Scan barcode
sumayyaha's review against another edition
5.0
This is a great book to show children how someone with anxiety or other disorders can stuggle, in a creative-fun way. Very positive.
ria_ray's review against another edition
4.0
Worst book of the trilogy, but still find myself reading it to this day (2023)
bookph1le's review against another edition
5.0
As if my kids and I would ever miss a new Raina Telgemeier!
I've read and enjoyed all of Telgemeier's previous books, but when I heard that this one would be a memoir of her own struggles with anxiety, which started when she was in 4th and 5th grade, I was eager to read it. Anxiety can be such a hard problem to deal with, and it can be both scary and debilitating, which I know from watching people I love struggle with it. I think thanks to an increased awareness of mental health and how it affects overall health we're more aware of the problem and note it in younger kids. Having books like this that talk honestly about the problem and that don't spare any details--she's frank but not gratuitous about how her anxiety provokes some nasty digestive issues--is really important. Kids who struggle with anxiety need to know that they're not alone, and it's helpful for them to have books they can identify with and that can help them work through their own problems.
This book is also very funny, and I particularly enjoyed the author's characterization of her grandmother, who pretty much steals every panel she's in. And while the book deals with a serious subject, the tone is also lighthearted at times, which furthers the author's message that while anxiety can feel like it's taking over a person's life, there is light and hope as well.
As always, the drawings in this were appealing and lovely. Telgemeier's books are always very colorful, and there were plenty of little touches in this book that I loved ("Duck Tales! Woo-ooo!). The cartooning style is nicely done.
Plus, as a parent, I really loved the other message embedded in this book: that everyone has problems they have to deal with, and until you know a person's story, you can't fully or accurately judge them. I also liked that it encouraged kids to be open about their problems with someone they trust. The importance of this message can't be underscored, and Telgemeier never does this in a preachy or condescending way.
I'm definitely adding this book to my pantheon of fantastic middle grade graphic novels, which is an extremely robust group. As a parent trying to cultivate a couple of avid young readers, I am so grateful for the wonderful quality of books like these--not to mention reading them also happens to be an extremely enjoyable experience for this fully grown adult!
I've read and enjoyed all of Telgemeier's previous books, but when I heard that this one would be a memoir of her own struggles with anxiety, which started when she was in 4th and 5th grade, I was eager to read it. Anxiety can be such a hard problem to deal with, and it can be both scary and debilitating, which I know from watching people I love struggle with it. I think thanks to an increased awareness of mental health and how it affects overall health we're more aware of the problem and note it in younger kids. Having books like this that talk honestly about the problem and that don't spare any details--she's frank but not gratuitous about how her anxiety provokes some nasty digestive issues--is really important. Kids who struggle with anxiety need to know that they're not alone, and it's helpful for them to have books they can identify with and that can help them work through their own problems.
This book is also very funny, and I particularly enjoyed the author's characterization of her grandmother, who pretty much steals every panel she's in. And while the book deals with a serious subject, the tone is also lighthearted at times, which furthers the author's message that while anxiety can feel like it's taking over a person's life, there is light and hope as well.
As always, the drawings in this were appealing and lovely. Telgemeier's books are always very colorful, and there were plenty of little touches in this book that I loved ("Duck Tales! Woo-ooo!). The cartooning style is nicely done.
Plus, as a parent, I really loved the other message embedded in this book: that everyone has problems they have to deal with, and until you know a person's story, you can't fully or accurately judge them. I also liked that it encouraged kids to be open about their problems with someone they trust. The importance of this message can't be underscored, and Telgemeier never does this in a preachy or condescending way.
I'm definitely adding this book to my pantheon of fantastic middle grade graphic novels, which is an extremely robust group. As a parent trying to cultivate a couple of avid young readers, I am so grateful for the wonderful quality of books like these--not to mention reading them also happens to be an extremely enjoyable experience for this fully grown adult!
novelette's review against another edition
3.0
Cute story about anxiety and the ways it can affect your body
mehsi's review against another edition
5.0
A new book in the Smile series, this time upset stomachs, family, food, and more.
Ducktales Woo-ooo! This was such a wonderful read, Raina Telgemeier has done it again! The third book in the Smile series and I am happy that the series continues. This one features a whole ton of topics but once again it all works and comes together as one story. I loved reading it.
Raina's life has been good so far, but after a case of food poisoning things start to go wrong for her. The word vomit is a trigger for her to get stomach aches and almost puke. Some foods are also triggering, and then there is the stomach aches she gets which often coincide with worries and fears. I could very well understand Raina, while I don't have IBS (or maybe I do but never tested for it) I also get terrible tummy aches when I am afraid or worried or have to do something exciting/scary. I was hoping that someone would notice and help, and thankfully she gets help from a therapist who was a wonderful person. She never pushed, she just let Raina talk, only giving some key words or questions. And it helped so so much, we see that while Raina is still getting tummy aches and probably will for a long time, she is now able to calm down and think of happier things to get out of the anxiety and most of the stress. Plus, she is able to eat foods without worrying too much (I had a big laugh when she was at her friends house and tried out new foods and got totally addicted to them).
I loved the friendship between Raina and her friends.
It made me happy that the parents did that for Raina, they saw that their little girl was growing up and needed more space of her own to do her own thing. To do her homework in peace, to have a place that is quiet and silent.
I do hope that the parents make some other food than just tacos. I did think that was a bit silly, and while I do understand it slightly with each family member being picky on what they eat it won't be easy to make something, but I know families with picky eaters and the parents still make healthy and varied food.
I am so sorry, but I just laughed when Raina confessed she was going to therapy and everyone and their mother confessed to going to therapy. What the hell? I swear if I confessed this at that age to people they would have looked strangely at me. I think even now if I confessed it to people they would look at me strangely. Therapy is not something everyone and their mother does here. I guess this is a very American thing then, that everyone is in/needs therapy?
But sorry, the whole Michelle thing? It just felt wrong in my eyes, especially how things were solved. She did horrible things, she said horrible things, but instead of someone taking Raina's side or anyone's as this girl was terrible to many people, the teachers did the same as they often did here. Oh, but those poor bullies, you should be kinder to them because they have some dramatic sob story that makes it all OK. I am sorry for that girl and that her life has been like this, but that doesn't excuse her from her behaviour and I would have liked to see this better handled than the way it did in the end. Teachers should have stepped up and helped Raina (and others) more. I feel like a big part of the stress that Raina experienced could have been stopped had anyone at the school just stepped up and talked to the bully and had a good conversation that doing these things is bad.
The art was once again very fun and the style very nice.
I just flew through this graphic novel and found it well written and a fantastic read. I can't wait what is next in the Smile series. I hope we get more books about Raina.
Review first posted at https://twirlingbookprincess.com/
Ducktales Woo-ooo! This was such a wonderful read, Raina Telgemeier has done it again! The third book in the Smile series and I am happy that the series continues. This one features a whole ton of topics but once again it all works and comes together as one story. I loved reading it.
Raina's life has been good so far, but after a case of food poisoning things start to go wrong for her. The word vomit is a trigger for her to get stomach aches and almost puke. Some foods are also triggering, and then there is the stomach aches she gets which often coincide with worries and fears. I could very well understand Raina, while I don't have IBS (or maybe I do but never tested for it) I also get terrible tummy aches when I am afraid or worried or have to do something exciting/scary. I was hoping that someone would notice and help, and thankfully she gets help from a therapist who was a wonderful person. She never pushed, she just let Raina talk, only giving some key words or questions. And it helped so so much, we see that while Raina is still getting tummy aches and probably will for a long time, she is now able to calm down and think of happier things to get out of the anxiety and most of the stress. Plus, she is able to eat foods without worrying too much (I had a big laugh when she was at her friends house and tried out new foods and got totally addicted to them).
I loved the friendship between Raina and her friends.
It made me happy that the parents did that for Raina, they saw that their little girl was growing up and needed more space of her own to do her own thing. To do her homework in peace, to have a place that is quiet and silent.
I do hope that the parents make some other food than just tacos. I did think that was a bit silly, and while I do understand it slightly with each family member being picky on what they eat it won't be easy to make something, but I know families with picky eaters and the parents still make healthy and varied food.
I am so sorry, but I just laughed when Raina confessed she was going to therapy and everyone and their mother confessed to going to therapy. What the hell? I swear if I confessed this at that age to people they would have looked strangely at me. I think even now if I confessed it to people they would look at me strangely. Therapy is not something everyone and their mother does here. I guess this is a very American thing then, that everyone is in/needs therapy?
But sorry, the whole Michelle thing? It just felt wrong in my eyes, especially how things were solved. She did horrible things, she said horrible things, but instead of someone taking Raina's side or anyone's as this girl was terrible to many people, the teachers did the same as they often did here. Oh, but those poor bullies, you should be kinder to them because they have some dramatic sob story that makes it all OK. I am sorry for that girl and that her life has been like this, but that doesn't excuse her from her behaviour and I would have liked to see this better handled than the way it did in the end. Teachers should have stepped up and helped Raina (and others) more. I feel like a big part of the stress that Raina experienced could have been stopped had anyone at the school just stepped up and talked to the bully and had a good conversation that doing these things is bad.
The art was once again very fun and the style very nice.
I just flew through this graphic novel and found it well written and a fantastic read. I can't wait what is next in the Smile series. I hope we get more books about Raina.
Review first posted at https://twirlingbookprincess.com/
khloe_c1's review against another edition
hopeful
informative
inspiring
lighthearted
reflective
fast-paced
3.5
eggjen's review against another edition
4.0
This is another graphic memoir from when Raina was in the 4th and 5th grade. It details her struggles with anxiety, fear of getting sick, friend struggle and learning to talk out your problems. My 10 and 13 year old both enjoyed this one, as did I.
dariatomescu29's review against another edition
2.0
never got to this one
might as well
it was alright
might as well
it was alright