Scan barcode
rags1709's review
mysterious
relaxing
slow-paced
3.25
This cozy mystery had a charming cast of characters, and the overall tone felt very inviting. However, the pacing was a bit slower than I typically prefer, and with so many introductions, it took a while for me to fully connect with the story. If you enjoy relaxed mysteries with a focus on character development, this could be a great choice! Unfortunately, for me, it wasn't quite the perfect fit.
laurenla's review
challenging
3.5
Kate Atkinson is a wonderful writer, but dealing with Brodie is maybe a contractual agreement? She’s gone meta here and not in the way of her earliest books. Fans of the series (like me) will read this, set your expections.
annemariewhelehan's review
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
I so wanted to enjoy this book having been a big fan of the earlier books.
Firstly, the first half overwhelmed me with characters and nothing was really happening.
Secondly, there were huge tranches of the book that were simply overwritten. I resorted to just reading first line of many paragraphs. It’s not often I read a book and wonder why the editing wasn’t stronger.
Thirdly, too many characters, and complicated with more fictitious characters from the murder mystery game. Did we really need the vicar and his flashbacks to pilgrimage walks of yesteryear?
The bits I enjoyed most (including the detail) were when Brodie was involved. But perhaps Brodie needs to retire from his career and let’s focus on Reggie?
Gifted. Publishing on 24 August, I read a Digital advance copy from Penguin Random House.
More...