Reviews

Gaia: Goddess of Earth by Imogen Greenberg

saccalai's review

Go to review page

3.5

This is a wonderful way for younger people to learn about mythology and includes a lovely message to encourage them to change the world. The signature Greenberg illustration style is bright, colourful and engaging.

pagesandpaws's review

Go to review page

2.5

 
Unfortunately, I was disappointed with what this book brought me. I totally understand what it was trying to do and I do think that the authors achieved some of the goals that they clearly set out to with this book. That being said it felt like a bit of a missed opportunity and not as authentic as I would have preferred. 
But lets start of with the things I did enjoy. I loved the art style throughout this book, I thought that each character was clear and distinguishable by their appearance and the colour palette was very aesthetically pleasing. I also thought that the pacing and length of this book was perfect, it didn't seem drawn out or rushed at any point and will work well for the target audience. In general I think children will really like this story, even more so with if they don't know much about greek mythology. The themes on looking after the natural world and human greed were ones I think were handled well and are important. 
That being said it is very inaccurate in its mythology which to me is a real shame, I understand that not everything is kid friendly when it comes to these myths but some of the more drastic changes I felt actually dampened the message the book was trying to spread. I also think the font on the book should be revised to make sure it is accessible as I definitely found some parts challenging to read.  
More...