Scan barcode
karambit's review
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25
Definitely a different feel from the first book + not as much focus on the action or intrigue, though I guess most of the people who love these books care more about the throuple than anything else. Don’t think the rules of the world were established very well + kept having to go back and reread to find out where they mentioned things.
Apparently every vampire in the castle could hear them smash through the stone walls but also all of their secret conspiracy talk was in the same room…and the courts are in different wings, but also they can all hear each other?? 😭 There’s a scene where Elke takes Remy to a loud place so no one can hear them speak, but then a minute later they just go back to the room and say everything they discussed in private where everyone can overhear them…So inconsequential but it was so distarcting every time it happened. Also Remy and Elke whispering in the cafeteria where presumably everyone would be able to hear them…?
The third “twist” villain just seemed like a hasty attempt to tie together the two books and was honestly not needed. I was almost moved by Remy’s relationship w/ his dad + the family scenes at the end, but it’s strange that he was even given a “redemption” in the first place when there’s a scene early on where Remy talks about how his dad is largely responsible for his sexual abuse??
I remember seeing a lot of comments talking about how Remy and Malekh don’t have a lot of connection between just the two of them, and I feel like that’d probably carry over into this. It just seems like a really wide jump from “I watched you kill my brother” to “Actually I was just horny the whole time 😋” like ?.,l,/..;’.’; Xiaodan was unconscious for so long I thought they’d bond more on their own. A lot of the foundations of their relationship in this seems to be Remy is insecure>Xiaodan/Malekh comfort Remy>they all have sex>Remy is insecure again. The focus on sex was a little funny though b/c usually idc about sex scenes but something about the way they’d go, “Omg these vampire court customs are so predatory! Btw did you know Xiaodan has a strap 🙀” made me laugh.
Wish the author had explored the themes of colonization more, b/c I think Ligaya’s story was definitely the most interesting, even if the vampires’ part in it had me a little confused.
The fanfiction vibes were about the same in this one (you could definitely see the remnants of internet speak), but it’s a fun book I guess if you don’t take it too seriously. Ending felt a little open, almost like there was going to be an epilogue and there just wasn’t. Also completely random, but I thought it was funny how there were almost no physical character descriptions for the majority of the book like what do they even look like 😭
Overall fine, thought it’d be a lot worse based on reviews. I was entertained reading it so that’s all that matters ig.
The third “twist” villain just seemed like a hasty attempt to tie together the two books and was honestly not needed. I was almost moved by Remy’s relationship w/ his dad + the family scenes at the end, but it’s strange that he was even given a “redemption” in the first place when there’s a scene early on where Remy talks about how his dad is largely responsible for his sexual abuse??
I remember seeing a lot of comments talking about how Remy and Malekh don’t have a lot of connection between just the two of them, and I feel like that’d probably carry over into this. It just seems like a really wide jump from “I watched you kill my brother” to “Actually I was just horny the whole time 😋” like ?.,l,/..;’.’; Xiaodan was unconscious for so long I thought they’d bond more on their own. A lot of the foundations of their relationship in this seems to be Remy is insecure>Xiaodan/Malekh comfort Remy>they all have sex>Remy is insecure again. The focus on sex was a little funny though b/c usually idc about sex scenes but something about the way they’d go, “Omg these vampire court customs are so predatory! Btw did you know Xiaodan has a strap 🙀” made me laugh.
Wish the author had explored the themes of colonization more, b/c I think Ligaya’s story was definitely the most interesting, even if the vampires’ part in it had me a little confused.
The fanfiction vibes were about the same in this one (you could definitely see the remnants of internet speak), but it’s a fun book I guess if you don’t take it too seriously. Ending felt a little open, almost like there was going to be an epilogue and there just wasn’t. Also completely random, but I thought it was funny how there were almost no physical character descriptions for the majority of the book like what do they even look like 😭
Overall fine, thought it’d be a lot worse based on reviews. I was entertained reading it so that’s all that matters ig.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Blood, Body horror, Death of parent, and Gore
Moderate: War, Injury/Injury detail, Sexual content, and Grief
Minor: Dementia, Fire/Fire injury, and Colonisation
takarakei's review against another edition
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.25
I’m being generous with 3.25 stars to be honest. It pains me to say that because I loved Silver Under Nightfall so much and I’ve told so many people to read it! and I still will…but as a stand-alone
The first half of this sequel wasn’t too bad, I was enjoying the banter between Remy and Malekh a lot. It was a tad spicier (still relatively closed door or just not graphic) but we do head into kink territory! The throuple relationship truly is the one saving grace in this book. However there wasn’t a ton more development persay, and there definitely wasn’t the same tension here from the first book.
I had such a hard time following this plot. There were a lot of new characters from different vampire courts introduced, but none of them felt distinct from each other so I couldn’t keep track of who was who and where their political loyalties were. It felt like there were multiple kind of plot twists (for lack of a better word) happening and the plot got really convoluted. I love political fantasies, but this was poorly done because it moved very slow and felt like a really different world almost from the first book. Idk there was a lot of new world building which seems strange for the second book in a duology.
The action scenes, which were so fun to read in the first book, in this were sparse and very quick. Every conflict seemed to be resolved too easily (this was a bit of my critique in the first book as well, but was exacerbated here). Monsters like weren’t the focus anymore??
It also definitely could’ve been at least 100 pages shorter.
And in the end his dad and mom weren’t actually bad? Like it was that the night king was ultimately at fault? I actually don’t understand it. I guess it’s nice that Remy reconciled with his dad but it didn’t necessarily feel earned?
The first half of this sequel wasn’t too bad, I was enjoying the banter between Remy and Malekh a lot. It was a tad spicier (still relatively closed door or just not graphic) but we do head into kink territory! The throuple relationship truly is the one saving grace in this book. However there wasn’t a ton more development persay, and there definitely wasn’t the same tension here from the first book.
I had such a hard time following this plot. There were a lot of new characters from different vampire courts introduced, but none of them felt distinct from each other so I couldn’t keep track of who was who and where their political loyalties were. It felt like there were multiple kind of plot twists (for lack of a better word) happening and the plot got really convoluted. I love political fantasies, but this was poorly done because it moved very slow and felt like a really different world almost from the first book. Idk there was a lot of new world building which seems strange for the second book in a duology.
The action scenes, which were so fun to read in the first book, in this were sparse and very quick. Every conflict seemed to be resolved too easily (this was a bit of my critique in the first book as well, but was exacerbated here). Monsters like weren’t the focus anymore??
It also definitely could’ve been at least 100 pages shorter.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Blood and Violence
Moderate: Child death, Dementia, Genocide, War, Sexual content, Colonisation, and Death
Minor: Abandonment, Sexual violence, and Toxic relationship
Toxic relationship/ sexual violence is talked about from a side characters past
More...