Reviews

The Dirty Secrets Club by Meg Gardiner

dereadergal's review against another edition

4.0

This is a great, fast paced thriller that leaves the reader wondering what will happen next every time they put the book down. The characters are well developed and are likable. Although the story is sometimes somewhat hard to follow and some parts could be a bit better, it is exciting and well worth reading.

laurenjodi's review against another edition

4.0

The Dirty Secrets Club by Meg Gardiner
Book #1 in the Jo Beckett series
4 Stars

Synopsis:
As a forensic psychiatrist or "dead-shrinker", Dr. Jo Beckett works with the police on cases in which the manner of death (accident, homicide, suicide) is unclear. In this debut book, Jo is called in when an up-and-coming DA is killed in what appears to be a murder-suicide. Once Jo begins digging it becomes clear that the young attorney was involved in a sinister organization whose members of being targeted. Can Jo stop the conspirators before she becomes one of their victims?

Review:
Well-written with a solid cast of characters including the lead, Jo Beckett, and an extremely eerie villain. Jo’s character is well-developed with the aid of some flash-back scenes that contribute to rather than detract from the progression of the plot. She has just the right mix of strength and vulnerability to engage the reader. The plot is interesting, has plenty of twists and turns, and comes to a compelling conclusion.
Recommendation:You couldn't go wrong with it.

space_and_sorcery's review against another edition

adventurous dark emotional mysterious tense medium-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix
• Strong character development? It's complicated
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.5

 

Sometimes it’s not such a good idea to go back to the earlier works of an author whose novels I enjoyed, and that proved to be the case with Meg Gardiner, whose Unsub series has been one of my best finds in the thriller/mystery category.  Since I enjoyed those books very much, while I was waiting for the fourth Unsub novel to come out I decided to give The Dirty Secrets Club a look, but sadly it did not compare with Gardiner’s later efforts, even though it was a swift, reasonably entertaining read.  It’s clear that in the nine years between this book and the first Unsub novel the author honed her skills considerably, so I guess I will limit myself to her newest offerings in the future. 

 

The main character in The Dirty Secrets Club is Jo Beckett, a forensic psychiatrist: her job is to examine the personality and life of the victims of equivocal deaths, to shed some light on the circumstances that brought them to their demise.  Jo is quite similar to Gardiner’s other heroine, Caitlin Hendrix, in that she is a mixture of strength and vulnerability, and very determined in her chosen profession - there is a grievous personal tragedy in her past that often weighs on her mind, and she still suffers from the claustrophobic effects of having been trapped in a car during a past earthquake, but her resolve in not letting these problems affect her and her work is indeed one of her most admirable characteristics. 

 

At the start of the novel, Jo is called by San Francisco PD Lieutenant Amy Tang to help in the investigation of a string of murder/suicides that seems to be targeting some of the most notable individuals in the city: a fashion designer blew up his boat, killing himself and his lover; a famous surgeon died of a suspicious heart attack after his son succumbed to a drug overdose; and more recently a US attorney launched her car from an overpass, killing herself and the passengers of a passing vehicle, and seriously wounding her assistant.  At the scenes of these events are often present baffling words like “Pray” or “Dirty” and no one is able to understand the reason why these people, who had everything to look forward to in life or career, choose to end their existence in such a publicly dramatic way. 

 

With the latest suicide, that of a sports star who dived from the Golden Gate Bridge, Jo and the police stumble on the existence of the Dirty Secrets Club: its members are prominent figures of society who enlist by revealing their most troubling, most damning secrets, the thrill of discovery probably offset by the conviction of being untouchable due to their position.  Someone is however targeting the members of the club, someone with a powerful grudge and a driving need for vengeance, and soon enough Jo will find herself enmeshed in this mysterious person’s plots…. 

 

As I said at the start of this review, The Dirty Secrets Club does not compare, both narratively and character-wise, with the author’s more recent novels, although I have to admit that the story is an engaging one and the need to understand the mystery at its roots is a powerful motivator to keep on reading, but unfortunately the plot is a bit confusing at times and is burdened by some long expositions that at times hobble the pace, particularly toward the end when the Bad Guy falls prey to the trope-y compelling need to Tell Everything Before The End, which to me often robs of any drama what should be a tense situation. 

 

Still, the story remains a reasonably compelling one and Meg Gardiner’s writing - even in these earlier stages of her career - takes you along for the ride with little effort, which proves to be a great help in suspending one’s disbelief at the more eye-rolling plot instances.   Certainly this was not my favorite pick from this writer’s production, but it was an… honest story - for want of a better word - and one I don’t regret reading at all. 

 

 

denaiir's review against another edition

4.0

I really enjoyed Jo Beckett's backstory, even though the plot of this one was not one of my favorite topics. I'm excited to read the next one

alifromkc1907's review against another edition

5.0

Gut Instinct Rating: 5
Characters: 4.5
Believability: 5
Uniqueness: 4
Writing Style: 5
Excitement Factor: 4.75
Story Line: 5
Title Relevance: 5
Artwork Relevance: 4
Overall: 4.69

bxermom's review against another edition

4.0

I'm so glad I finally got a chance to finish this! I was a bit unsure when I started it. I didn't think it was a book that I would want to finish. It really picked up after the beginning chapters and had a great ending. I think I will try another one of her books.

jajorgen's review against another edition

4.0

This is the second Gardiner book I've read (after seeing the column about her written by Stephen King). I agree with him that Gardiner really knows what she's doing. Her protagonists are interesting and she's got the suspense pacing down perfectly. In this one the investigator, Jo Beckett, is a forensic psychiatrist. She's called in when a death can't be easily identified as suicide, murder, or accidental.

I liked Jo, who has the expected painful backstory but who isn't wallowing in it. She goes about her business with common sense and intelligence and I look forward to seeing more of her. If there's a weakness here it's in the free-hand she's given by the police. Her gathering evidence and interrogating suspects struck me as a little off given the nature of the death, though Gardiner does just enough to make it mostly plausible.

megmcardle's review against another edition

2.0

This was pretty disappointing to me. I hate when authors use their setting as a gimmick. I was hoping for some good SF scenery in this novel, but instead the author only set the book here to be able to have an earthquake in the plot. And not just one earthquake (at a key plotting moment), but another one later on as well! Not believable and not very compelling.

sandi67's review against another edition

4.0

Jo Beckett #1

eternan's review against another edition

adventurous challenging dark mysterious tense fast-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? Plot
• Strong character development? Yes
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5