Scan barcode
heliopteryx's review
adventurous
4.0
These were all pretty good stories of far future humans living on alien planets. Screwtop has aged the best of the three, but they're all fanciful stories about big ideas and people and aliens doing good and bad things.
The Crystal Ship by Joan D. Vinge The depiction of drug usage and colonies as a way of solving overpopulation are how this story shows its age. Still, the ideas of cultural hegemony, cultural exchange, and the issues around colonialism are still relevant today.
Megan's World by Marta Randall I found this story hard to get into because the "bad guy" human character is written so comically annoying and incompetent, it's hard to stand him. But the more I read, the more I got drawn into the local alien politics that humans intruded into, and Megan herself. I very much liked the ending.
Screwtop by Vonda N. McIntyre Of the three, this one's characters felt the most real. It takes place in a prison labor camp, and we gradually learn snippets of who each character was before being sent here, and what sort of place this planet is. The ending surprised me, but in a good way.
The Crystal Ship by Joan D. Vinge The depiction of drug usage and colonies as a way of solving overpopulation are how this story shows its age. Still, the ideas of cultural hegemony, cultural exchange, and the issues around colonialism are still relevant today.
Megan's World by Marta Randall I found this story hard to get into because the "bad guy" human character is written so comically annoying and incompetent, it's hard to stand him. But the more I read, the more I got drawn into the local alien politics that humans intruded into, and Megan herself. I very much liked the ending.
Screwtop by Vonda N. McIntyre Of the three, this one's characters felt the most real. It takes place in a prison labor camp, and we gradually learn snippets of who each character was before being sent here, and what sort of place this planet is. The ending surprised me, but in a good way.
linguisticali's review
3.0
3.5 stars.
Let me preface this by saying that this book was never really going to be my thing. I'm not really into sci-fi, and even less into old sci-fi, and I don't really go in for short stories/novellas either. But I am into women writers, so here we are.
Each of these stories was better than the one before it. It's a real pity they weren't all as good as Screwtop, because then I would have enjoyed this collection a lot more. I felt that all three suffered from some overwriting and telling rather than showing, but to different extents.
I found The Crystal Ship confusing and hard to follow. I think it was going for a (heavy-handed) critique of colonialism, but its treatment of the native species mainly felt condescending (it read to me like the "noble savage" trope, set against the decadence of the spaceship dwellers) and made me uncomfortable. I didn't totally follow what was going on in this one, to be honest. It was only about 60 pages long and I still had to skim half of it to get through it.
I enjoyed Megan's World far more, and found the style and the characters much easier to engage with. It read far more like high fantasy to me, and I think it would have done well as a full-length fantasy novel. I really liked Megan herself, and I would have been interested to read what happens after the end of this novella.This is ultimately the origin story for a god, and it would be intriguing to read about how the world adapts to her.
Screwtop was far and away my favourite. It felt the most radical, particularly in how it conceptualises relationships. I'm always disappointed in sci-fi in which relationships and gender roles and other norms are somehow all exactly the same, and this was great in that respect. At the centre of this story is a family of two men and a woman, and at no stage is their triad treated as abnormal (or if it is, it's only in relation to making bonds at all in the context of the harsh prison camp). They have a loving relationship with one another that's at the heart of this whole story, and it's wonderful. Kylis is a sympathetic protagonist, and this was the only story that really involved me emotionally. I read it all in one sitting, after taking weeks to get through the first hundred pages of the book.
Let me preface this by saying that this book was never really going to be my thing. I'm not really into sci-fi, and even less into old sci-fi, and I don't really go in for short stories/novellas either. But I am into women writers, so here we are.
Each of these stories was better than the one before it. It's a real pity they weren't all as good as Screwtop, because then I would have enjoyed this collection a lot more. I felt that all three suffered from some overwriting and telling rather than showing, but to different extents.
I found The Crystal Ship confusing and hard to follow. I think it was going for a (heavy-handed) critique of colonialism, but its treatment of the native species mainly felt condescending (it read to me like the "noble savage" trope, set against the decadence of the spaceship dwellers) and made me uncomfortable. I didn't totally follow what was going on in this one, to be honest. It was only about 60 pages long and I still had to skim half of it to get through it.
I enjoyed Megan's World far more, and found the style and the characters much easier to engage with. It read far more like high fantasy to me, and I think it would have done well as a full-length fantasy novel. I really liked Megan herself, and I would have been interested to read what happens after the end of this novella.
Screwtop was far and away my favourite. It felt the most radical, particularly in how it conceptualises relationships. I'm always disappointed in sci-fi in which relationships and gender roles and other norms are somehow all exactly the same, and this was great in that respect. At the centre of this story is a family of two men and a woman, and at no stage is their triad treated as abnormal (or if it is, it's only in relation to making bonds at all in the context of the harsh prison camp). They have a loving relationship with one another that's at the heart of this whole story, and it's wonderful. Kylis is a sympathetic protagonist, and this was the only story that really involved me emotionally. I read it all in one sitting, after taking weeks to get through the first hundred pages of the book.
More...