Scan barcode
anatrnd's review
4.0
це було чудово! Торн тепер одна з моїх улюблених фентезі персонажок, бо НУ ВОНА >>>>>>>. романтика спочатку здавалась зайвою у цій пригодницькій, політичній та досить жорстокій серії, та і я не дуже люблю троп ґуд бой × бед ґьорл, але я просто закохалась в Торн і Бранда, вони чудові, і їхнє кохання поступово розвивалось, за що плюсик автору. до речі, в цій частині підвезли вже справжнє фентезі (ельфійську магію), бо у першій частині, як пам'ятаєте, нічого, крім вигаданого світу, не було.
загалом, мені дуже сподобалось продовження, можливо навіть більше, ніж "Пів короля". єдиним мінусом (кайнда?) виділила б те, що Ярві якийсь зовсім інший, порівняно з попередньою книжкою, і це мейкз сенс, бо у нього вже нова посада, але все одно був певний дисонанс, що це інший персонаж, а не головний герої першої частини
загалом, мені дуже сподобалось продовження, можливо навіть більше, ніж "Пів короля". єдиним мінусом (кайнда?) виділила б те, що Ярві якийсь зовсім інший, порівняно з попередньою книжкою, і це мейкз сенс, бо у нього вже нова посада, але все одно був певний дисонанс, що це інший персонаж, а не головний герої першої частини
nixueq's review
adventurous
emotional
tense
medium-paced
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
A loveable YA. Simpler/lighter than other Abercrombie's books, but it was a perfect read for a train ride. I liked the focus on a female character. I disagreed with some character development, but I guess it's a personal preference thing. The style was nice, the characters mostly well-written.
eurenei's review against another edition
adventurous
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
spacepandita2022's review against another edition
El primer libro tenía un trama super sencilla (príncipe es traicionado, y vemos todo el trayecto de él intentando volver a su reino) no hay nada nuevo u innovador, pero con un buen protagonista. Si pierdes un buen protagonista con una trama tan sencilla, todo se derrumba. Siempre quería saber lo que pasaría con Yarvi (libro 1), en este libro no lo tengo.
Espina y Brad, no me convencen como protagonistas, ella es una guerrera fuerte, y ya está, no conozco más allá en ella aparte de eso, así que no logro interesarme en ninguno de los dos, y ya en el 41% de la novela tendríamos que conocerla más. Solo esperaba los momentos en que aparecía el Padre Yarvi (el protagonista del primer libro, medio rey) y eso era menos del 1% de la novela.
Voy a continuar con el tercero de la trilogía, capaz eso si me gusta, solo esperemos que se entienda bien considerando que no sé como termina este libro.
Espina y Brad, no me convencen como protagonistas, ella es una guerrera fuerte, y ya está, no conozco más allá en ella aparte de eso, así que no logro interesarme en ninguno de los dos, y ya en el 41% de la novela tendríamos que conocerla más. Solo esperaba los momentos en que aparecía el Padre Yarvi (el protagonista del primer libro, medio rey) y eso era menos del 1% de la novela.
Voy a continuar con el tercero de la trilogía, capaz eso si me gusta, solo esperemos que se entienda bien considerando que no sé como termina este libro.
abbeysykes's review against another edition
adventurous
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
ian_ramos's review
adventurous
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
jenhurst's review against another edition
3.0
I was disappointed that it followed different character and it felt very much like a middle book.
sandrameij98's review
adventurous
dark
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
psoglav's review against another edition
4.0
UKUPNA OCENA (overall rating) - 7/10
Radnja (story) - 7/10
Likovi (characters) - 9/10
Pripovedanje (writing style) - 10/10
Okruženje (setting) - 7/10
Aberkrombijev stil pisanja je i dalje odličan, sa živopisnim likovima i odličnim kvazi-srednjevekovnim svetom sa vikinzima kozacima i rusima, koji je izgleda postapokalipsa našeg sveta (izgleda da su današnji ljudi nekadašnji vilin narod). Šteta je što pisac više ne razrađuje ovu ideju.
Za razliku od prethodnog dela, čini mi se da je radnja malo usporena, da ima manje živopisnih opisa borbi, a i kao da su glavni likovi već viđeni u njegovim prethodnim romanima, samo dosta manje upečatljivi.
Sačekaću i treći deo da dam konačni sud o trilogiji, ali nakon nedavno prošitane "Osvete" (koja je po recenzijama "najslabija" od 3 novele u svetu Oštrice - Best Served cold, The Heroes i Red Country) imam utisak da se ABerkrombi malo umorio od primene istog šablona u svojim romanima, i da promena okruženja i sveta gde se radnja odvija prosto nije dovoljna...
Radnja (story) - 7/10
Likovi (characters) - 9/10
Pripovedanje (writing style) - 10/10
Okruženje (setting) - 7/10
Aberkrombijev stil pisanja je i dalje odličan, sa živopisnim likovima i odličnim kvazi-srednjevekovnim svetom sa vikinzima kozacima i rusima, koji je izgleda postapokalipsa našeg sveta (izgleda da su današnji ljudi nekadašnji vilin narod). Šteta je što pisac više ne razrađuje ovu ideju.
Za razliku od prethodnog dela, čini mi se da je radnja malo usporena, da ima manje živopisnih opisa borbi, a i kao da su glavni likovi već viđeni u njegovim prethodnim romanima, samo dosta manje upečatljivi.
Sačekaću i treći deo da dam konačni sud o trilogiji, ali nakon nedavno prošitane "Osvete" (koja je po recenzijama "najslabija" od 3 novele u svetu Oštrice - Best Served cold, The Heroes i Red Country) imam utisak da se ABerkrombi malo umorio od primene istog šablona u svojim romanima, i da promena okruženja i sveta gde se radnja odvija prosto nije dovoljna...
peterkeep's review against another edition
5.0
A worthy successor in every way to his YA debut, Half a King. It's got every bit of the same Joe Abercrombie-isms that I'll buy into every time he writes them. I can gush for more of that, but at some point it's probably embarrassing how much I enjoy his combination of cynicism, grit, humor, and awkward self-criticism.
He did do something new and neat, though: in his second book of the trilogy, he switched up the characters. We're a few years removed from the events of the first book, and those characters are very much involved in the events of this book, but the two "main" characters, Thorn and Brand, are completely new. It's kind of cool to see things through new eyes. With short snappy books like this, it makes a lot of sense to switch up the POV characters, since we don't have the page-count to follow a long realistic character development. Instead of rushing things or forcing new perspective changes alongside one that could be a bit tired, he gets pretty daring and starts over.
It paid off really well! These characters are definitely nothing new for him - he's written a quiet warrior who is plagued by his morals butting up against his strength and expectations. He's written the female with a chip on her shoulder, and he's even written the slow awkward romance before. But it still works well here and he does it with some new twists and unique details.
He also does some exposition on his world, and it turns out to be pretty much what I expected going in. Once I heard that this wasn't going to be a part of his First Law world, I guessed that it would be.
Anyways, even with that being a bit underwhelming, I'm still really happy with the trilogy so far. It looks like there's a nice plot set up for the final volume, and I'm excited to see what Abercrombie does with the final book: new POV characters again, or a combination of the ones we've seen already? I need to get around buying the final book to finish it out sooner rather than later.
He did do something new and neat, though: in his second book of the trilogy, he switched up the characters. We're a few years removed from the events of the first book, and those characters are very much involved in the events of this book, but the two "main" characters, Thorn and Brand, are completely new. It's kind of cool to see things through new eyes. With short snappy books like this, it makes a lot of sense to switch up the POV characters, since we don't have the page-count to follow a long realistic character development. Instead of rushing things or forcing new perspective changes alongside one that could be a bit tired, he gets pretty daring and starts over.
It paid off really well! These characters are definitely nothing new for him - he's written a quiet warrior who is plagued by his morals butting up against his strength and expectations. He's written the female with a chip on her shoulder, and he's even written the slow awkward romance before. But it still works well here and he does it with some new twists and unique details.
He also does some exposition on his world, and it turns out to be pretty much what I expected going in. Once I heard that this wasn't going to be a part of his First Law world, I guessed that it would be
Spoiler
a post-apocalyptic world, where WE'RE the people who left all of the relics behind and shattered the world, etc.Anyways, even with that being a bit underwhelming, I'm still really happy with the trilogy so far. It looks like there's a nice plot set up for the final volume, and I'm excited to see what Abercrombie does with the final book: new POV characters again, or a combination of the ones we've seen already? I need to get around buying the final book to finish it out sooner rather than later.