Reviews

Elmalar Diyarı by John Cheever

bittersweet_symphony's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Cheever is a modern American writer with calm insight into the middle-class suburban life. He address themes similar to John Updike and John Irving: shadowy desires amid Victorian morals that won't seem to die, normal people who cope with routine life through unsavory fantasies, and alienation from living inauthentic lives dictated to characters by the wider American culture. Cheever has far less comical, and outsider characters facing bizarre circumstances than Irving. His characters are ordinary people, living uneventful plotlines with unique internal tensions. His characters are positively more agreeable than Updike's.

Of the ten stories included, "The Fourth Alarm", "Artemis, the Honest Well Digger", and "The Chimera" were the top performers.

brianlokker's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A friend gave me this book years ago, soon after the collection was published. For some reason I never got around to it until now. I wavered between rating it three stars or four. In the end, I'm giving it four stars, primarily for the quality of Cheever's prose. The stories themselves are uneven, I think. My favorites are probably "Artemis, the Honest Well Digger" and "The Fourth Alarm." From the latter: "I asked for a divorce. She said she saw no reason for a divorce. Adultery and cruelty have well-marked courses of action but what can a man do when his wife wants to appear naked on the stage?" What indeed? But just a typical dilemma for Cheever's characters.

kansass's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Otro cuento donde el protagonista está instalado en Italia, en este caso se trata de Ada Bascomb, un laureado poeta, obsesionado con ganar el premio Nobel. Es de las pocas veces que le he leido a Cheever hacer una alusión más o menos directa a la homosexualidad, el protagonista parece que vive la vida realmente a través de sus sueños, que es quizás cuando puede ser él mismo.

"¿Por qué él -provinciano y famoso por su sencillez- había decidido abandonar Vermont para ir a Italia? ¿Había sido una decisión de su bienamada Amelia, muerta hacia diez años? Ella solía adoptar muchas de las decisiones del matrimonio. Él, hijo de un campesino, ¿era tan ingenuo que creía que la vida en el extranjero podía agregar cierto color a sus severos comienzos? ¿O se trataba sencillamente de una actitud práctica, una evasión de la publicidad que en su propia patria había sido fastidiosa?"

fionasfiction's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

My review on Fiona's Fiction:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxBcTVn6s04
More...