Reviews

Earth 2, Vol. 6: Collision by Tom Taylor, Marguerite Bennett, Daniel H. Wilson, Andy Smith

trike's review against another edition

1.0

This was so choppy it was nearly incomprehensible. No flow at all and it feels like every three pages was done by a different team. Plus none of the vignettes have proper endings. I don’t even really know how it relates to what had gone before. And then it all comes to an ending in just a few pages, but we never get to see what happened to characters just a couple pages earlier. Nor is there any appearance by the big bands. Truly bizarre.

tmaluck's review against another edition

2.0

If I've got my story threads straight, I believe the issues comprising this trade are meant to interweave with the World's End event issues, which is unfortunate because many of these issues are build-up for characters without any payoff. This trade is a lot of backstory without any sort of catharsis or resolution - not that catharsis is mandatory, but on its own, this volume is more like a montage than anything.

jamesflint's review

2.0

Rep: gay characters, black character, Chinese-American character

ik it was only meant as like. setting up world's end & that but uh. it was chaos basically & the only thing i got from it was that technically sam zhao is alive & thats all i rly care about