Reviews

The Smiler With the Knife by Nicholas Blake

bev_reads_mysteries's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0


Nigel and Georgia have just settled into a life of rural domesticity in Devon when they notice some dubious goings-on in the little village. It all starts when Georgia's sharp eyes spot a tarnished locket while trimming their hedge. The locket holds a photo and a strange circular badge...and apparently belongs to Major Keston. Then the Major entertains some rather unusual visitors and seems to be indulging in a spot of smuggling under the cover of a local ghost legend. But what exactly is being smuggled? Nigel consults his uncle Sir John Strangeways who is also the head of Scotland Yard's C-Branch. Sir John needs someone to infiltrate what looks to be an underground Nazi-sympathizer organization located in the heart of England. Nigel's reputation as an investigator with close ties to the police make him unsuitable--so a plan is hatched to distance Georgia from the Strangeways so she can go on one more adventure. An adventure that will not only put her life in danger--but an adventure that will also decide the fate of England. She will have to use all her resources as an adventuress to make her way through the affair.

After I adjusted to the fact that Nigel was not the hero of the piece, I settled down to enjoy this political thriller with a very resourceful heroine indeed. Georgia handles herself rather well among the hush-hush cloak and dagger types and uses great ingenuity to get herself out of some rather tight places. She dresses up as everything from Father Christmas to a Radiance Girl (a cross between an interpretative dancer and a New Age devotee) and is aided by adventurer-wannabes like the manager of a well-known department store and a plucky vicar's wife. There's a cross-country chase and Georgia manages a rather MacGyver-style escape. It's all great fun and a thrilling adventure all in the name of foiling the fascist bad guys. No great mysteries here, just a straight political thriller complete with evil master mind and henchmen. A topical story for the times which has held up very well. ★★★ and a half.

First posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.

persey's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Published in 1939 and set in the near future, this is a revealing take on its own times and scarily apropos right now in its invocation of creeping authoritarianism, the appeal of fascism and the cult of personality. Unfortunately, much of it is just absurd even for a cozy with its charades, clock golf and more, and it undermines the sense of menace with repeated “had she but known” invocations which make it clear there will be a good outcome. Not that it was in doubt, but it would be much more effective not to be continually clobbered with that reassurance.
More...