Scan barcode
rymdkejsaren's review
3.0
It's quite slow to build and the formatting often left me confused about the perspective changes. But it's a fascinating look at the world of today written 30 years ago. It's also quite disturbing in places, and because of the repeated perspective switches and a fairly jumble voice, it's sometimes hard to separate the actions and beliefs of the characters from the overall voice of the book.
errantdreams's review
4.0
There are ways in which the book now feels behind the times, obviously. No smart phones, still using VCRs and modems (modems!), no web cams. That makes a huge difference in the plot. It also slows down character research, which makes up a large part of the book–but Brunner makes it interesting.
There were some plot developments this time that seemed a little obvious, but while I admit my memory sucks, I’m pretty sure that’s just because I’ve read it before. It made an impression when I was in high school!
The characters in this book are quite good. They aren’t always likable. They stumble around trying to figure out what’s going on and often get it wrong. It is the case that the young women in this group of children lose some of their knack for influence during their periods. I thought that was actually a rather brilliant move on evolution’s part–it strongly encourages reproduction by allowing them to retain their abilities for nine months simply by having babies. Meanwhile, the children have to figure out how ‘best’ to manage their abilities, and each one is very different from the others. Some had simply stayed with their families; some ran criminal rackets; and almost all of them were in control of their ‘parents’. Only David is willing to take on the task of hunting down and bringing in his siblings, planning to use them to ‘save’ the world from itself. Another thing I like about these kids is that most if not all of them come across as narcissistic sociopaths–they have to watch the people around them in order to learn proper emotional responses.
Just to make things a little crazier for Peter, his own daughter Ellen, who has never met him, is forced on him due to the death of her mother. He has no interest in being a parent, but the two of them grow together and help each other in many ways.
On an almost irrelevant note, Peter at some point learns that there’s a crisis because an approved pesticide is now killing all the bees. Brunner had a touch of prescience there.
I liked this book almost as much as I did as a child, and would love to see more of this world.
Original review on my site: http://www.errantdreams.com/2016/06/nostalgia-review-children-of-the-thunder-john-brunner/
There were some plot developments this time that seemed a little obvious, but while I admit my memory sucks, I’m pretty sure that’s just because I’ve read it before. It made an impression when I was in high school!
The characters in this book are quite good. They aren’t always likable. They stumble around trying to figure out what’s going on and often get it wrong. It is the case that the young women in this group of children lose some of their knack for influence during their periods. I thought that was actually a rather brilliant move on evolution’s part–it strongly encourages reproduction by allowing them to retain their abilities for nine months simply by having babies. Meanwhile, the children have to figure out how ‘best’ to manage their abilities, and each one is very different from the others. Some had simply stayed with their families; some ran criminal rackets; and almost all of them were in control of their ‘parents’. Only David is willing to take on the task of hunting down and bringing in his siblings, planning to use them to ‘save’ the world from itself. Another thing I like about these kids is that most if not all of them come across as narcissistic sociopaths–they have to watch the people around them in order to learn proper emotional responses.
Just to make things a little crazier for Peter, his own daughter Ellen, who has never met him, is forced on him due to the death of her mother. He has no interest in being a parent, but the two of them grow together and help each other in many ways.
On an almost irrelevant note, Peter at some point learns that there’s a crisis because an approved pesticide is now killing all the bees. Brunner had a touch of prescience there.
I liked this book almost as much as I did as a child, and would love to see more of this world.
Original review on my site: http://www.errantdreams.com/2016/06/nostalgia-review-children-of-the-thunder-john-brunner/
More...