why it is labeled this way, I honestly see older readers enjoy it way more. The world of Furthermore was raw and sometimes too cruel, but also many thoughts were too deep for such a young audience. In my opinion, this story is for everyone, no matter how old are you.
If you are looking for a cute, magical and whimsical read with a beautiful flowery writing style, this book is that one. I truly enjoyed the way the book was written, character development, the magic system...everything was so unique. And also can we just admit that that cover is splendid? Even though I loved this story very much, I couldn't give it 5 stars because of that ending. I found it too rushed and not that satisfying yet I still think this book is worth your time.
However, I don't know if I 100% agree with the fact this is supposed to be "a middle grade" story. Although I see why it is labeled this way, I honestly see older readers enjoy it way more. The world of Furthermore was raw and sometimes too cruel, but also many thoughts were too deep for such a young audience. In my opinion, this story is for everyone, no matter how old are you.
sumayyaha's review against another edition
5.0
I love these characters! I loved Tahereh's writing! I was fascinated by the plot! And I want more.
mariahistryingtoread's review against another edition
2.0
Furthermore was my last pick for asianreadathon 2020.
I was drawn to this book because of its cover. It's so vibrant and eye-catching that I couldn't help, but be intrigued. Unfortunately, this book completely embodies 'don't judge a book by its cover' in the worst way.
Alice Alexis Queensmeadow is a poor girl who lives in the magical town of Ferenwood. Sadly for her she lacks all color and is iffy on the magic as well. Plus, her beloved father has been missing for 3 years and her mother barely seems to care about her at all. But, that's when Oliver Newbacks appears tasked with finding her father and needs her help to look for him in the equally magical - but totally lawless - Furthermore.
I was put off immediately because of the writing style. It's written in a faux whimsical way with the author often jumping in to tell you how to feel. Not only did this feel like a cop-out for actually doing the hard work of crafting three-dimentional characters, it also made me so frustrated I was unable to really like anybody. There was no space for me to experience the characters for myself and reflect. Tahereh Mafi was constantly jumping in to over explain what was going on. I'm not a kid and even if I was, kids are smart enough to reason out why someone might lie or be rude to another person. There doesn't need to be some heavy handed spiel about how sometimes people who are isolated form defense mechanisms. That's implied by you actually having things happen, me reading about the characters' reactions and then piecing it together on my own. Way too much tell and don't show in this book.
I don't think it's supposed to be an Alice in Wonderland fusion yet I often felt like this book was the knock of version of that story. But, Furthermore had none of the charm nor wit. It was supposed to be this wild, scary place filled with literal cannibals. Instead, it was just confusing and rather mild-mannered. It's populated by villages that each have their own set of rules and breaking them could result in the afore-mentioned cannibalism. However, Alice and Oliver really only go to like 5 or so places. And despite setting up this whole deadline situation where you can't take up too much time or you'll be in trouble, there's no suspense whatsoever. Again, we're *told* about these obstacles but not shown how threatening they really are. There's no pressing time police, there's no location they have to be at by a certain time, there's no person they *must* meet. Literally like halfway through they completely abandon the main plot for a side quest that takes up the entire rest of the book.
And they, by sheer happenstance, waltz right into the ending. It's not earned at all. Furthermore is supposed to need all this intelligence and critical thinking to make it through, but honestly all I saw was a lot of running. Mafi didn't write any kind of puzzles or tricks nor was there an underlying twist (like how in Through The Looking Glass the whole story - while ridiculous - is actually a game of chess). Later on in the book it even implies that free will doesn't exist in Furthermore which makes all of this matter even less.
The character arcs also run right into a wall. We don't properly finish Alice's arc about self-acceptance, address her mothers' mistreatment of her all these years, or tie together the 'lessons' from Furthermore to Olivers' major character flaw. All of these are made to be major plot points only to go absolutely nowhere or end so abruptly you're left feeling underwhelmed.
And on the topic of characters there weren't enough of them. I really wanted to dig into the depths of Furthermore. The best way to do that would be by meeting some of its denizens. However, despite Oliver making a point to say that not everyone is an evil cannibal they meet only two and half people who aren't. And I'm being generous counting it as I am. It's particularly egregious since Oliver literally lived in Furthermore a year before having to get Alice's help and implies he has a fair amount of friends. Why don't we call on any of them? Oh, that's right, because they totally shift the direction of the story in a poor attempt to make Alice actually relevant.
That brings me to Alice herself. She's the whole catalyst here because Oliver needs her to find her father. Too bad she's useless. When it comes down to it Oliver has all the real skills to survive in Furthermore and Alice is only needed for one thing. Also their friendship is so rushed you can't even point to that as her true reason for being there. She's little more than a combative liability.
So this is super long, but I'm kind of annoyed that such an interesting premise was executed so poorly. I gave it two stars because I somehow still kind of like Alice and even with all the issues I had it wasn't 1 star bad imo.
I was drawn to this book because of its cover. It's so vibrant and eye-catching that I couldn't help, but be intrigued. Unfortunately, this book completely embodies 'don't judge a book by its cover' in the worst way.
Alice Alexis Queensmeadow is a poor girl who lives in the magical town of Ferenwood. Sadly for her she lacks all color and is iffy on the magic as well. Plus, her beloved father has been missing for 3 years and her mother barely seems to care about her at all. But, that's when Oliver Newbacks appears tasked with finding her father and needs her help to look for him in the equally magical - but totally lawless - Furthermore.
I was put off immediately because of the writing style. It's written in a faux whimsical way with the author often jumping in to tell you how to feel. Not only did this feel like a cop-out for actually doing the hard work of crafting three-dimentional characters, it also made me so frustrated I was unable to really like anybody. There was no space for me to experience the characters for myself and reflect. Tahereh Mafi was constantly jumping in to over explain what was going on. I'm not a kid and even if I was, kids are smart enough to reason out why someone might lie or be rude to another person. There doesn't need to be some heavy handed spiel about how sometimes people who are isolated form defense mechanisms. That's implied by you actually having things happen, me reading about the characters' reactions and then piecing it together on my own. Way too much tell and don't show in this book.
I don't think it's supposed to be an Alice in Wonderland fusion yet I often felt like this book was the knock of version of that story. But, Furthermore had none of the charm nor wit. It was supposed to be this wild, scary place filled with literal cannibals. Instead, it was just confusing and rather mild-mannered. It's populated by villages that each have their own set of rules and breaking them could result in the afore-mentioned cannibalism. However, Alice and Oliver really only go to like 5 or so places. And despite setting up this whole deadline situation where you can't take up too much time or you'll be in trouble, there's no suspense whatsoever. Again, we're *told* about these obstacles but not shown how threatening they really are. There's no pressing time police, there's no location they have to be at by a certain time, there's no person they *must* meet. Literally like halfway through they completely abandon the main plot for a side quest that takes up the entire rest of the book.
And they, by sheer happenstance, waltz right into the ending. It's not earned at all. Furthermore is supposed to need all this intelligence and critical thinking to make it through, but honestly all I saw was a lot of running. Mafi didn't write any kind of puzzles or tricks nor was there an underlying twist (like how in Through The Looking Glass the whole story - while ridiculous - is actually a game of chess). Later on in the book it even implies that free will doesn't exist in Furthermore which makes all of this matter even less.
The character arcs also run right into a wall. We don't properly finish Alice's arc about self-acceptance, address her mothers' mistreatment of her all these years, or tie together the 'lessons' from Furthermore to Olivers' major character flaw. All of these are made to be major plot points only to go absolutely nowhere or end so abruptly you're left feeling underwhelmed.
And on the topic of characters there weren't enough of them. I really wanted to dig into the depths of Furthermore. The best way to do that would be by meeting some of its denizens. However, despite Oliver making a point to say that not everyone is an evil cannibal they meet only two and half people who aren't. And I'm being generous counting it as I am. It's particularly egregious since Oliver literally lived in Furthermore a year before having to get Alice's help and implies he has a fair amount of friends. Why don't we call on any of them? Oh, that's right, because they totally shift the direction of the story in a poor attempt to make Alice actually relevant.
That brings me to Alice herself. She's the whole catalyst here because Oliver needs her to find her father. Too bad she's useless. When it comes down to it Oliver has all the real skills to survive in Furthermore and Alice is only needed for one thing. Also their friendship is so rushed you can't even point to that as her true reason for being there. She's little more than a combative liability.
So this is super long, but I'm kind of annoyed that such an interesting premise was executed so poorly. I gave it two stars because I somehow still kind of like Alice and even with all the issues I had it wasn't 1 star bad imo.
dragonboot's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
4.0
This was delightful! I enjoyed it a lot more than I thought I would.
mehsi's review against another edition
I read, or tried to read, this one in Dutch, but will write a little bit in English. This was one of my most anticipated books of 2016.
I got to page 100+ and I just couldn't read any further. Endless descriptions that just tired me. Instead of seeing the world, I just saw a blur of rainbow puke (since everything was supposedly so full of colour). Poetic words that sometimes don't bother me, but in this one it did. Pretentious, fancy words/language that just didn't fit. I didn't like the MC, she was just meh to me. Olivier was even worse. Our MC's mom was terrible.
I got to page 100+ and I just couldn't read any further. Endless descriptions that just tired me. Instead of seeing the world, I just saw a blur of rainbow puke (since everything was supposedly so full of colour). Poetic words that sometimes don't bother me, but in this one it did. Pretentious, fancy words/language that just didn't fit. I didn't like the MC, she was just meh to me. Olivier was even worse. Our MC's mom was terrible.