Scan barcode
callienicole's review against another edition
4.0
Oh my goodness, this book. If it wasn't for a few content issues it would have for sure received five stars from me. I really liked it.
This book starts right away with a plane crash and two castaways on a desert island, and follows them through their journey to survive together. If that premise doesn't grab you, I don't know what will.
I really loved the way this book was written. The narrator is omniscient, and certain chapters flip to background information on the castaways and their lives pre-plane crash, as well as histories of the island they are stranded on. I thought this was really very well done. The writing was excellent, and the characters were developed so well, but the plot itself was also very gripping. When I had to put this book down I was still thinking about it, and those kind of stories are always fun.
Now for content issues, because as a Christian, when reading secular books I like it best when I know upfront what I might be getting into, and I figure a lot of you like to know that too...
Language: I was pretty annoyed because Jesus's name is taken in vain throughout this book as the cuss word of choice. I hate that. Various uses of other cuss words, and four or five (?) uses of the f-word. Overall, less bad language than some books I've attempted to read, but certainly enough to disappoint me.
Sexual content: The castaways' clothes are ruined pretty early on, so there are some matter-of-fact descriptions of nudity (of course, we can't have fully clothed castaways *eye roll*). There is a sexual encounter that, while not completely explicit, was explained enough that it did make me squirm and required skipping a couple paragraphs.
Spiritual: This book is quite secular. It did mention "destiny" or "the gods" (little "g"). The characters shoot up prayers to some deity that they don't know. I found that aspect depressing.
Other thoughts: Despite the lack of recognition on the part of the characters of any divine help, the overall tone of this book was hopeful. What could have been a really bleak, depressing plot line is instead the backdrop for a sweet love story. It was also surprisingly optimistic about life in the womb, and I personally loved that aspect. I'm one who likes my endings a little happier than the way this one ended, but the bittersweet tone fit the rest of the book. I recommend it with hesitation because of the content complaints above, but if you are looking for a good story with good writing, this is one to check out.
This book starts right away with a plane crash and two castaways on a desert island, and follows them through their journey to survive together. If that premise doesn't grab you, I don't know what will.
I really loved the way this book was written. The narrator is omniscient, and certain chapters flip to background information on the castaways and their lives pre-plane crash, as well as histories of the island they are stranded on. I thought this was really very well done. The writing was excellent, and the characters were developed so well, but the plot itself was also very gripping. When I had to put this book down I was still thinking about it, and those kind of stories are always fun.
Now for content issues, because as a Christian, when reading secular books I like it best when I know upfront what I might be getting into, and I figure a lot of you like to know that too...
Language: I was pretty annoyed because Jesus's name is taken in vain throughout this book as the cuss word of choice. I hate that. Various uses of other cuss words, and four or five (?) uses of the f-word. Overall, less bad language than some books I've attempted to read, but certainly enough to disappoint me.
Sexual content: The castaways' clothes are ruined pretty early on, so there are some matter-of-fact descriptions of nudity (of course, we can't have fully clothed castaways *eye roll*). There is a sexual encounter that, while not completely explicit, was explained enough that it did make me squirm and required skipping a couple paragraphs.
Spiritual: This book is quite secular. It did mention "destiny" or "the gods" (little "g"). The characters shoot up prayers to some deity that they don't know. I found that aspect depressing.
Other thoughts: Despite the lack of recognition on the part of the characters of any divine help, the overall tone of this book was hopeful. What could have been a really bleak, depressing plot line is instead the backdrop for a sweet love story. It was also surprisingly optimistic about life in the womb, and I personally loved that aspect. I'm one who likes my endings a little happier than the way this one ended, but the bittersweet tone fit the rest of the book. I recommend it with hesitation because of the content complaints above, but if you are looking for a good story with good writing, this is one to check out.
emeraldjulep's review against another edition
emotional
hopeful
reflective
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
*Audio
*Narration was great and I think added to my enjoyment of the book
*Narration was great and I think added to my enjoyment of the book
erinwea's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.25
Interesting concept but could have been better. The French was a little annoying, as others have said.
Am I the only one bugged by the constant mention and care of his contacts?! And they lasted 2 years??
Am I the only one bugged by the constant mention and care of his contacts?! And they lasted 2 years??
blueberry's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
sad
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
4.0
shareen17's review against another edition
4.0
At first this book seems like it's going to be very similar to the movie Cast Away. It's about two people who survive a plane crash and find themselves on a remote desert island. It becomes a look at what makes a meaningful life.
jordanwilde's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
I can honestly say I was emotionally involved with the characters from start to finish. At its core, it's a survival story. The author allows you to connect with the characters on their own, and reminds us why we keep rooting for them. At first I felt like the book was missing a huge plot point at the end, but really it's not. I think that comes from me wanting it to end differently, but alas, that's not the story.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death and Child death
Minor: Suicide
booksconnectus's review against another edition
4.0
I really enjoyed this book-devoured it, actually. At first I thought it was nothing like I usually read and that perhaps I wasn't going to like it-but I did and I wanted more after the last page was turned. I only gave it 4 stars instead of 5 because I needed to know how the ending came about...but maybe I need to go back and re-read a bit....I know I am being really vague here-but I do not want to give anything a way. This book was everything-a bit of mystery, lots of humor, a love story, survival story and really good, easy prose.
csbooklove's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
inspiring
reflective
sad
medium-paced
3.75
This book is a different style and tone than I’m used to reading. In the beginning, it was almost hard to get into. I kept waiting for some hook to draw me in that wasn’t coming, but I felt like I needed to keep pushing forward, rather than give up on it. Soon I found myself immersed in this story. I think it’d be easy for me to discredit the book because of its unique style, because everything isn’t laid out perfectly and wrapped with a little bow. I came to appreciate the style and format in which the story was told, and feel like what wasn’t written and given to the reader was just as important as what was. Certainly this won’t be a book for everyone, but I’m definitely glad I got the chance to read it.
colpenbewley's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.75
novelvisits's review against another edition
4.0
Original Source: https://novelvisits.com/castle-of-water-by-dane-huckelbridge-review/
{My Thoughts}
What Worked For Me
Begins at the Ending – I always like a story that starts with the end as Castle of Water did. In the very first chapter we see a man going to a grave and leaving a bunch of bananas there. It doesn’t take long to realize who that man was, but the question of what he’s doing, and why, lingers throughout the story. As a reader, you know this is where you’ll end up and in this story that worked especially well.
Easy to Like Characters – I don’t need to like characters in order to love a book, but it’s always a nice addition when I do. Both Barry and Sophie, our stranded couple, were easy to like. Sophie had a biting quality to her in the beginning, as one would expect after the shock of a plane crash, losing a husband while on her honeymoon, and coming to realize they were truly alone.
“Right then and there, the trapdoor on both their lives clicked and fell out from under them. A brief, sinking sensation, and then the cold thump of reality. No one was looking for them. Not one boat, not one soul.”
Barry was a little inept and nerdy. Both grew as individuals and a team as day, after day, after year on the island progressed.
Side Stories That Work – Oftentimes side stories can drag the main storyline down, but in Castle of Water Huckelbridge’s only added to his overall plot. I especially loved a running storyline that had Barry and Sophie alternately telling the other a fictional account of what their life might be like off the island. It highlighted the people they had grown into being.
Great Narration – I loved the voice of the narrator in this book. There was just something so mater-of-fact about the way the story was told. I loved that element!
What Didn’t
A Lot of Unlikely Coincidences – The book did require you to do a little suspending of disbelief. Barry and Sophie benefitted from some unlikely coincidences, like the fact that centuries ago, Polynesians had used their atoll as a stopping place on long journeys. Those Polynesians had conveniently planted coconut and banana trees on the island and had seeded the nearby lagoon with clams. Sophie had had survival training at the feet of her grandfather, and Barry operated a shortwave radio as a child. And the biggest one of all? The one little Bic lighter, after three years it was still working!
{The Final Assessment}
It was easy to breeze past the minor flaws that made island life possible for Barry and Sophie and to instead focus on the people they were and the relationship they developed. Yes, the book was a little on the sappy side, but you know what? There’s room in the world for a sappy love story every now and again. Castle of Water was a really lovely, easy, fast read. We all need that sometimes!
{My Thoughts}
What Worked For Me
Begins at the Ending – I always like a story that starts with the end as Castle of Water did. In the very first chapter we see a man going to a grave and leaving a bunch of bananas there. It doesn’t take long to realize who that man was, but the question of what he’s doing, and why, lingers throughout the story. As a reader, you know this is where you’ll end up and in this story that worked especially well.
Easy to Like Characters – I don’t need to like characters in order to love a book, but it’s always a nice addition when I do. Both Barry and Sophie, our stranded couple, were easy to like. Sophie had a biting quality to her in the beginning, as one would expect after the shock of a plane crash, losing a husband while on her honeymoon, and coming to realize they were truly alone.
“Right then and there, the trapdoor on both their lives clicked and fell out from under them. A brief, sinking sensation, and then the cold thump of reality. No one was looking for them. Not one boat, not one soul.”
Barry was a little inept and nerdy. Both grew as individuals and a team as day, after day, after year on the island progressed.
Side Stories That Work – Oftentimes side stories can drag the main storyline down, but in Castle of Water Huckelbridge’s only added to his overall plot. I especially loved a running storyline that had Barry and Sophie alternately telling the other a fictional account of what their life might be like off the island. It highlighted the people they had grown into being.
Great Narration – I loved the voice of the narrator in this book. There was just something so mater-of-fact about the way the story was told. I loved that element!
What Didn’t
A Lot of Unlikely Coincidences – The book did require you to do a little suspending of disbelief. Barry and Sophie benefitted from some unlikely coincidences, like the fact that centuries ago, Polynesians had used their atoll as a stopping place on long journeys. Those Polynesians had conveniently planted coconut and banana trees on the island and had seeded the nearby lagoon with clams. Sophie had had survival training at the feet of her grandfather, and Barry operated a shortwave radio as a child. And the biggest one of all? The one little Bic lighter, after three years it was still working!
{The Final Assessment}
It was easy to breeze past the minor flaws that made island life possible for Barry and Sophie and to instead focus on the people they were and the relationship they developed. Yes, the book was a little on the sappy side, but you know what? There’s room in the world for a sappy love story every now and again. Castle of Water was a really lovely, easy, fast read. We all need that sometimes!