Reviews

Elementary: All-New Tales of the Elemental Masters by Ben Ohlander, Kristin Schwengel, Rebecca Fox, Elizabeth Vaughan, Stephanie D. Shaver, Tanya Huff, Jennifer Brozek, Mercedes Lackey, Michele Lang, Gail Sanders, Elisabeth Waters, Rosemary Edghill, Diana L. Paxson, Samuel Conway, Cedric Johnson, Louisa Swann, Ron Collins, Fiona Patton, Michael Z. Williamson, Jody Lynn Nye, Dayle A. Dermatis

acf151's review against another edition

4.0

I really liked how Jody Lynn Nye was able to contribute a second story with the same cast of characters from the first anthology. I'd like to see this continue with other authors, there are several very compelling characters from whom I'd like to see more; for instance, Marie from Arms of the Sea and El from The Fire's Daughter.

mousegoddess's review against another edition

4.0

Much much MUCH more coherent and cohesive than the other anthology. Enjoyed thoroughly.

pandareads41's review against another edition

4.0

enjoyed this one. I liked that some of the stories seemed like a continuation of the stories from Elementary Magic.

glennisleblanc's review

3.0

I like this universe so reading more set in it with other takes would be great. Several of the stories are set outside the usual time frame that the author has used. As with most collections there were high points and low points. It wasn't an amazing collection of stories but there is something for everyone that is a fan of the Elemental Masters books. Now to read the first collection of these stories at some point in time. Mostly to see if there is more by some of the writers I did like in the collection and if they have more with their take on it.