Reviews

One-Third Nerd by Gennifer Choldenko

mehsi's review

Go to review page

4.0

I received this book from the publisher/tour host in exchange of an honest review.

I was so very excited when I got the confirmation that I was accepted for the tour and was scheduled for a review/excerpt. This book has been on my Eep-2019 for some time, so you may just imagine my delight (yes, I was bookshimmying).

Oh, and then I opened the ecopy and found out that this author also wrote the Al Capone series, I read two in that series and liked them both. So my excitement was upped even further. Now I really couldn't wait to read this book.

And this book was such a fun one! Liam, the big brother, Izzy, his little sister who has Down Syndrome, Cupcake the Dog who has a problem, their divorced parents who try to take care of them. OH yes, Dakota. We don't talk about Dakota. This is a positive area, an area of happiness and joy. Dakota doesn't fit in there. But, yes, she sadly exists and was the reason why this book isn't a 5 stars, but instead a 4.

I just adored Izzy, she was a sweetie and I loved how while she didn't always have the words, she always was there with hugs and love. She was just one big positive bundle of joy. She even hugged the angry neighbour next door, and she did things that other characters wouldn't have done but that were absolutely the sweetest. She even helped out her siblings when they needed help, it was adorable how she tried to explain what she meant, and how eventually they understood.

Liam was just the best, though I did feel sorry for him at times. He didn't have an easy life at times, which was mostly to blame to a certain person we aren't going to name in this positive space. I loved how he allowed Izzy to be part of the club just because she got all sparkly at seeing that beautiful pink bracelet, and how he sat down with her to explain things to her in a soft way so that she wouldn't be too upset. He also helped out with the club of kids like Izzy. Making up a song, including all of them, being so sweet and understanding. He brought a smile to me at so many moments in the book.
I hope he can be a bit more honest about where he lives though. That was also something that was mentioned quite a few times. He has made a new friend, but he is afraid that person would judge him if he saw his house. I did love the friendship between him, his old friend, and his new friend. They made quite the trio.

Then there is Cupcake. An adorable dog with a big problem... She is peeing everywhere. Is there something big happening or is it the medicines she uses? Sadly, our characters don't have the money to go to the vet any more. I found the prices ridiculous. Who the hell can pay 3k for a treatment? I know I never would be able to do that.
So most of this book is Liam, Izzy, and She-who-will-not-be-named, try to make money in various ways to help out their dog. Most of the ideas were just dumb, but there were a few that made me happy. I could have thought of a few more ideas of things they could have done. Like doing groceries for those less-abled/eldery, selling cupcakes/lemonade, making things and selling those.

There are also many many illustrations that warmed up my heart even further. Then again, Églantine Ceulemans is one of my favourite illustrators, she draws so well.

All in all, I loved this book, and I would recommend it. Just ignore the one we shall not name in this positive and happy place.

Review first posted at https://twirlingbookprincess.com/

nicolemhewitt's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This review and many more can be found on my blog: Feed Your Fiction Addiction

One-Third Nerd is a heartwarming middle grade story about a typically atypical family just trying to get by. I say typically atypical because, let’s face it, in today’s world very few families fit the standard nuclear family mold. Liam’s parents are divorced and they struggle financially. His youngest sister has Down’s Syndrome and his other little sis is brilliant (but maybe a bit of a handful). I think that Chodenko captured the family dynamic well. None of them are perfect, but they love each other and they’re doing their best.

Liam is sometimes self-conscious about his apartment and his brainy sister’s antics (she’s 100% nerd—perfect for her, but not great as far as Liam’s concerned). He’s especially concerned about how he looks to the new kid, Moses, who he thinks has it all together (especially since Moses is a superstar at tennis, Liam’s sport). To top everything off, the family dog is sick and has been peeing all over the house, and the landlord says they have to solve the problem or get rid of their beloved pet. Liam’s little sister isn’t about to let that happen so she puts her brain power toward saving her. Along the way, Liam starts to see his sister in a new light (at least a little) and he learns that maybe he doesn’t have to try to impress Moses—he’s just a kid looking for a friend. This is the type of middle grade where everything is tied up in a neat little bow, which might feel trite to some adult readers, but will probably go over well with the younger middle graders the book was written for. Overall, it’s a sweet story that will teach kids about the power of family, friendships, and not giving up.

***Disclosure: I received this book from the publisher via NetGalley and Rockstar Book Tours in exchange for an honest review. No other compensation was given and all opinions are my own.***

spiffysarahruby's review

Go to review page

3.0

This was cute.

megmro's review

Go to review page

3.0

Three siblings, whose parents have recently divorced, deal with their changing domestic and financial circumstances. Centers around their attempts to come up with enough money to take their dog Cupcake to the vet, or else lose her forever. The middle sister is neurodivergent, compounding the older brother’s frustrations.

Happy ending, but frustrating sister actions throughout, which aren’t properly resolved for the reader. You sort of end up hating her. Also, the Mom is super passive. Both the parents seemed kinda lame to me.

ashleyaewert's review

Go to review page

4.0

This super relatable story had me laughing! Sibling love, parents of divorce, pesky landlords and forty-seven chromosomes all working together to keep their dog Cupcake from having to find a new home.

jengennari's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Another page-turner adventure from Choldenko! Everyone is lovable in this story, including the leaky dog. I love that the storytelling focuses on the kids solving the dog dilemma without calling attention to this divorced family and the siblings' neurological differences.

demitramaria's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Cute family story that would be a great read aloud.

fernandie's review

Go to review page

3.0

Note: I received a digital review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.

cmcahill's review

Go to review page

4.0

5th grader Liam is one-third nerd, which is fine with him, but little sisters Dakota (all nerd, all the time), and super friendly Izzy are raising his percentage. Their dog, Cupcake, is having accidents in their apartment and their landlord says the dog has to go. The family can't afford to take the dog for an expensive procedure at the vet. Will the kids be able to figure out how to save Cupcake.

smsaks's review

Go to review page

funny lighthearted medium-paced

3.5