Scan barcode
guardachuva's review
reflective
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
Content Warnings
Moderate: Animal death, Child death, and Sexual violence
bunnieslikediamonds's review against another edition
3.0
Marnie the book is darker and more complex than Marnie the movie, and so is Marnie the character. Hitchcock's depiction of the traumatized Marnie always seemed icky to me, and Sean Connery as her husband is the most loathsome Hitchcock character ever. Really, I'd rather date Norman Bates. The basic premise is the same in the book as in movie: pretty con artist Marnie is caught stealing from her employer by a widower who has fallen in love with her. He blackmails her into marrying him, but alas, to his horror she turns out to be frigid. Surprisingly, raping her doesn't help, so he starts investigating her past. Winston Graham's book, while dated, tells the story from Marnie's point of view, creating a more sympathetic character. She may be a liar and a thief, but somehow that doesn't seem so bad compared to her blackmailing rapist husband. The ending is much better than in the movie.
caramels's review against another edition
3.0
“You’re a strange creature. The strangest I’ve ever met”
anatrnd's review against another edition
slow-paced
3.0
головна героїня, Марні, постійно змінює своє ім'я і переїжджає після того, як вчергове вкраде гроші зі свого тимчасового місця роботи. але одного разу закоханий у дівчину власник друкарні, в якій вона працювала, знаходить її і обіцяє нікому нічого не розповідати про вкрадену суму, якщо Марні вийде за нього заміж.
відразу видно, що книжка стара, тому що в наш час цифрових технологій сумніваюсь, що Марні змогла б настільки легко втікати від відповідальності. але мені було трохи нудно не через це. книжка занадто довга: і зав'язка, і переживання Марні в середині історії, і навіть кінцівка затягнуті. а ще мене розчарувало те, що книжку всюди подають, як трилер, але насправді це психологічно-кримінальний роман зі слабеньким відлунням трилеру.
найцікавішою особисто для мене була якраз психологічна сторона історії, переживання sex repulsed Марні (впевнена, що вона ароейс, representation matters!), її прийоми в психіатра, ставлення чоловіка до жінки і тд.
не впевнена, що комусь пораджу цю історію, якщо мене просто запитають якісь книжкові рекомендації, але, загалом, мені сподобалось, і я могла рілейтнутись до Марні, а я люблю відчувати такі емоції при прочитанні.
відразу видно, що книжка стара, тому що в наш час цифрових технологій сумніваюсь, що Марні змогла б настільки легко втікати від відповідальності. але мені було трохи нудно не через це. книжка занадто довга: і зав'язка, і переживання Марні в середині історії, і навіть кінцівка затягнуті. а ще мене розчарувало те, що книжку всюди подають, як трилер, але насправді це психологічно-кримінальний роман зі слабеньким відлунням трилеру.
найцікавішою особисто для мене була якраз психологічна сторона історії, переживання sex repulsed Марні (впевнена, що вона ароейс, representation matters!), її прийоми в психіатра, ставлення чоловіка до жінки і тд.
не впевнена, що комусь пораджу цю історію, якщо мене просто запитають якісь книжкові рекомендації, але, загалом, мені сподобалось, і я могла рілейтнутись до Марні, а я люблю відчувати такі емоції при прочитанні.
boxcar's review
dark
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
an extremely dark book with no lovable characters, only characters that are far less worthy of hate than others. Lots of gut wrenching surprises.
sewingdervish's review against another edition
3.0
I enjoyed this, I found it more believable than the film. No woman can freak out every time they see red! It also seems to me that Marnie has more legitimate reason to be messed up in the book. It's a 3.75 stars for me.
paperbackstash's review against another edition
4.0
“People might think it lonely living on my own nearly all the time, but I never found it lonely. I always had plenty to think about, and anyway maybe I'm not so good on people.”
A fascinating psychological train-wreck. I'd seen the movie several times growing up since Alfred Hitchcock was behind the helm - and it stuck in my mind while reading the story so I can't help comparison. It followed a lot of the book faithfully, although the ending was completely different, as was her hidden trauma, and there lies some of the weakness of the story that dropped it to a four star rating over five. I'm sure I would feel the same even if I didn't see the film.
Marnie isn't exactly a likable character. She has redemption at the end but her heart of stone only thaws so much, and the author kind of abruptly cuts the story off at the end. I'd had loved to see the scene where she came back to Mark and he knew it, and to see where they went from there, and where she told him - and/or- the doctor all she'd discovered, but as a reader I kind of feel cheated of that. I only like unknowns looming ahead if it adds spice to this story, but the way the ending handled itself frustrated me.
Still the book is difficult to put down. The beginning is especially potent when Marnie is going through the motions as thieving Mary, then is discovered, then answers and fields questions from both Mark and the doctor. Mark as a character is a shining gem- the patience and tragedy of the man was maybe more depressing to me than Marnie's mental struggles.
The book is almost 400 pages, and you'd think a lot of shifting scenes may be needed to keep it interesting - but it doesn't need that for the pacing doesn't suffer. Winston Graham's writing style is perfect for this type of story and even the dialogue shifting when Marnie is regressing was well-done. It's first person POV and surprisingly well-done. I may have to hunt down more of this author's work.
It was interesting to be in the head of a thief like this too. Thieving is despicable, but there are different forms of that addictive madness so they can still be intriguing to read about. Toss in psychological horrors and hidden secrets, and it gets even better.
Even if the ending is a little frustrating, when I started it yesterday I've found it difficult to put down, the writing got to me, and the characters are well-done and absolutely different from the norm. Worth a read if you find a copy or pick up the e-book copy. And then, if you haven't already, you need to watch the movie at some point - despite some melodrama of the time, it's another unique and twisted take on the story, adding a completely different ending and color blindness being part of the psychological trauma.
A fascinating psychological train-wreck. I'd seen the movie several times growing up since Alfred Hitchcock was behind the helm - and it stuck in my mind while reading the story so I can't help comparison. It followed a lot of the book faithfully, although the ending was completely different, as was her hidden trauma, and there lies some of the weakness of the story that dropped it to a four star rating over five. I'm sure I would feel the same even if I didn't see the film.
Marnie isn't exactly a likable character. She has redemption at the end but her heart of stone only thaws so much, and the author kind of abruptly cuts the story off at the end. I'd had loved to see the scene where she came back to Mark and he knew it, and to see where they went from there, and where she told him - and/or- the doctor all she'd discovered, but as a reader I kind of feel cheated of that. I only like unknowns looming ahead if it adds spice to this story, but the way the ending handled itself frustrated me.
Still the book is difficult to put down. The beginning is especially potent when Marnie is going through the motions as thieving Mary, then is discovered, then answers and fields questions from both Mark and the doctor. Mark as a character is a shining gem- the patience and tragedy of the man was maybe more depressing to me than Marnie's mental struggles.
The book is almost 400 pages, and you'd think a lot of shifting scenes may be needed to keep it interesting - but it doesn't need that for the pacing doesn't suffer. Winston Graham's writing style is perfect for this type of story and even the dialogue shifting when Marnie is regressing was well-done. It's first person POV and surprisingly well-done. I may have to hunt down more of this author's work.
It was interesting to be in the head of a thief like this too. Thieving is despicable, but there are different forms of that addictive madness so they can still be intriguing to read about. Toss in psychological horrors and hidden secrets, and it gets even better.
Even if the ending is a little frustrating, when I started it yesterday I've found it difficult to put down, the writing got to me, and the characters are well-done and absolutely different from the norm. Worth a read if you find a copy or pick up the e-book copy. And then, if you haven't already, you need to watch the movie at some point - despite some melodrama of the time, it's another unique and twisted take on the story, adding a completely different ending and color blindness being part of the psychological trauma.