Scan barcode
amyvl93's review against another edition
funny
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
I was really excited to read Olive as novels about women who choose to be childfree still feel few and far between, and I was interested to read something that grapples with this. However for me this novel missed the mark, largely because our protagonist was The Worst.
Olive Stone (yes really) has recently broken up with her long-term boyfriend because he is ready for children and she doesn't think she wants them. Meanwhile, her best friends from secondary school have all followed this path; her friend Bea became a Mum early and how has three children, Cecily is ready to pop with her first baby and Isla is struggling to conceive and going through IVF. In her role working as an senior member of the team at an online feminism website, Olive begins to explore what it means to be childfree. We also get flashback scenes to Olive and her friends from university through their twenties as their lives change.
I found most of the characters fairly unbearable, and from the start the lack of communication between this group of apparent deep best friends just struck me as unbelievable; Olive as a protagonist is deeply judgemental of almost everyone she interacts with (and covers this up by just saying she's a journalist constantly) which makes it somewhat unsurprising that she apparently has no other friends than three people she's known since she was a child. What could have been an interesting exploration of important topics mostly had me hoping that I don't turn out like Olive; whilst her friends were all managing to live family lives in London and the South East which are entirely out of reach for most other people.
There were definitely moments in Olive that rang true - Isla's deeply complicated feelings about fertility, a nightmare baby shower, Olive's first attendance at a childfree session and her early interactions with a new love interest.
However, it felt like there were too many plotlines that were introduced (Olive's heavy drinking, some terrible partners, literally any of her writing) and go no where - it's almost hinted that Olive's reliance on alcohol is 'cured' by the arrival of a new relationship. There are important topics within the pages of Olive, which will hopefully be picked up in more successful novels.
Olive Stone (yes really) has recently broken up with her long-term boyfriend because he is ready for children and she doesn't think she wants them. Meanwhile, her best friends from secondary school have all followed this path; her friend Bea became a Mum early and how has three children, Cecily is ready to pop with her first baby and Isla is struggling to conceive and going through IVF. In her role working as an senior member of the team at an online feminism website, Olive begins to explore what it means to be childfree. We also get flashback scenes to Olive and her friends from university through their twenties as their lives change.
I found most of the characters fairly unbearable, and from the start the lack of communication between this group of apparent deep best friends just struck me as unbelievable; Olive as a protagonist is deeply judgemental of almost everyone she interacts with (and covers this up by just saying she's a journalist constantly) which makes it somewhat unsurprising that she apparently has no other friends than three people she's known since she was a child. What could have been an interesting exploration of important topics mostly had me hoping that I don't turn out like Olive; whilst her friends were all managing to live family lives in London and the South East which are entirely out of reach for most other people.
There were definitely moments in Olive that rang true - Isla's deeply complicated feelings about fertility, a nightmare baby shower, Olive's first attendance at a childfree session and her early interactions with a new love interest.
However, it felt like there were too many plotlines that were introduced (Olive's heavy drinking, some terrible partners, literally any of her writing) and go no where - it's almost hinted that Olive's reliance on alcohol is 'cured' by the arrival of a new relationship. There are important topics within the pages of Olive, which will hopefully be picked up in more successful novels.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Infertility
Minor: Alcoholism and Death
overbookedmama's review against another edition
emotional
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Content Warnings
Minor: Abortion, Miscarriage, Infidelity, Infertility, Grief, Eating disorder, Death, and Alcoholism
More...